3 ms·
I used to participate in the folding at home project. Not sure it makes sense post alphaFold. Is this not a solved problem now? Or does additional compute stil
by Havoc 3y ago
I used to participate in the folding at home project. Not sure it makes sense post alphaFold. Is this not a solved problem now?
Or does additional compute still matter?
- humnre 3y ago> Is this not a solved problem now? This is an interesting question. Can any contemporary “ai” solution be considered a solved problem? A lot of these neural net architecture are designed first and foremost as approximation engines without any guarantees the provided approximation is even any good. This can be useful, but especially in a medical sense, also insufficient or even dangerous. > AlphaFold's protein structure prediction results at CASP were described as "transformational" and "astounding".[93][94] Some researchers noted that the accuracy is not high enough for a third of its predictions, and that it does not reveal the mechanism or rules of protein folding for the protein folding problem to be considered solved.[95] Nevertheless, it is considered a significant achievement in computational biology[92] and great progress towards a decades-old grand challenge of biology.[93] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_folding https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protein_folding Protein folding is still very much an unsolved problem.
- COGlory 3y agoWhat AlphaFold is doing is essentially matching a sequence of amino acids to solved protein structures, albeit dynamically, and with some advanced constraints. In essence, it's not predicting how the protein will fold, but rather, how the protein will look once it's done folding. And in many many cases, there's no matching fold for a sequence. Also, proteins are dynamic. They interact with other proteins. They sample multiple conformations, they frequently rearrangle, or become disordered, and then re-ordered. AlphaFold is just a single snapshot. If we want to understand how proteins fold, we need more than just AlphaFold.