3 ms·
The Oxford Comma and the Internet (2013)
- dang 3y agoDiscussed at the time: The Oxford Comma and The Internet - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5247718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5247718 - Feb 2013 (43 comments)
- Crespyl 3y agoIt's funny that even in 2013 people were already complaining that articles sounded like AI.
- tom_ 3y agoWorth your time, and not - I don't think - unrelated: https://www.ftrain.com/wwic https://www.ftrain.com/wwic
- robertlagrant 3y agoDang, could we change the title to "The Oxford Comma, and the Internet (2013)" please.
- Stratoscope 3y agoWhy? That wouldn't be an Oxford comma, it would be a bogus comma. The title is fine as it is.
- jinwoo68 3y agoHe was joking, I believe.
- zoky 3y ago"The Oxford, Comma, and the Internet (2013)"
- eszed 3y agoSee, now you just sound like Christopher Walken.
- Stratoscope 3y agoThere you go. Now that's an Oxford Comma!
- Stratoscope 3y agoEven though the Oxford comma has fallen out of fashion, there are a few cases where you really need it. My favorite example is the old joke: There are two hard problems in computer science: naming things, cache invalidation, and off by one errors. Leave out the comma and it makes a mess of things: There are two hard problems in computer science: naming things, cache invalidation and off by one errors. Don't take my word for it. Read both versions out loud, pausing for each comma, and not pausing where the comma was removed.
- hunter2_ 3y agoWhen reading a written work aloud: is it typical that the decision to pause before the last item is determined by the Oxford comma (or lack thereof)? Personally, I pause there regardless, for the same duration that I pause between items throughout the rest of the series.
- alistairSH 3y agoWith Oxford comma: "We invited the strippers, JFK, and Stalin." [three distinct items in the list] Without Oxford comma: "We invited the strippers, JFK and Stalin."[two named items in the list] Reading with or without the pause is natural either way. And massively changes the meaning of the sentence.
- gerdesj 3y agoI cannot see a way that those sentences do not both mean the same (nonsensical) thing involving strippers, JFK and Stalin. I think that your analysis in [] is wrong. Your second example says two named items but it still has three - strippers, JFK and Stalin.
- kergonath 3y ago> I cannot see a way that those sentences do not both mean the same (nonsensical) thing involving strippers, JFK and Stalin. This specific example is nonsensical to demonstrate the possible confusion, but this sort of confusion is really common. > I think that your analysis in [] is wrong. Your second example says two named items but it still has three - strippers, JFK and Stalin. No, in the second example, JFK and Stalin are two instances of strippers. So there are three nouns, but only two people.
- bitwize 3y agoThe Oxford comma is a must, and here's why: "The U.S. President, a racist, and a misogynist." (Barack Obama, David Duke, Andrew Tate) "The U.S. President, a racist and a misogynist." (Donald Trump)
- foobar1962 3y agoI'd write that using a colon instead of the first comma, thus: "The U.S. President: a racist and a misogynist." (Donald Trump)
- wolverine876 3y agoThat would be a misuse of the colon: The Chicago Manual (sec 6.67) advises against using it "in what would otherwise constitute a grammatical sentence", and only after an indepedent clause (though an assumed verb is allowed).
- gerdesj 3y agoFrom OP: “She lives with her two children, a cat and a dog.” The clause defines a list of type children, size of two, relationship: "her children". The correct punctuation character following a definition is usually : followed by object instantiation. Ideally we would flesh out the full structure to include "lives with" too. lol etc. However we can avoid ambiguity with: "She lives with her two children and a cat and a dog." No need for any funkiness or whatevs. Keep it simple kids! the: "... and a <thing>" idiom can be repeated as much as you like without fiddling with commas.
- wolverine876 3y agoBut what if there is a goldfish too? Someday, you'll need a comma-delimited list. The only rule is to be clear and consistent.
- CapitalistCartr 3y ago"I'd like to thank my parents, Ayn Rand and God."
- NoboruWataya 3y ago"I'd like to thank my mother, Ayn Rand, and God."
- vcg3rd 3y agoThe problem isn't the Oxford comma. The problem is lazy--or possibly rapid, if one is generous--writing and editing (if any). If the use or absence of a comma causes ambiguity, it's probably best to rewrite the sentence. I believe it was Orwell who wrote a friend: "I am sorry this letter is so long. I didn't have time to make it shorter."
- GrumpySloth 3y agoBlaise Pascal, several centuries earlier.
- gerdesj 3y agoWell, if we are going to be authoritative then we might like to ... well: "I believe it was Orwell who wrote [to] a friend: " ... soz, you are probably left pondian and have a habit of writing your friends. I like to get all transitive and write to mine.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> you are probably left pondian and have a habit of writing your friends. I like to get all transitive and write to mine. "Writing your friends" is transitive; "writing to them" is intransitive.
