5 ms·
Airline Takes Revenge After Bad Review, Posts Passenger's Passport Online
- TulliusCicero 3y agoWe don't know if the reviewer here is guilty of some wrong, but posting his passport is definitely wrong from the business' side, even if it's not technically illegal in that country.
- _trampeltier 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 3y agoTheir hope is that he will recognized and denied service or treated with kid gloves by other airlines.
- bertil 3y agoYou can share his name, or at least the name he uses to send similar messages for that. No need to share a document that will be used by dangerous people to impersonate him.
- throwanem 3y agoPedant's note: To 'handle with kid gloves' refers to an especially soft and delicate type of leather ('kidskin', from an original and now archaic sense of 'kid' meaning a young goat), and as a figure describes especially gentle or deferential treatment.
- projektfu 3y agoSeems like that might be one interpretation. Instead of denying service, say we don't give influencers money for reviews and make sure he has nothing to complain about, even if he has nothing to gush about. Then a shitty review would be obviously because of the lack of payola.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoNo, they wouldn't want other airlines giving him extra nice service, they'd want other airlines treating him as toxic. Which is not the meaning of "kid gloves."
- anigbrowl 3y agoProjektfu's interpretation is what I had in mind, actually. Some airlines might prefer to avoid conflict by treating the guy as delicately as possible. I don't know what the thoughts of the Timorese airline are.
- throwanem 3y agoYeah. You can show influencers as hard a hand as you like, for all of me; I'm only here to clarify that "kid gloves" reads as if to ask for showing them a soft one.
- throwanem 3y agoI'm not really sure why an East Timorese regional airline needs to give a damn what an American Youtuber thinks or says. Pretty sure this guy's audience is not the market they're playing to.
- atoav 3y agoIn the German equivalent the gloves are made of velvet: "mit Samthandschuhen anfassen"
- Nextgrid 3y ago[flagged]
- awiesenhofer 3y ago> The only way for this to stop is to match their level of unprofessionalness/childishness. Whatever the situation, this is NEVER the right way!
- Nextgrid 3y ago> Whatever the situation, this is NEVER the right way! I agree with your opinion in a world where nobody profits off unprofessional/childish behavior, so any instances of it would be temporary lapses in judgement that are better dealt with by assuming good faith and not reciprocating the bad behavior. But I'm not sure if this holds in a society where some people figured out how to monetize unprofessional behavior? In this case, assuming good faith and accommodating them doesn't work and just gives them what they want.
- atoav 3y agoNope. Shilling for corporate might seem like a desirable thing, but unless you are on top of corporate and you only pretend to shill for corps there is really nothing in there for you. Businesses can (and will!) fuck over customers if given the chance. And the way they are fiven the chance is by not having laws preventing behaviour like that. Additionally, such reactions are in front of a big audience. Petty revenge might feel warranted to simple minds, but for an airline that one case is irrelevant, and the effect such things have on the resr of the audience is what counts. And judging by the reactions in this thread this move is one that damages the airline more than it helps preventing any future problems.
- pimlottc 3y agoThere's more detail in another article linked from this one [0]. There is a heavily redacted version of the passport image from the Facebook post in the YouTube video @ 4:00 > Recently the country manager for Aero Dili, Acacia Mota, made a post on Facebook about Cahill with some wild claims. He states that Cahill reached out before his flight, asking for a free flight, free accommodation, a food allowance, and $50,000 in cash, in exchange for a positive review. > Those are some outrageous claims, so what proof did Mota provide? Well, instead of sharing a screenshot of the alleged extortion attempt, he shared a picture of Cahill’s passport, with all the details showing. Cahill isn’t sure how he got that picture, though it may have been from during check-in (given that there were issues), or from his arrival in the country. 0: https://onemileatatime.com/news/airline-revenge-youtuber-passport/ https://onemileatatime.com/news/airline-revenge-youtuber-pas...
