4 ms·
This is easy to fix. Make Amazon responsible for warranting all sales on their platform. Amazon claims they are not the seller, some anonymous party running an
by Animats 3y ago
This is easy to fix. Make Amazon responsible for warranting all sales on their platform. Amazon claims they are not the seller, some anonymous party running an ad on their platform is the seller. That was litigated in Pennsylvania, and when it got to the level that Amazon was looking at a major lose, Amazon settled to avoid a precedent.
On the ad front, anyone who runs an ad for a third party should have to be able to produce the actual name and address of the advertiser on request, or accept responsibility for the contents of the ad. Businesses have no right to be anonymous. That is existing law in the EU and California.
Fraud is a problem because the major platforms get a free pass on supporting it. Not because it's hard.
- kurthr 3y agoKYC or you're liable. Interesting solution. It's kinda amazing it's not already that way (since advertisers need to get paid). I guess it would make it harder to advertise, if you're not already big so that could hurt little guys, but so is scamming customers.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoKYC just incentivizes discrimination. Eventually ends up with innocent people not being able to get bank accounts or rent hotel rooms because they get associated with prior probabilities that do not necessarily apply to them, aka discrimination. Punishing scammers to dissuade and reduce the quantity of scammers is the government’s job and should not be laid on businesses, for a well functioning high trust society. If international jurisdictions are a problem, then the national government needs to provide an identify verification API for businesses so they know the customer they are dealing with is subject to the legal system of the country.
- Nursie 3y agoThis is nonsense. Businesses are not above the law and claiming that you are only a proxy or that what you do is too complex shouldn't get you out of having to follow those laws. We're talking KYC (or direct liability) for businesses here. There is nothing discriminatory about it.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI specifically wrote why know your customer laws are bad. A law that makes a bank liable for their customer’s illegal actions harms people who kind of sort of look like they could be doing something illegal, even if they are innocent. Plainly discriminatory. A law that makes hotels liable for human trafficking harms people who “look” like human traffickers. Guess what, now people who want to pay with cash or don’t have an ID or don’t fit whatever other profile are no longer welcome at a hotel. Again, obviously discriminatory since people who didn’t do anything illegal are being punished. These aren’t made up examples, these are real life examples. The government is literally telling a business they have to judge someone without the person being able to provide a defense, like they would in a court of law.
- Nursie 3y agoIf you sell something to the public, you must abide by certain regulations. A law that says "Amazon must know their sellers and be able to pass the consumer on to those sellers, or it is liable itself as a backstop" might indeed shut some people out of Amazon's marketplace who cannot comply. But those people would not be allowed to legally retail to the public anyway, as they couldn't fulfil those requirements > The government is literally telling a business they have to judge someone without the person being able to provide a defense, like they would in a court of law. A business, not a someone, and there are all sorts of compliance rules you could complain about doing exactly the same thing.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoA business is someone. And KYC should just be the government providing an identify verification API so that in the event there is a problem, the government knows who to go after. Government leaders just want to be able to point fingers at as many people as possible with KYC laws (which do more than just require the business to verify who they are doing business with). A business should know who they are transacting with, but a business should not be vetting them for illegal activities. That is a job for courts. Businesses can even be required to report who buys what and how much (for example, bulk supplies to make methamphetimine or explosives), but the business should not be using nebulous heuristics such as credit score or income or other non illegal things to figure out who may or may not be a criminal. Last example, the US government should require online marketplaces to know who they are doing business with, and it should be someone within US jurisdiction. The US government should also provide the online marketplaces with an identity verification API to do this. So when a product sold on Amazon causes a problem, it should be easily possible for the government to charge the seller with a crime, and dole out an appropriate punishment.
- Animats 3y agoThat's for ads. For online retail, the site that takes the money is the retailer. Period. The platform and the sellers can fight out who pays for returns and warranty problems. After the customer gets paid.
- palmfacehn 3y agoThis is basically regulatory capture for the fraudsters. Fraudsters will have forums full of ID fraud services to fix their KYC problem. Big platforms won't blink at the costs involved with verification. Fraudsters will simply rinse and repeat when their scheme collapses. Normal business people will have yet another headache. Corner cases will exist where users are condemned to unending bureaucratic limbo. A human support person, if they exist at all, will repeat a meaningless mantra, "I'm sorry sir, we've been unable to verify your identity with the documents provided. This is a compliance requirement as per the online platform safety act of 2026" All the while, scammers will be churning out new KYC'd accounts. The process will have nothing to do with safety, as the platform will only care about complying with the new regulation. Don't forget that Amazon still earns fees from each sale. Large platforms will enjoy the compliance requirements as an additional barrier to entry for competitors. Not to mention the inevitable day when all of that personal data is released. Breeches exposed for all to see. Another headache the fraudsters won't have. The regulars of the ID fraud forum will probably enjoy it. I could start my own VC fund if I had $1 for every post on HN claiming, "It is so simple and easy! We can fix this with more government!" It is never so simple when you are dealing with humans and incentives. Human societies are not codebases you can just patch to eliminate bugs.
- Nursie 3y agoIf big platforms like amazon find themselves liable if they cannot connect seller activity to real human beings and real businesses, they will have an incentive to fix their systems to stop those spammers churning out KYC'd accounts. The platform will care about costs to itself. One of the advantages these large platforms enjoy over smaller ones is their ability to pass the buck on consumer law, to their benefit and to the scammers. By making it the platform's liability, always, this could start to change. If the companies that think of themselves as large 'platforms' end up erecting barriers to legitimate business in the process, then that becomes their problem and is likely to result in more competition in the market from companies who act as actual stores themselves. It's not 'so simple' but a liability change, and an end to exempting retailers like amazon from their retailer responsibilities could start to rebalance things.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> Amazon settled to avoid a precedent Maybe that's the true problem. At some point courts should stop settlements from happening due to the value of precedents to society as a whole.
- otterley 3y agoWhile I get your point about precedential value, most disputes won’t result in new law even if litigated. Settlements are more economically efficient than having every dispute adjudicated. There is pretty much universal agreement among economists about this and many papers have analyzed the question. And the court system is definitely not an economy of scale.
- Nextgrid 3y ago> That was litigated in Pennsylvania, and when it got to the level that Amazon was looking at a major lose, Amazon settled to avoid a precedent. That seems like a problem in our legal system though. It basically means you can force your opponent through a long & expensive legal process (hoping they'd give up or run out of resources in the meantime) and still not risk anything yourself as you can abort the whole thing the second the tide starts turning against you.
- Majromax 3y ago> That seems like a problem in our legal system though. The civil legal system is designed to settle essentially private disputes between parties. It is not really a matter of public interest whether my neighbour or I bear the liability for the tree branch that hits my parked car during a storm. Your discomfort arises because the actions of large companies are matters of public interest, such that a notionally 'private' dispute can still affect hundreds of thousands of people. Class-action lawsuits are one way to shoehorn this sort of dispute into the court system, but the other way is regulation. Depending on the framework, regulators can issue orders themselves or bring court cases for the sake of public interest. Unfortunately, good, timely, and competent regulation is its own hard problem.