11 ms·
GlobalFoundries wins $3.1B in CHIPS Act subsidies for NY, Vermont
- minroot 3y agoman, the parking lot! couldn't they make it underground?
- vitro 3y agoOr at least put solar panels on top of it. Provides electricity and shades cars. It should be a norm.
- sofixa 3y agoIt's the law in France over a certain size of parking lot, which is great.
- mschuster91 3y agoIntel in Germany is even worse. The parking lot is larger than the plant [1]! For fucks sake, large commercial (both office and industry) zones should only be permitted when the developers show a viable mass transit solution for their employees. Even if it's just buses, that's still better than thousands of cars. [1] https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/sachsen-anhalt/magdeburg/magdeburg/intel-chipfabrik-standort-eulenberg-jobs-chronik-100.html https://www.mdr.de/nachrichten/sachsen-anhalt/magdeburg/magd...
- geraldwhen 3y agoMost office complexes have parking lots larger than buildings. People are smaller than cars, commute one person to car, and buildings are often multi story where parking is not. Hence campuses that are 85% parking lot.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Hence campuses that are 85% parking lot. Yeah and that is nuts. We lose ridiculous amounts of valuable land for barely any productive use - every day Germany loses 39 ha for buildings and 8 ha for transportation infrastructure [1], which means streets and parking lots. Loss of land is an externality that doesn't get priced in anywhere. [1] https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/boden-flaeche/bodenbelastungen/bebauung-versiegelung https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/boden-flaeche/bodenbel...
- InvaderFizz 3y agoLoss of land does get priced in as prices rise with a lower supply and higher demand. It just takes a while to really feel it.
- bee_rider 3y agoI mean, they have to buy the land for the parking lot, so it does get priced in. But we should also have a Land Value Tax to push people toward using it more productively.
- vel0city 3y agoThe Land Value Tax on that site would still have been incredibly low and probably still justify paving a parking lot. It is a toxic superfund site way out in the boonies. You're not going to develop some kind of dense mixed use town center in that space anytime soon.
- raverbashing 3y agoThere probably is mass transit access to the Magdeburg plant (or the state can guarantee an expansion there) I'm thinking that "excess parking" is usually due to wanting to secure a site with enough expansion potential but also putting it to use in the most cheap way possible (like, you won't verticalize the parking until needed and that would require more planning, permits, etc)
- selimthegrim 3y agoYou should see the Jones Farm parking lots.
- edgyquant 3y agoNo we definitely should not enforce a ridiculous regulation like that. Again people like you miss the entire point by thinking everything should exist only in big cities where public transportation makes sense. We need to bring these factories back to small towns and regulations like you’re proposing completely kill that.
- mschuster91 3y ago> We need to bring these factories back to small towns and regulations like you’re proposing completely kill that. For an Amazon parcel sorter or a wholesaler distribution facility, sure, there are enough towns with desperate populations that can be exploited (and Amazon in particular is infamous for using that leverage). But a company like Intel that needs highly educated staff? They won't go to some random village hours away from civilization.
- edgyquant 3y agoThis regulation being proposed would not just effect fabs. I’m originally from southern Illinois, a place with a total of 300k people spread out over a large area. Most towns are <10k and the biggest is 40k. In this area there are a /ton/ of factories making everything from car parts and tires to books to bombs and artillery shells. Most of these factories are outside of towns and there is zero public transportation. With this in mind do you see the problem with only allowing factories to be built in places accessible to public transportation? The people making such proposals are seriously out of touch with half of the country.
- twoodfin 3y agoPeople who work at a wholesaler distribution facility don’t want the same lifestyle comforts as the highly educated? That’s a strange claim. I know lots of highly educated folks who love rural life, and blue collar workers who enjoy urban amenities.
- vel0city 3y agoHours away from civilization? This example fab is 7mi from downtown Saratoga Springs, an absolutely delightful small town. It is also <30mi from Albany and ~20mi from Troy. Loads of small towns aren't hours away from "civilization".
- vel0city 3y agoLook at Malta, NY on satellite view. Then tell me mass transit makes sense for that location. Tell me a few good bus routes that would actually make sense for people to take instead of driving their car. Not every spot on Earth is a dense urban area.
- bakchodi 3y ago[dead]
- infecto 3y agoWhy? That would probably cost many multiples more than what exists above ground. I am guessing upstate New York and where this plant is located, is not incredibly dense.
- ambrose2 3y agoI used to work there, and can confirm that there’s plenty of space there for more parking lot, there’s woods in all 4 directions and it sits on an old super fund site (former rocket fuel testing).