- csdvrx 3y ago> There is a heavily redacted version of the passport image from the Facebook post in the YouTube video @ 4:00 > Well, instead of sharing a screenshot of the alleged extortion attempt, he shared a picture of Cahill’s passport, with all the details showing Did they share an heavily redacted version, or all the details? Sharing an email could run afoul of local laws (it's a personal message, and by default private), however a passport is a government document. If they did redact some important details, I think it may have been the fairest response to an attempt at extortion by a known drama king: they may have just wanted him to avoid trying to take advantage of others. Then it would not be retaliation, but trying to protect others. I have travelled a bit, and in poor countries (though certainly not as poor as East Timor, but certainly poorer than the US) I've noticed that people care a lot about fairness, and really don't like it when privileged tourist try to take advantage of their position and the advantage their foreign income brings. I've also noticed than when you play fair, people play very fair with you: on a restaurant when I had taken only one sip of the wine because I was driving, the waiter noticed AFTER I had paid by credit card, and issued a cash refund for the wine because they thought it was unfair to charge me for something I did not consume - and they did not accept tipping. Then the next day when I returned the rental car and when I explained I had difficulty finding a gas station to do a full refill (the gas gage was 7/8 instead of 8/8), the refueling fee was waived - and when I took the car, the agent explained me that I should take pictures of the car (so I did!) in case there was any issue because it had a tiny scratch on one door. Maybe I was very lucky and I stopped at a unique restaurant and Europcar agents are more friendly than others, or maybe people treat you the way you treat them: be nice, and they will reciprocate.
- Beijinger 3y ago"have gotten food poisoning on board." This is highly unlikely. Think about what would happen, if XX% of the passengers get food poisoning. Airplane food is probably one of the safest in the world from this perspective. I indeed got food poisoning once on a plane. I assume (!) it was caused by food from the lounge in the airport in Addis Ababa. But not from food served in the plane. But for sure would make a funny scene for a movie. 200 people shitting their guts out and competing for 4 toilets.
- russdill 3y agoThat how food poisoning works on TV. It's not how food poisoning typically works in reality. https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/symptoms.html https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/symptoms.html
- Beijinger 3y ago? "Diarrhea, Vomiting" from your link. Trust me. I had it on a plane.
- prmoustache 3y agoThe thing is that you can never be positive that the poisoning comes from the last meal, a previous one, or getting germs in your hands somewhere else and having them transfered hands to mouth sonetimes inbetween. It is simply dishonest to accuse someone of food poisoning in a review unless statistics points to it (like an x amount of passenger of same flight suffering from the same symptoms).
- nixgeek 3y agoIt feels like the 'influencer economy' has money plus goods/services changing hands in return for reviews all over the place, and the bar for disclosing things like affiliate links exists, but adherence to that bar is mixed with influencers, and enforcement of that bar also seems rare (at least in the US). Is it possible to believe that a travel influencer with 700,000 subscribers (plus whatever other channel statistics matter to doing these deals with Marketing departments; number of views, watch times, number of click throughs?) would expect a free flight, some accommodation, a food allowance, and some money in return for the time and effort to do the flight, edit a video, post it? Likely yes. Does that make it okay to post his personal details? No. But this does seem like the definition of "Fsck around; find out", given the influencer in question has posted lots of stuff *slamming* other businesses, and they've now done it in a country where the airline's response isn't illegal, and the airline isn't covered by IATA's code of conduct, so they have no recourse.
- rado 3y agoWhile Josh does indeed thrive on drama, AFAIK he never takes free flights or anything.
- prmoustache 3y agoHow do you know that?
- FireBeyond 3y agoThere is zero way to know that. When the cheesegrater Mac Pro launched in 2019, I was interested in one. I am also interested in photography. So I loved watching at least 6 or 8 videos from my favorite photography YouTubers unboxing and reviewing their launch day Mac Pro and Pro Display XDRs... All of which they'd "ordered". I put that in quotation marks because as I watched and rewatched these videos I noticed something: every. single. one. had exactly the same non-baseline spec: 18 core CPU, 384GB memory, Vega II Duo GPU and an 8TB SSD. And every single one had got the Pro Display XDR with the nano coating and the stand. And it wasn't a case of "maybe that ships faster", or anything, and besides, that's a $25K setup with the screen. Also, if you're a photographer, even if you're working on medium format digital, and 100MP images, you in no way shape or form need 384GB of memory, or that GPU - the whole thing was massively overspecced. For me, LightRoom / Capture One and Photoshop all did not break a sweat on my 12 core 192GB W5700X variant (which was mainly specced that way for other reasons). It was pretty obvious that though they may well have ordered one, that Apple had sent them all a launch day setup, all identically specced. They could substitute theirs when it arrived and send back the other unit, or whatever. But not one single one of them ever said anything about it.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThis seems like an instance of, Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.
