3 ms·
Both this article and the article on Turchin himself don't pass the smell test. They both read more like opinion pieces than informative articles. Like they wer
by bena 3y ago
Both this article and the article on Turchin himself don't pass the smell test. They both read more like opinion pieces than informative articles. Like they were written by either Turchin himself or people who know him.
Contrast the article on Turchin to the one on Tim Berners-Lee (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Berners-Lee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Berners-Lee).
No wishy-washy weasel language. No vague claims of contributions, just straight up: He was here, he did this thing.
- pictureofabear 3y agoI didn't get that same feeling from reading the two articles, but Turchin's article on Elite Overproduction is relatively new and the idea is only as old as 10 years. It's a theory that's very convenient for explaining the present but seems to be grounded in past political instability, so who knows... maybe it'll stand the test of time. It is interesting though.