4 ms·
Signal (and Signal's phone number model) predates Telegram. It was designed as an SMS and WhatsApp replacement; that is, it was originally designed to replace i
by tptacek 3y ago
Signal (and Signal's phone number model) predates Telegram. It was designed as an SMS and WhatsApp replacement; that is, it was originally designed to replace insecure phone-number-addressed systems.
Obviously, the cryptographic guarantees of the two systems aren't even close to comparable.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoMay be. But that feature wasn't there since 2014. Signal has adopted a lot of "social media" feature from WhatsApp and Telegram over the years.
- tptacek 3y agoThey're messengers. They have messenger features. The details of how those features are implemented is what matter. Last I checked, Telegram doesn't even have encrypted group messaging, and it has a serverside database of who's talking to who. I don't know what "feature" you're talking about not existing until 2014, but before Open Whisper Systems, the thing we call Signal was "TextSecure", a literal SMS replacement.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>They're messengers. They have messenger features. And some are better at being messengers than others.
- tptacek 3y agoThis is true. At every point where Telegram and Signal had the choice between being a pleasant messenger experience or being secure and private, each made decisions consistent with all their previous decisions.
- tjoff 3y agoFor some definition of secure and private. Forcing you to use your phone number and then the same second you created your account go behind your back and spam everyone you just did so is neither private nor something many would associate with secure. I guess something doesn't have to be secure if you can pretend it is public. Of course Signal has carefully designed their goals to allow them to do that but in doing so that is a straight up asshole move in a context where they should be seeking trust? Absolutely mind bending. This is a great improvement, but they have already proven they can't be trusted with anyone's phone number so it is a damn shame they still won't allow you to create an account without one. It is a decent service otherwise, but my fricking god I hope they at some point realize the harm they've done. Up until today I've been ashamed of suggesting signal. Hopefully that will change with this feature.
- tptacek 3y agoMy general experience in discussing this over the last 10 years is that nerds like us generally find it absolutely mindbending when privacy services make decisions in the interests of ordinary people, such as using the phone-number-based addressing ordinary people already use in order to minimize serverside metadata. But I think it mostly just speaks to how carefully people aren't thinking about the project's goals, and the fixation they have on their own goals. A lot of people are just super angry they can't write their own TUI for Signal.
- tjoff 3y agoThat argument might have had something to stand on if: 1. Users were properly informed 2. Users were given the option to opt-out And please don't pretend being annoyed about not being able to write third party client is in the same realm, that is just disingenuous.
- tptacek 3y agoI'm pretty comfortable with how sturdy my argument is, but that doesn't mean I think you have to agree with it.
- slim 3y agoTextSecure and Redphone did not upload your contacts to the cloud. No need to be a security expert to know that it's unwise to leak user state to contacts. In fact textsecure (now Silence) is the first SMS app to have a different colors for each contact to help the user avoid mistakingly messaging the wrong person.