3 ms·
>We're opening a pandora's box where a good portion of the computer's drivers are no longer running on Linux. What do you mean by this? Device drivers are stil
by charcircuit 3y ago
>We're opening a pandora's box where a good portion of the computer's drivers are no longer running on Linux.
What do you mean by this? Device drivers are still running on Linux.
>How many of the upstreaming efforts that are now underway will be undermined by folks running vendor blobs against the stable & closed Google Kernel Interface
Keep in mind that the KMI (kernel module interface) is only stable within the same LTS release. When upgrading to the next LTS there can be breakages since Linux still hasn't made a stable API for out of tree developers to use.
>instead of the changing & GPL Linux Kernel Interface
The interface is the same normal interface as any other kernel modules. It's up to the kernel module's developers if they wish to use GPL exported symbols or not.
>GKI seems like an insane threat to mainstream winning
I see it as being mostly neutral as it's goal is for being able to deliver security updates to phones by just swapping out the kernel. It's slightly beneficial in the sense that the code for the initial startup of the system has to be upstreamed since the kernel has to be able to boot far enough to get to the point where it can load vendor kernel modules.
>it's a totally parallel constructed world designed to avoid the need to mainstream
The world where there is code that can not be upstreamed already exists. GKI is about cleaning up the boundary of where upstream code lives and where third party code lives making each piece more modular.
>I'd love to see a Google Kernel Interface run on a non-Android device
As mentioned by a sibling GKI stands for Google Kernel Image and you could run it on a non Android device if you wish as it's open source including information like what version of the compiler should be used.
>& have the wrapper be ultra-coupled to Android
There is no wrapper here. There are a few additional patches to the kernel that add some hooks for vendor kernel modules to use, but kernel modules do not have to go through a wrapper.