4 ms·
Patent Absurdity (2021)
- iancmceachern 3y agoRules I've been taught in 20 years as a R&D design engineer: 1- you are being paid to design new things, new ways. Design something how you think it should be designed until told otherwise 2- don't read patents, search for patents about what your working on, and certainly don't "design around" them. This is like sequestration of the jury in a trial, don't pollute your brain 3- let the other folks do their job, they will review your work, tell you what's novel and patentable, what's just regular, and what's not usable because it's covered by other ip and you need to do it not that way, then change those bits as needed. The R&D engineer (or dev, scientist , etc.) needs not be the patent agent, and visa versa. Edited:typo
- the_panopticon 3y agoThe triple damage is interesting. The founders like Jefferson didn't envision that punitive aspect, I imagine. Instead Thomas J wrote "He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me. That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe,..." https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12.html https://press-pubs.uchicago.edu/founders/documents/a1_8_8s12.... It's unfortunate that we have to avoid work of others and cannot easily stand on the should shoulders of giants.....
- ryukoposting 3y agoIs it worth going into patent law as an engineer? I've always been interested in this stuff and I feel like I could make a difference for the better.
- kurthr 3y agoThe best patent lawyers/examiners are engineers. You really do have to understand the patents and the technology to write/read patents well. However, it is really boring. To be paid well, you'll need to pass the patent bar exam. Being a paralegal doesn't make great money compared to an engineer. There are two paths though, one is to get a law degree, the other is to be an examiner for a few years. The lost income of being an examiner (and they're mostly remote now) is much less than the cost of a law degree. You probably won't be making the huge bucks ($1k/hr) litigating without a law degree, but you can make decent money at a lot of large tech companies. You also get to stay at the front of technology... even if the patents are REALLY BORING.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThere's a third path: be a patent agent. You're empowered to prosecute patents for anyone, and most IP firms employ one or more of them. No law degree needed. I was one of those, for about a year. It is not the same as either paralegal OR examiner. Will people pay you? Well, individual inventors will nickel and dime you, and big companies want big IP law firms. So it's tough. So yeah, it's boring, but once you've mastered it, it doesn't change that much.
- rudyfink 3y agoIf you would like to reach out, I can probably answer some things for you. But, whether it is ultimately worth it or not, is a personal decision.
- ryukoposting 3y agoI'd love to talk about it some more. Is it common to go "back to school" for this kind of thing? I'm a few years past my undergrad now. Still in my 20s, though.
- rudyfink 3y agoFeel free, my contact information is in my profile. "Back to school" in this case would, usually, mean law school, at least in the U.S. My sense is it is not uncommon for there to be a gap between undergraduate and law school. Depending on your interests and background, there are, potentially, paths for working with / around patents (some mentioned in this branch) that would not require going back to school.
- kurthr 3y agoAlthough this is generally true of Legal's recommendation to all engineering development, it is often not possible. In particular, once you start writing your own patents (or having counsel write and you approve) then you'll have to answer questions about prior art, if anything is even close. At that point you have to at least read and respond to counsel's questions about particular patents and that means reading the spec, and usually the claims to understand them. At least those conversations are privileged, but that doesn't mean you don't have to answer in court. The only reason this is really recommended is to avoid triple damages as opposed to simple damages. Depending on what you're working on, it's value and your investment, it may well make sense to look at patents... but for a large company it's usually patent lawyers working for you. In general, it's not a great idea to just go reading lots of only vaguely related patents and documenting it without purpose, because you would increase liability with minimal gain. Furthermore, if you've read a patent and then come up with a great patentable idea, they can further claim more easily that your invention wasn't novel and was obvious from combining some other art with that patent, thus invalidating it. Having a good story about how you came up with the idea is important on the stand. Patents are boring and there's risk so mostly avoid it.
- yowzadave 3y ago> In particular, once you start writing your own patents (or having counsel write and you approve) then you'll have to answer questions about prior art, if anything is even close. Yes. I have found that pursuing patents is an enormous time-suck; it is a complete distraction from actually inventing things, and should be regarded as a major risk to your productivity.
- kurthr 3y agoFiling patents may suck for you, but it's not like, BigCorp who pays your salary is going to let you out of it. If you're creating something unprotected by copyright (eg physical), and don't completely control the means of production, then not having a patent means your invention/productivity is likely worthless due to competition anyway. By the time you could have a product made, your manufacturer could simply make more and sell at a lower price those you receive nothing for. It's really common for kickstarters, and you can try splitting up the manufacture or adding little software bits to control it, but there's a reason patents on the creation of physical objects exist.
