5 ms·
Magnificent 7 profits exceed almost every country in the world. Should we worry?
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoTo start the conversation off with the obvious: "Magnificent 7" reads like someone satirizing CNBC. I genuinely do not believe anyone worth listening to has used this phrase unironically. Absurd.
- EchoChamberMan 3y agoFrom the article, > Magnificent 7 returned an incredible 107% over 2023, far outpacing the broader MSCI USA index, which delivered a still healthy but relatively paltry 27% to investors. If I owned those stocks, I'd say that's magnificent.
- creer 3y agoBut not for the reasons or mechanisms bandied about. The various members are magnificent for fairly distinctive reasons, meaning they seem to me run in very different manners. They have tech and valuation more or less in common - and that's about it.
- EchoChamberMan 3y agoI wouldn't say they are magnificent at all, but as a description of their production of wealth, especially in common news, it seems very fitting, considering they are 3-4x as "productive" as the alternative. I don't find the usage of magnificent "absurd" in context.
- mistrial9 3y agoreminds me of oil industry analysts using descriptions of raw petro products that sound like the names of wines
- nkurz 3y agoI agree with your sentiment, but unfortunately it's become the common term to refer to a particular group of stocks. It was semi-ironically coined last year by a Bank of America analyst who was pointing out the risks of having such a concentration in so few companies, but at this point almost everyone in the media is using it unironically. It's possible that your rule of not listening to anyone who uses it should still stand. If it helps you view it a little more positively, consider the argument that at least "Mama Ant" didn't catch on: https://www.fool.com/investing/2023/07/31/mama-ant-helps-you-recall-the-magnificent-7-stocks/ https://www.fool.com/investing/2023/07/31/mama-ant-helps-you...
- graemep 3y agoThe headline is misleading. The comparison is of profits and market cap to those of national stockmarkets, not whole countries. It does show there is a problem. The main one being that most of them do not face real competition - big tech companies can erect too many barriers to entry. The other question is whether they are overvalued at these levels. The article quotes a 107% return over 2023 in these companies. Did something happen in 2023 to make them so much more valuable? Or was the market badly undervaluing them at the start of the year?
- creer 3y agoThere are likely several problems. Such as headlines that feed obsessions. Such as comparing irrelevant numbers. Such as innumeracy. Such as easy obsessions which distract from real problems. etc, etc.
- IMTDb 3y ago> Did something happen in 2023 AI ?
- creer 3y agoSome can be called AI stories. But Apple, Tesla? Probably not.
- latency-guy2 3y agoThe US government is heavily propping up the strongest performer (NVIDIA), markets are reacting to this propping up action, and NVIDIA is reaping the benefits for being where they have always been. The other companies are also expected to do well since they implement software on top of NVIDIA's hardware. I think out of the list, only NVIDIA is overvalued given today's output and no indication of NVIDIA moving to US-only semiconductor production in my timeframe of ~5 years, but others could be looking at longer periods and justify it. Of course, I'm not an analyst whose opinion will drive buy/sell markers to anyone.
- creer 3y ago> big tech companies can erect too many barriers to entry. It's easy to complain about this. But let's also keep in mind BOTH (1) That erecting a billion-plus actual legit revenue business is NOT easy. (2) That network effects can often amplify such businesses - but that this is not a new issue: remember "nobody gets fired for going with IBM" from way back. (3) That these unstoppable giants DO actually have a short lifetime: remember AOL, myspace, Sony consumer electronics, Yahoo, DEC, HP, GE, oh right IBM, and so many others, in fact most others. So that one problem is looking at all this with a too short timeframe. In fact, NONE of these are sure bets or guaranteed ANY future. They have to keep performing. They have to keep avoiding fuckups. They will still not avoid better run, or more lucky competitors.
- seydor 3y agoSoftware, and now AI is at the top of the business pecking order. Software companies tell other companies how to run themselves, so concentration is natural. It will only get worse (or better , depending on point of view)
- creer 3y agoAI is certainly not at the top in revenue, not even close. Unless you are selling shovels (nvidia, cloud computing). It's fashionable and lots of people are betting on the potential. Remains to be seen how close and remunerative the products will be. And standalone or as middleware services, one winner or a sea of providers, etc?
- seydor 3y agoI didn't say anything about revenue. They will be at the top of the power structure, which inevitably will make them the most revenue, (like finance did before software)
- downrightmike 3y agoCompany profits are just unpaid wages.
- johngladtj 3y agoWhat a silly way to look at it. Are losses overpaid wages too?
- EchoChamberMan 3y ago"Losses" are unpaid wages too. Profit only exists if you do not fully distribute revenue, it seems to me. "Silly" - avoid swipes please.
- missedthecue 3y agoI don't think things would work as well as they do now if everything was a non-profit. I can't imagine trying to raise capital for my ideas if I had to tell investors that they would not get their money back. And I would not be able to do what I'm doing now without investors.
- downrightmike 3y agoWhat if instead of a few founders and the investors getting crazy paydays, those proceeds were paid to those who do the work, workers wouldn't need investors to buy into their ideas unless they provided a lot more value than cash. The current system is flawed in that that small group of investors drain the company of all its value and then dump it on the stock market hoping retail and index funds will pick it up. The value proposition currently sucks.
- johngladtj 3y agoThere is absolutely nothing today preventing workers from operating the way you want them to. If your system is so successful, why aren't most companies running like that?
- geonineties 3y ago
- tiahura 3y agoWho’s we? If you depend on one of those countries economies for your standard of living, probably.