- wolverine876 3y ago> "Writing your friends" is transitive; "writing to them" is intransitive. Does the infinitive [edit: ^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H] made it intransitive? Also, 'writing' is a noun (a gerund), not a verb.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoYou packed a lot of confusion in there. 1. There is no infinitive in either phrase, though it is true that "writing" is a non-finite form. As you note, it is a gerund. 2. While you are correct to say that a gerund is a noun, you're wrong to say that it isn't a verb. You can clearly see that it retains the complements of the verb. A gerund is a verb cast into the syntactic form of a noun just as a participle is a verb cast into the syntactic form of an adjective. 3. A transitive verb is one that takes a direct object. An intransitive verb is any other verb. 4. "Them" is a direct object of "write" in "writing them", but an indirect object, marked by the preposition to, in "writing to them". 5. Just to be really clear, it is only possible to supply a direct object to the gerund "writing" because it is a verb that (in British usage) takes a direct object. There is no such concept as the object of a noun.
- russellbeattie 3y agoI went to college for journalism and had to memorize the AP Style Guide cover-to-cover. We got marked down for any violation of its rules in our writing, including the Oxford Comma. Repeated violations were usually mocked publicly. My lifelong avoidance of it verges on the Pavlovian. I don't think I could start using it if I tried - just the thought makes me shudder.
- wolverine876 3y ago> - I see you placed spaces around your em dash, which is the AP way. Which I'm using to segue to this completely off-topic question, because you actually know these things: I see you did not use a proper em dash (I don't judge). Does the AP Style Manual see that as an em dash, different than an en dash and from a hyphen, or is it just a dash? I don't think the Style Manual ever uses the term em dash and doesn't necessarily differentiate. What would your journalism professor say? I know, I know - who cares? I do!
- russellbeattie 3y agoGood question, but I honestly have no idea. Relooking at the sentence, I think a semicolon would probably be the most grammatical. There must be an online version of the Guide to search. Or actually, maybe ChatGPT would know.
- wolverine876 3y agoThanks. I searched an older edition of the Guide and my (lack of) results are the basis of my question; I think the current online version requires a subscription.
- murphyslab 3y ago> Throw in the Oxford comma and George has become a policeman: “Through the window she saw George, a policeman, and several onlookers”. The problem here might also be that of artificially limiting the solution to commas. We have alternative or better punctuation available to demarcate the interrupting thought. One could emphasize the relationship better either with an em dash or with parentheses: “Through the window she saw George — a policeman — and several onlookers.” “Through the window she saw George (a policeman) and several onlookers.” In text either of those could better express the different emphasis which verbally would be conveyed by a shift in the speaker's tone.
- stouset 3y agoSince we’re being pedantic, canonically you aren’t supposed to separate an em dash with spaces. I assume that’s because typographically it already sets the parenthetical somewhat farther apart than a regular space would. “Through the window she saw George—a policeman—and several onlookers.”
- wolverine876 3y ago> you aren’t supposed to In the world of grammar, these words are always a shot at your own toes. I'm missing a few myself and I learned: always specify a domain or a source. The AP Style Manual, the bible of grammer for journalism (at least in the US), says to put spaces around the dash. However, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39436513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39436513
- xeonmc 3y agoNo, there should never be spaces around Em-dashes, while for En-dashes they are situational---spaced if being used in lieu of Em-dashes, and unspaced if used as ranges (e.g. 1938--1945) or comparisons (e.g. Blue--Red Dichotomy)
- wolverine876 3y agoWhat basis do you have for saying that, and for refuting the AP Style Manual? Are you claiming it says otherwise?
- bfLives 3y agoThe fact that, at the time of writing, all of the comments on this post are about the Oxford comma rather than the actual thesis of the article goes a long way to proving its point.
- calf 3y agoMost analyses focus on ambiguity/inconsistency of ,/and with other ways to read the same sentence, but I've found it interesting to focus merely on the grammar of serial lists alone: b and c // binary operator a and b and c // associativity a, b and c // abbreviation of the first 'and' a, b, and c // thus, the ", and" is arguably redundant Starting with 'and' as a binary conjunction, the above have a sort of notational consistency in that the Oxford comma would be redundant. a, b, c // comma-separated list a, b, and c // the additional 'and' functioning as a kind of terminator/sentinel symbol, it is intentionally redundant. But starting with ',' to denote a proper sequence, the 'and' becomes redundant. It's not that redundancy is bad (redundancy can improve robustness against errors). But the above shows that even ignoring what a/b/c are children or cats or partial clauses, there are some interesting language questions to wonder about. Now I'm imagining flipping the lists around: a, and b, c, d, ... a and b, c, d, ... I find this curious..