> which earns it extra credit Does it? Maybe this is what bifurcates opinions on it! I'd agree it's different: I just don't think it's different and good. An

> which earns it extra credit Does it? Maybe this is what bifurcates opinions on it! I'd agree it's different: I just don't think it's different and good. And difference alone doesn't bump it past similar but better-written books, imho.