3 ms·
Signal: * Gives the servers virtually no control over communications between parties. * Goes through huge pains to minimize serverside metadata storage. * Is
by tptacek 3y ago
Signal:
* Gives the servers virtually no control over communications between parties.
* Goes through huge pains to minimize serverside metadata storage.
* Is a sealed system end-to-end; the client and the server are part of a single coherent design that together make promises about privacy and security that apply to every user of the system; Matrix is a protocol ecosystem.
A good example of this is group messaging: Matrix servers control group membership. In Matrix, group membership is key management; a Matrix server decides who can decrypt your group messages. That's not how Signal works! But I don't think anybody seriously thinks Signal is a replacement for a large Slack.
- fsflover 3y ago> * Goes through huge pains to minimize serverside metadata storage. And yet uses AWS: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39414322 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39414322
- tptacek 3y agoAnd? It could run on NSA servers and it shouldn't in theory much of a difference. (I would not use Signal if it ran on NSA servers). The threat model assumes attackers have maximal control of the server environment.
- baq 3y agoAssume US AWS servers are NSA servers.
- tptacek 3y agoYou get that it's the literal opposite, right? There are actual rules, whether you believe NSA follows them or not, about NSA interfering with US servers. Not only are there no rules applying to overseas servers, but interfering with those servers is literally NSA's chartered mission.
- baq 3y agoI’m not in a position to know anything except unconfirmed rumors about the NSA. Hence my position remains unmoved.
- tptacek 3y agoOk! Either way: immaterial to Signal.
- greyface- 3y agoRules historically have not been an impediment to the NSA. Worst case, they can be ignored, best case, they can be interpreted with extreme creativity. Five Eyes partners are not subject to the same rules, and information can be shared freely with them. This continued insistence (widespread - not just you!) on the benevolence and good faith of US intelligence, post-Snowden, doesn't make any sense to me.
- tptacek 3y agoYes, I agree that the rules don't mean much to NSA. Do you see why that doesn't matter in this case?
- greyface- 3y agoNo, I don't see that. I do, however, see you in the parent comment arguing that rules are what currently prevent the NSA from compromising AWS.
- tptacek 3y agoYou skipped whether you believe NSA follows them or not. Even if NSA ignores those rules, they have literally no rules about compromising foreign servers; they are required to do so, as part of their job. Take a step back and note that nobody on HN is going to make an argument premised on "you should trust NSA to follow the rules". You can accept that as an axiom and have easier conversations here.