- jprd 3y agoWhen I worked at Malta 5y ago, that parking lot was too small. If you didn't get in at an early hour, you were parking in the gravel lots that are off this picture to the right. Combine that with the actual size of the Fab, hella lot of walking :) As for solar panels, the Fab operates 24/7/364 (usually 1 downtime day a year). Which means even with the large amounts of snow that will build-up in the winter, there are always cars in the lot - clearing that is a big job and not sure how to do it with solar panels.
- Alpha3031 3y ago> Which means even with the large amounts of snow that will build-up in the winter, there are always cars in the lot - clearing that is a big job and not sure how to do it with solar panels. I'm not sure how much sense it'll make in this specific case, but in general, interestingly, with a high albedo (e.g. snow covered or white for some other reason) ground surface, vertically mounted bifacial panels produce very close to equator facing panels with the appropriate tilt. The value of that generation might actually be greater, as it obviously spreads out the profile towards the evening peaks. For the regular horizontal/tilted ground mounts, NY is quite far north, so you're looking at a mount angle of 43° or so to optimise overall power production, and you can go about 15° more tilt and only lose maybe 1 or 2% of summer production, but increase production in winter when the sun is angled lower. If you go for like 55° to 58° tilt, there's probably not going to be very much snow accumulating on the panels themselves.
- csomar 3y ago> The GlobalFoundries expansion would create up to 1,500 manufacturing jobs and 9,000 construction jobs over the next 10 years, federal officials said. So assuming the construction jobs are temporary and the manufacturing jobs is what remains, this works out at around $2.066 million per employed personnel. Assuming a federal income tax rate of 20% and a 30 year tenure, this means the personnel should have a take home pay of $344k/year. And this is just for the scheme to break-even. I think this IRA (the act) and CHIPS act are going to be just another wealth transfer where the "work" being done just to check boxes to be eligible for the money getting sloshed around.
- ericmay 3y agoBut those employees also do things like buy cars and lattes, and they also pay state and local taxes, sales tax, etc. as does the foundry. There are other economic benefits too. But even if your simple calculation was correct and all there was to this story, what you’re missing in your post is that America as a nation has decided we need to produce semiconductors here for economic and national security purposes and so therefore subsidizing their manufacture is a normal thing that would occur.
- gosub100 3y agothey would buy cars, lattes and pay tax on non-subsidized jobs, too. Why should the latte shop owner have to pay tax to run their business, while the chip mfg doesn't? it just creates two classes of people. > America as a nation has decided we need to produce semiconductors here for economic and national security purposes a few decades ago we decided to move manufacturing jobs overseas because paying people who had families and bought "cars and lattes" here was just too expensive. Why reneg on that commitment?
- ericmay 3y ago> they would buy cars, lattes and pay tax on non-subsidized jobs, too The point here was that your assumption of the economic effects of the subsidies didn’t include other meaningful factors.
- 802er 3y ago>Schumer said the deal includes a commitment from GlobalFoundries to continue to provide a $1,000-per-employee annual subsidy for childcare and to extend the benefit to construction workers who build the new plant. So pacing inflation on the cost of childcare? What a joke. Childcare in Vermont is ranging between $15,000-$25,000 per year among families I know. That subsidy covers less than a month. As the largest private employer in Vermont I think they can do more than that. It’s not like they pay well. I see on their advertisements that night shift operators are paid 21.93 hourly with a shift differential. So day shift makes even less. Looks like shifts are 7 to 7 am and pm night and day. What a schedule. It’s one thing if you’re a nurse making at least low six figures. But this? Grueling manual labor in those suits for twelve hours a day for a sub livable wage in Vermont and New York. https://livingwage.mit.edu/states/50 https://livingwage.mit.edu/states/50
- verdverm 3y agoI worked the overnight there when IBM still owned it, it was 4/4-3/3 on/off with 12 hours shifts, 8 overtime per paycheck It was really, really nice having 4 days off. It's a super easy job, basically babysitting machines, more reading the Internet than anything else
- fallingknife 3y agoOr maybe they can mind their business, not concern themselves with how employees spend their salary, and pay the same to workers with and without children.
- rasz 3y agoThe 'we give up R&D' GlobalFoundries? https://www.anandtech.com/show/13277/globalfoundries-stops-all-7nm-development https://www.anandtech.com/show/13277/globalfoundries-stops-a...
- seventytwo 3y agoIf it’s not TSMC, it’s bad?
- jeanlucas 3y agoHow's that related at all to the link? It's just a news article pointing out that GlobalFoundries gave up on making 7nm chips.
