2 ms·
"It is also noteworthy what it HN ranking for: A comment is the top result for "where was gta made"." Not for me. Wikipedia is #1. I retrieved 100 results.
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
"It is also noteworthy what it HN ranking for:
A comment is the top result for "where was gta made"."
Not for me. Wikipedia is #1. I retrieved 100 results. None of them were HN comments.
"A comment from desdiv is ranking #1 for the question "Monaco in italian""
For me Wikipedia was again #1. HN comment was #2.
"Another article that ranks well for several keywords like "ruined my life" is GRAHAM PANTHER's article, and HN also ranks well for brand-related KW, such as every question about the cost of youtube tv, where Google favours the post from thunderbong."
For the search "cost of youtube tv", NerdWallet ranked #1. HN comment was #10.
It is baffling to me that people, who certainly know that results for the same query can vary according to a number of factors, e.g., geolocation, pretend every computer user performing some Google search query is getting identical results.
Ideally that is how search should work. But Google web search is not ideal. Far from it. It is advertising company search. The goal is not to return results in a consistent, transparent manner according to a relatively simple, well-known algorithm. It is to sell advertising services. The goal is not truth. It's money.
- skybrian 3y agoWhy would you even want the same results everywhere? Local results will be better for many queries.
- jcmp 3y agoYou are right ofcourse, results variey a lot. The results in the post where sourced from a third party tool for the UK and the US so kind of the results you would get in inkognito mode.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"Local search" when using Google is not optional. The user cannot choose a region when searching www.google.com. The advertising company chooses the region. Why. For the user of course. The company is a trillion dollar charity run by volunteers working on users' behalf for "the good of the web". Right. Does local search benefit sales of advertising services. Proponents of so-called "tech" companies will always try to justify the choices of the so-called "tech" company^1 as being for the benefit of the user. It could be half true. To use DNS as an analaogy, EDNS0 client subnet (ECS) was another one of Google's magnificient "improvements" to the internet. Google fans would argue that ECS is 100% for the benefit of users. However it just so happens to be useful for advertising.^2 What a fortuitous coincidence. 1. The user does not choose. Choice is removed. 2. https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/13993698.json https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/item/13993698.json