- yieldcrv 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? As you know, it's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. I seem to have noticed your comments having taken a downtick in this direction lately. That's a bad sign. If you could please recalibrate in the direction of higher quality, that would be good. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html`
- yieldcrv 3y agookay, working on it. when I post I think my comments are intended to spark introspection, are accurate, and merely lack consensus here, at the moment. the only things flagged instead of discussed are regarding things that affect disproportionately overrepresented communities here. suggests that community moderation is not impartial or that the comments arent inherently against site guidelines.
- dang 3y agoAppreciated. It seems to me that you might be confusing your intent with the effects your comments are likely to have. I believe you that your intent is to spark introspection, but when you do it with snark and flamebait (as in the GP), that's definitely not what we're going to get, in the median case. This is a common problem—most people who post flamebait comments have quite a different intent in their mind than what ends up coming across to the reader. The trouble is that the rest of us don't have access to your intent—you have to disambiguate it for us. Past explanations in case helpful: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=burden%20disambiguate%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=troll%20effects%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22expected%20value%22%20subthread&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- bbor 3y agoDoes anyone think the patent system is possibly worth saving? Perhaps some tiny shred of it? In light of the NYT copyright case (where they are clearly backed up by precedent, yet also completely at odds with human flourishing) and patent absurdities like this (these??), I really don’t see how one could possibly defend it. If there’s one thing open source and modern academia have shown, it’s that you don’t need these weird absolute arbitrary contracts to incentive R&D.
- evdubs 3y agoResearchers at the Fed agree: > The case against patents can be summarized briefly: there is no empirical evidence that they serve to increase innovation and productivity https://files.stlouisfed.org/files/htdocs/wp/2012/2012-035.pdf https://files.stlouisfed.org/files/htdocs/wp/2012/2012-035.p...
- makerdiety 3y agoSince software disproves the utility of authoritarian restraints on intellectual labor, you should only expect the defenders of patents to be incapable when it comes to physiology. Only animals with dysfunctional genetics would advocate for restrictions on vectors of progress. Naturally as a result of evolution summoning its own enemies following the destruction that years of evolution and growth orchestrates.
- bbor 3y agoI would express extreme incredulity at the argument that anyone who has different opinions than I do about intellectual property is deficient in any particular “physiological” way, especially a genetic one. For example an easy example, consider how all your favorite intellectual heroes from eras past were completely wrong about SO much - physics, astronomy, chemistry, and social ethics are common pain points. If Aristotle and Newton can be so wrong, then our opponents aren’t necessarily deficient. But also I’m being pedantic and I agree that the rise of IP laws is a natural consequence of IP having value in the first place.
- 3y ago
- bbor 3y agoMore substantively: I’m planning on using AI (grounded symbolic RAG-esque ones) and existing patent examples & instructions to help me write a patent for an AI system I’ve designed, passing it off to (non-specialized) attorney friends and family only for final glances. Does a kind hacker need denizen want to make an example of me and explain why I shouldn’t try that? The actual filing fees for “microenterprises” is low, and it doesn’t say you need to be a lawyer… plus cmon, there’s no way that “legal code” mentioned here is some impenetrable jargon. In more provocative terms: once we have agential assistants with grounded legal knowledge, i think the patent lawyer industry will get its lunch eaten by AI-assisted laymen
- D13Fd 3y agoI see a few issues: (1) One of the biggest values the attorneys add is in prosecution. Absent attorney help, there is a big risk that you'll do things during prosecution that may impact the effectiveness of the patent during any litigation. (2) Training an AI on existing patents is nice, but what you really need to do is train it on good existing patents. And you are probably not in a position to tell which ones are good. (3) Asking attorney friends and family for "final glances" is a pretty big ask. Ethically it's questionable for them to offer advice in an area they are unfamiliar with, and even more so to offer advice based on a quick glance. The "legal code" the claims are written is not impenetrable jargon at all. But, absent experience in litigation, it's hard to understand how the Court is going to construe claim language in a claim.
- bbor 3y agoThank you for the clear response - was hoping to elicit such an expert :). That all makes sense. I’m most interested in #3, as I obviously wouldn’t want to make them liable or connected to the patent in any meaningful way… will have to look into that. The hope is/was that, since this is a cheap patent taken out by a non-profit micro enterprise, the stakes are low; if it eventually gets infringed it wouldn’t be the end of the world. So in that context, I wasn’t expecting any serious liability passing to them. Also if anyone has resources for #2 I’d love to hear them :). I guess this is a huge field on its own now (I think IBM invested w/ Watson in legal research?), but I’m definitely going to try to find public datasets anyway. Or blogs, guidebooks, textbooks, etc… …something tells me the question “which patents are good” might be take a while to answer comprehensively! Better start soon, I guess.