- icegreentea2 3y agoFrom the Anandtech article, you'll note that a major challenge GloFo cited in bringing 7nm online was getting the fab space for it, citing that they would need to sink 10-15 billion to bring 7nm (and lower) nodes online. You'll note that in the submitted article, GloFo is promising to do exactly that ("In return for the subsidies, GlobalFoundries said it would invest about $12.5 billion in the projects, most of which would be spent to expand the company’s Fab 8 in Malta, in Saratoga County."). Basically it seems like GloFo made a pretty hard nosed decision based on financing (guess they were just a few billion short last time) back in 2018, and now that they have those missing billions, they're going to go ahead. Based on these numbers, it does seem likely this would allow GloFo to bring online 7nm. But getting much past that (5nm and lower) seems uncertain. That said, having additional domestic 7nm production (crucially, 7nm that does not displace existing 14nm+ production) would be useful.
- seventytwo 3y agoA geo-strategic win for securing the semiconductor supply chain, and the top parent comments in here are complaints about the parking lot and how much tax money it’s going to take. Sheesh.
- devwastaken 3y agoNo one wants manufacturing in their back yard.
- Always42 3y ago^it's crazy to me usa hasn't brought chip mfg in sooner, but easy to say in hindsight
- seventytwo 3y agoWell, we’ve been of the collective mindset that internationalizing supply chains is best, for multiple reasons. And, under the right conditions, that may be true. However, the world is becoming morr multi-polar, so the calculations are changing. Lots of political, economic, and social inertia…
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> we’ve been of the collective mindset that internationalizing supply chains is best, for multiple reasons. Ultimately (multimately?) the collective mindset is of the investors and execs who directly, financially benefit from those reasons. I know this is a narrow lens with which to view pub+corp financial decisions. But it keeps producing such stunningly accurate pictures and I find it hard to not use it.
- pm90 3y agoI think thats a very simplistic view. Yes labor is cheaper in Asia. But the other factor is the availability of a certain kind of labor force. You need a lot of people that are highly skilled to operate these facilities. There isn’t that kind of workforce available in NA today.
- pxeger1 3y ago> Gina Raimondo said the plant will make “high-value chips” that are currently not made in the United States. The 300-millimeter chips are essential for national security [...] 300mm? What dimension is this measuring? I would expect feature size to be 300nm, but 30nm or 3nm is surely more likely.
- stn8188 3y agoThis is talking about pre-diced wafer diameter. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wafer_(electronics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wafer_(electronics)
- dubcanada 3y agoI suspect they mean wafer size, 300mm is a common wafer size.
- Alpha3031 3y ago> What dimension is this measuring? Twenty bucks says wafer size, since 300 mm wafers are standard. Edit: Also, here's the press release for the announcement: https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/02/biden-harris-administration-announces-preliminary-terms-globalfoundries https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/02/biden-harris-a...
- bee_rider 3y agoCertainly not the transistor size unless they’ve invented some new Gate All Around Ingot technology, hahaha.
- Kirby64 3y agoThat’s a shorthand for modern processes. Older process technology was made before 300mm wafers were standard, and retrofitting old processes to use larger wafers is generally considered to be not worth the cost since all the tooling is depreciated and paid for in 200mm or smaller wafers. Anything made today from the ground up would use 300mm wafers, though. Even slightly older process nodes (55nm, for instance).
- dragontamer 3y ago300mm is the new wafer standard. 200mm was the standard a few years ago.
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- capital_guy 3y agoAs a native upstate new yorker, I root for the success of GlobalFoundries. But it was exceedingly frustrating to me that they went and did layoffs in 2022 despite their booming revenues and incoming subsidies [0]. It seems to me there should be some kind of rule to prevent these layoffs for companies that receive billions of federal dollars. [0] - https://vtdigger.org/2022/12/01/globalfoundries-to-cut-up-to-800-jobs-worldwide/ https://vtdigger.org/2022/12/01/globalfoundries-to-cut-up-to...
- nos4A2 3y agoSuch a rule can have the opposite effect though, a company may choose to hire/grow more conservatively if it is subject to a condition that it cannot layoff.
- viscountchocula 3y agoIsn't their layoff a tacit admission that they should have grown more slowly, though?
- epistasis 3y agoWhen the Fed raises interest rates, it slams on everyone's brakes. Should GlobalFoundries somehow predicted the macro environment, better than everyone else, and followed their gut on reading macro tea leaves and pre-anticipated what the Fed would do? Ideally, yes, they would know the future, but in reality the best laid plans must change to meet reality, as current events always has surprises that can not be 100% derisked.
- gizmo 3y agoLayoffs are necessary from time to time to keep org chart bloat down. It's not just about the money. I don't mean this in a callous way and I understand that layoffs are painful for those getting fired. But for a business to thrive it has to make the correct strategic choices.
