5 ms·
It's good enough when I don't need a number to sign up at all. Unfortunately they're not there yet. So for now.. meh Without that it's just a slightly more pri
by wkat4242 3y ago
It's good enough when I don't need a number to sign up at all. Unfortunately they're not there yet. So for now.. meh
Without that it's just a slightly more private WhatsApp.
In fact I wish we could move to another kind of identifier than a "phone number" for things like this. It's probably pretty region-dependent but personally I never use my phone to actually make phone calls or text. All my voice, video and messaging traffic to friends goes through apps, though the number is unfortunately still used as an identifier. Unfortunately, because if I let a number lapse I lose access to the whatsapp and telegram accounts related to it. This way it makes it hard having multiple accounts.
I'd prefer if mobile providers would just become a dumb data pipe the same as landline providers have already become. My Spanish provider still forces me to take a "landline" with my internet but I don't even have a phone connected to it.
- fsflover 3y agoI solved this problem (and more) by switching to Matrix.
- tptacek 3y agoRecords of precisely who you talk to are being kept serverside because of that decision. Maybe that's totally fine for you! Most people have pretty unserious secure messaging threat models (I don't mean that as a value judgement).
- greyface- 3y agoThe same is likely true of Signal, no? Traffic analysis on AWS' edge would tell you precisely who is talking to who, and user identities are tied to legal identities via phone numbers. Maybe Signal doesn't store this data serverside, but there are entities with both the capability and motivation to obtain it. I bet there are Signal XKEYSCORE selectors.
- tptacek 3y agoNo, it's not. Traffic analysis is potent, but it is not a literal SQL database of who has talked to who when.
- fsflover 3y agoSo the problem is the same: trusting the server. At least small Matrix servers aren't huge targets for attacks, since they don't serve so many users. Also on Matrix you can run your own server.
- stavros 3y agoSignal doesn't know who's talking to you, it's called sealed sender: https://signal.org/blog/sealed-sender/ https://signal.org/blog/sealed-sender/
- fsflover 3y agoWhich is irrelevant when Amazon has all IP addresses.
- akerl_ 3y agoSo the two things we're comparing are: 1. Signal, where an attacker with granular access to AWS's global network logs could perform traffic analysis to match timings between sender and recipient IP addresses, which would work for some portion, and narrow things down for some other portion. The attacker would then need to combine that with data from mobile networks and other ISPs to link the sender/recipient IPs at a given timestamp with a subscriber. 2. Other messaging platforms, including Matrix, where they can just check the server's database to get a table of what user messaged what other user at a given time.
- Arathorn 3y agoOn Matrix, that assumes the attacker knows where the server is or that it even exists. Whereas on Signal it’s pretty obvious where the server is, given there’s only one logical server.
- Erratic6576 3y agoThe amount of problems remains stable, as a universal constant . Problems are neither solved nor created, only transformed. By switching from Telegram to Matrix, new problems arose. By switching from Matrix to Session, by switching to Signal, where we are now, fewer problems arose
- shp0ngle 3y agoSignal will not publicly admit that, but they are using phone numbers as a cheap anti-spam measure. If anyone can sign up with an email, you will have same spam problems as with email, and will need to implement some spam filtering, and so on. It's harder to spam with phones. Although, as they now do in Burma, they can just kidnap a lot of people from China and India and keep them as slaves and make them send spam from phones. But anyway that's a different story
- tptacek 3y agoI feel like Signal has been up front for many years about why they use phone numbers, and I get incessant spam on other phone number platforms (most especially: phones) so I'm not sure that holds water.
- shp0ngle 3y agoThey seem to actually confirm it themselves, which I didn't know. > We use third-party services to send a registration code via SMS or voice call in order to verify that the person in possession of a given phone number actually intended to sign up for a Signal account. This is a critical step in helping to prevent spam accounts from signing up for the service and rendering it completely unusable—a non-trivial problem for any popular messaging app. From their blogpost
- tptacek 3y agoI'm sure they absolutely do use it as a spam signal. You use what you've got. But that's not why they use phone number identifiers, which is a design decision they and others have written ad nauseam about.
- zx8080 3y agoThey probably require phone numbers to be able to comply with the three-letter government agencies requirements and their requests on specific people. Metadata is specifically available "for free" (who calls/messages whom when).
- nicce 3y ago> Without that it's just a slightly more private WhatsApp. They are not even comparable. WhatsApp does not encrypt metadata at all, which is the most interesting information you can leak.
- medstrom 3y agoAlso WhatsApp is closed-source, so you can only take their word for whether the E2E is really E2E -- and it's owned by Facebook.
- Erratic6576 3y agoWhy wouldn’t you trust Zuck’s word? He seems like an honourable
- binary132 3y agoThere’s really nothing stopping someone from publishing an instrumented / modded binary to a mobile App Store unless there’s a user-verifiable build chain, even if it is open-source. Even if the backend IS e2ee, the UI can be extended to keylog / etc. The App Store provider can be in on it too. DNS can be filtered to provide some degree of control and traffic inspection, but there’s always DNS over HTTPS, tunneling, and so on and so forth. I’d be surprised if Signal was doing it, since getting caught at it would totally destroy their reputation, but I’d honestly be surprised if WhatsApp didn’t have at least a backdoor for it.
- nicce 3y agoFor Signal, open source since 2016 https://signal.org/blog/reproducible-android/ https://signal.org/blog/reproducible-android/ Unless you espcially meant by ”App Store”, by Apples App store, it is Apple to blame in that case because it is not possible due to the encryption of app binaries.
- binary132 3y agoI wasn't speaking specifically about Signal nor about a particular storefront. I'm glad Signal has at least a reproducible build on one platform. That doesn't change my main point: "it's open source" is NOT a guarantor of this AT ALL without usable build verification.
- hobobaggins 3y agoSignal's vaunted double-ratchet encrypted groups have a severe weakness in the key exchange where the server can add itself as a participant. Granted, this is pretty hard to solve when participants come online and offline at different times without having a trusted and always-online entity to handle the list of the current members (in the signal model, it's the server), but signal's still definitely not a silver bullet, even if people treat it like it is. But if Signal gets pwned or captured, it can easily add itself into any group, or even add and remove instantly.
- ianburrell 3y agoDo you evidence of that? Are you sure you aren’t confusing Signal and Matrix, which had that big? We would have heard about Signal after the Matrix bug if it also had it.
- hobobaggins 3y agoIt's not really a bug. It's a design decision. There's no clear solution for it from an encryption perspective without a big tradeoffs (like requiring all participants to be online at the same time). Besides, the larger the group, the more likely that one of the nodes has been compromised anyway. Everything's a tradeoff -- don't depend on the security of a single solution if you're really trying to keep a secret; defense in depth.
- ianburrell 3y agoYou haven’t shown that this flaw is in Signal in addition to Matrix. I heard about Matrix having that exact flaw, and if Signal had the same flaw, it would be big news. I remember Signal saying that they are not vulnerable.
- cpach 3y agoIf this was true I would expect there were additional sources besides a random anonymous HN comment.
- antisocialist 3y ago[dead]
- Timshel 3y agoSurprised you did not mention Matrix/Element.
- mikae1 3y agoOr https://wire.com/en https://wire.com/en
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y agoOr Threema.
- rini17 3y agoI also wish their desktop client doesn't need to update hundred megabytes every few days.
- illiac786 3y agoI guess it bears repeating, but you can sign up from a public phone booth. So I do not understand what the problem is with needing a phone number. Is it because it's inconvenient to you?