6 ms·
OTP at a High Level (2019)
- asaph 3y agoAm I the only one who saw the title and thought OTP was "one time password"?
- andsoitis 3y agoThe domain name right along the title should give you a hint…
- tim333 3y agoGoogling OTP it Erlang comes no 9 in the results. The first three are One Time Password. I think there should be a rule to avoid unexplained abbreviations unless the meaning comes up easily in Google.
- LoganDark 3y agoNope. Should really say "Erlang OTP" or something
- Zondartul 3y agoQuoting the article: "OTP stands for _Open Telecom Platform_, which is literally a meaningless name that was used to get the stuff open-sourced back in the old days of Erlang at Ericsson."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LoganDark 3y agoThen maybe the acronym should just be expanded.
- bw86 3y agoThat would be unfitting. OTP started as "Open Telecom Platform", but today the long form is not in use anymore. To quote Wikipedia (with emphasis from me): "The name OTP WAS originally an acronym for Open Telecom Platform, which WAS a branding attempt before Ericsson released Erlang/OTP as open source." Today, OTP is the name. To avoid confusions, it would have been best to add "(Erlang)" before the title.
- Jtsummers 3y agoThe URL kind of gives away the theme of the site. And the first sentence starts with “Erlang/OTP”.
- chefandy 3y agoSure: you could just have a list of links with the text "click here" that you hover over to see the url, too. If you haven't worked in the BEAM world those terms packed into a URL might not grab your attention enough to trigger recall, and what are headlines for if not telling us what's on the other side of the click?
- fuzztester 3y ago>and what are headlines for if not telling us what's on the other side of the click? Wow, good way of putting it.
- LoganDark 3y agoSure, if I spent more than half a second deciding if I want to click something, which I usually don't. This isn't "I can't tell this is Erlang without clicking". This is "there are no obvious signs that it's Erlang without clicking".
- Jtsummers 3y ago“adoptingerlang.org” shows up on the discussion page and the HN main list. No need to click, just to read the word “erlang” that is literally right there. It’s pretty easy actually.
- LoganDark 3y agoDude, not everyone knows everything. I'd have to have run into this situation before in order to know to look for erlang in the URL here. Plus, do I ever look at the URL before I click something on HN? no. I had assumed "OTP" was so incredibly obvious that there was no need to look at the URL, that's all. > It’s pretty easy actually. Hindsight is 20/20... blaming user error is pretty cheap when my entire point is that it's easy to make user error.
- eindiran 3y agoI clicked thinking it was going to be about one-time programmable memory.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fatkam 3y agoprobably not. here is an answer from mistral-next: > "OTP" can stand for different things depending on the context. However, in the context of transportation, it commonly stands for "One-Time Password". In the context of fanfiction, it can stand for "One True Pairing". In the context of Atlanta, Georgia, OTP stands for "Outside the Perimeter", referring to the areas outside of the Interstate 285 loop that encircles the city. Please provide more context if you meant a different usage. Erlang OTP makes no sense... just like X, or Alphabet as company names
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThe article itself has a blurb that says what it stands for: > OTP stands for _Open Telecom Platform_, which is literally a meaningless name that was used to get the stuff open-sourced back in the old days of Erlang at Ericsson.
- fatkam 3y agoof course it has to, because no one knows about it... too bad they didnt use it in the title, because even with HN's highly limited title length, I think it would have fit
- butterisgood 3y agoOutlaw Techno Psomething
- bmitc 3y agoYes. OTP is engrained in my head as the One True Programming (way of building large systems).
- LorenzoGood 3y agoJust out of curiosity for anyone starting a new Erlang project: Why use Erlang over Elixir?
- mekoka 3y agoDepends on the project, but let's say you're writing something that should or could be made a part of other projects. I might be mistaken and correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it might be easier for an Erlang project to be integrated into an Elixir one than the reverse.
- Miner49er 3y agoI can speak on this a bit. I'm fairly new to Erlang, but the team I'm on has been using Erlang since before Elixir was created. So we've been doing Erlang just because it's what we've been using, and the team knows it, not Elixir. However, we recently just decided to start new projects in Elixir rather then Erlang. One argument a former team member would make against Elixir is that it has almost too many ways of doing things, in some cases. Erlang is a much simpler language. One example he used was sigils. Sure, they're nice, but it also means there's multiple ways to define a binary string, for example. Sometimes it is nice to have a single way to do something and not have to worry about making a decision about it. This example isn't great anymore though since Erlang is getting sigils in OTP 27. Another argument I can think of is that Erlang is learning from Elixir. Erlang took its maybe expression from Elixir's `with`, and, IMO, the maybe expression is better. They're also adopting sigils. But, like I said, we ended up deciding to go with Elixir for new projects, so I would be curious to see what reasons other people have for picking Erlang.
- square_usual 3y agoWhat do you think is better about the maybe expression? Just curious, haven't looked into it too deeply and I thought it behaved exactly like when.
- Miner49er 3y agoWell, I haven't written any Elixir yet, so I'm probably saying that without really knowing. The main thing, and maybe I just am missing something, but I don't really understand what the point of the 'do' in Elixir's 'with' is? In Erlang you just have the maybe and anything that would go in that do block would just go inside the maybe expression. That seems a lot better to me. I also just prefer the look of Erlang's maybe. I think maybe is a clearer name for what the statement is doing and the lack of the 'do' block looks better to me and makes it easier to read.
- crowdhailer 3y agoThis is a great series of posts. I get so used to the erlang environment I forget to share the cool bits because they become normal