- 3y ago
- maerF0x0 3y agoWhile I agree with the geo-political arguments, I'd prefer to see regulations that allow the freemarket to design a solution, rather than a government contract to choose the winner. (eg: cars with 100% US made chips, or no chips, receive a tax rebate at the final consumer purchase) I also feel the need to comment that this is corporate welfarism and that is very much contrary to free markets or capitalism. IMO the government should not be choosing winers, but incentivizing everyone who generates a benefit. As an illustration (but not neccesarily the exact policy), what if the government awarded a benefit per TFLOP produced in the USA, or per chip created etc. (up to some maximum). Then a handful of competitors could all participate and benefit from the incentives. As it stands now its $3.1B harder to compete with GlobalFoundaries on the open market, meaning competitors and thus innovation and supply will actually be harmed. We also see time and again that corporate subsidies are not sufficiently beneficial to constituents to be worth the money. The best data i can find is on stadiums[1], but also some about when amazon was shopping itself around for incentives.[3] [1]- https://reason.com/volokh/2023/12/16/virginia-should-refuse-to-subsidize-the-construction-of-a-new-stadium-for-the-capitals-and-wizards/ https://reason.com/volokh/2023/12/16/virginia-should-refuse-... , https://reason.com/2013/12/21/why-stadium-subsidies-always-w/ https://reason.com/2013/12/21/why-stadium-subsidies-always-w... [2]: https://subsidytracker.goodjobsfirst.org/parent/tesla-inc https://subsidytracker.goodjobsfirst.org/parent/tesla-inc is a good resource for seeing how much companies have been subsidized [3]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/teresaghilarducci/2019/02/27/should-your-city-give-millions-to-big-rich-companies/?sh=6bb087c962ba https://www.forbes.com/sites/teresaghilarducci/2019/02/27/sh...
- DinoCoder99 3y ago> while I agree with the geo-political arguments, I'd prefer to see regulations that allow the freemarket to design a solution, rather than a government contract to choose the winner. I think the market did choose and the choice was "not in the us".
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y ago>that is very much contrary to free markets or capitalism Free markets and capitalism are related but not the same. The government using capital as an incentive for companies to increase output is an example of capitalism.
- _giorgio_ 3y agoBillions... Just imagine what they could do with trillions, eh Sam?
- downrightmike 3y agoApple and Microsoft seem to be doing pretty well
- beezle 3y agoFrom Vermont reporting - "Meanwhile, part of the money will be used to modernize the Essex Junction campus. Officials say the upgrades will enable the Vermont operation to become the first high-volume manufacturing facility capable of making gallium nitride semiconductors, which are used in electric vehicles, power grids, smartphones and more."
- thoughtstheseus 3y agoPlease stop the wasteful spending. Concentrate semi development geographically to realize synergies and economies of scale. Building redundant and competitive production thousands of miles apart in the Northeast/Great lakes, Texas, and the west Coast is not the best idea when you are resource and labor constrained.
- dangus 3y agoWasteful? What is a better national investment than the semiconductor industry? Look into the history of TSMC. It became what it is because of direct government investment. I'm sure to some people it seemed like a gamble at the time. This amount of money is basically trivial on the national level and the upside is tremendous.
- fxd123 3y ago> Building redundant and competitive production You do realize these fabs already exist? There is no redundant or competitive production currently.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoWith climate change getting more and more severe, I can't imagine a higher risk strategy (for anything) than geographic concentration. Talk about putting all your eggs in one basket.
- garunski 3y agowhat a crock of shit! no. none of this money will be spent wisely. these companies are requiring the government to subsidize their profits without having to spend their own money. the promise of jobs is all fluff. billions to buffalo didnt send even one billion to buffalo and certainly didnt improve any lives in that region. as someone who lives here, I wish I could trust these people but the reality is that the state is so corrupt and US government is on the same level, where all the money will be forced out of the people and nothing will be delivered.
- rasz 3y agoYou are right when it comes to subsidies in general. Recent moves and voices send a clear signal across the world - US is not a reliable security guarantee partner. CHIPS subsidies is a hedge against China taking over Taiwan. US is building onshore capacity to be able to renege on defense promises given to Taiwan at minimum cost. I would be very worried if I was in Taiwan. Im already worried as it is living in Europe and learning article 5 might just be a mere suggestion to US.
- garunski 3y agothe 3.1 billion could be spent on Education, Libraries, Updating Infrastructure that is destroyed by harsh winters, investing in restoration of natural resources, helping the failing farmers, updating rail and lake/river deliveries. But no. we should def give it to people that will spend exactly 1% pretending to develop a factory and claim the rest for themselves because they encountered problems.