- ranger_danger 3y agoSince people don't seem to like that response no matter who says it these days... I guess all I can say is "that doesn't give them the right".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 3y agoA video review needs to offer drama – either amazing over-the-top experience or absolute misery – in order to perform well. This is part of the problem. Social media sites are full of niche content that is interesting at first (when encountering it as a new topic) but rapidly devolves into the BEST, the WORST, the CRAZIEST, or way overworked micro-obsessions. I get tired of the sound of my own voice during periods of high social engagement, but most influencers, youtubers etc seem sadly immune to this, preferring instead to wring their subject material dry.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoI've found Mark Smith, a.k.a. 'The Man in Seat 61'[1], to be a very reliable travel blogger/vlogger. His information on railways across Europe is up-to-date, detailed and stays away from such melodramatic exaggeration as you describe. It's usually easier to get the timetables from his site than it is from the travel company! I'm not affiliated with him in any way; I post it here just as a reminder that honest travel journalism still exists if you know where to find it. [1]: https://www.seat61.com https://www.seat61.com
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoThis is an guy who thrives on faux drama in his youtube videos (as is typical), harassing the national airline one of the poorest countries on earth. 20% of the population of East Timor is unemployed and 52.9% live on less than $1.25 a day. About half of the population is illiterate. What is being sold as revenge by all of these airline and points websites is more likely a lack of sophistication from the employee(s) in question, and likely having more pressing concerns than this guy. The first-world, monetised, exaggerated outrage and victim theater is sickening and for none of the reasons stated by this idiot influencer.
- krisoft 3y ago> This is an guy who thrives on faux drama in his youtube videos (as is typical), harassing the national airline one of the poorest countries on earth. So? If they have been wronged they should be free to post the email where the influencer was blackmailing them. What does publishing his passport achieve other than showing that they shouldn’t be trusted with a lemonade stand, let alone with being an airline. > likely having more pressing concerns than this guy Probably. In that case they should solve those problems and not engage with him.
- kmeisthax 3y agoYou're defending a corporation that has doxxed a YouTuber for posting a critical review. This is censorship, plain and simple, whether or not the corporation in question intended it to be an attack. Even if it was an accident, which seems unlikely, wouldn't that vindicate the YouTuber's faux drama? See, this airline is so incompetently run that, when they complained about me, they made up shit and posted my passport instead of actual proof!
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoAll you're doing is making assumptions about the intent of the airline, based on nothing. Of course intent matters, who knows exactly why they posted his passport. You also have no more information on the actions or intent of the youtuber than anyone, but you're defending him as the victim here, based solely on his questionable claims in the context of his fabulist videos.
- seydor 3y agoThis ended up being the best advertisement for the airline of the impoverished country
- pridkett 3y agoThat could be a feature of airlines in the future. “We guarantee that every influencer and faux-influencer will have a miserable flight. For everyone else, we promise a reasonable flight at a reasonable price and a minimal number of influencers.”
- seabass-labrax 3y agoI'm slightly surprised that the passenger here (Josh Cahill) did not mention applying for a new passport. Although the stored biometric and encrypted information is clearly not accessible with merely a photograph, the passport number itself is sufficiently private to cause severe headaches if published publically! With this in mind, it appears to me even more important to foster a norm of contactless identity verification at border controls. Ideally, you should never have to let your passport leave your person, and there would be international agreements to make custody of a non-citizen's passport illegal.
- madsbuch 3y agocan you explain what type of headaches your would expect? in Denmark we have had the issue that some companies issues loans solely based on social security numbers. however, the root issue is that lenders did not verify identity, and I am quite sure that companies malpracticing like this are liable themselves. mean while, AFAIK, in Sweden social security numbers are public info - that it probably what we should aim for.
- ranger_danger 3y ago> can you explain what type of headaches your would expect? identity theft
- alwa 3y agoAt least in the US, isn’t the stored biometric data just a JPEG of the person’s face? In that sense, a photograph should suffice to reproduce it :) If the intention is in fact to communicate some fact about the passenger to other parties in the travel sector, it does seem like it might make sense to disambiguate the passenger you’re talking about by specifying their gender and date of birth, and for that matter a stable state-issued identifier. I am curious about what kind of headaches a passport document number could cause, though. I hear people worry about it a lot, but also I’m accustomed to places of public accommodation routinely scribbling the document number down at check-in, or photocopying the document themselves. Is the threat, like, a false visa application or something? Is it the birthday that people are worried about getting out there?
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoI am glad that EU has GDPR so something like this would cost stupid corporation a lot of money.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- blanchard34 3y ago[dead]