2 ms·
In what sense does it fall apart? Corporations are treated like people because they're made up of and owned by people. You don't lose your right not to be subj
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
In what sense does it fall apart?
Corporations are treated like people because they're made up of and owned by people. You don't lose your right not to be subject to arbitrary fines just because you incorporated. And a lot of corporations are owned by millions of different individuals, so instead of having millions of people take the government to court, it's easier to have the corporation's officers do it on their behalf. That's all "corporations are people" really is.
- eropple 3y ago> You don't lose your right not to be subject to arbitrary fines just because you incorporated. One: NLRB rulings are "arbitrary" only if you somehow believe that a regulatory body, whose rulings can be appealed to an Article III court for redress, are intrinsically "arbitrary". Which is a quiet little hide-the-ball attempt at rhetoric. Two: your fictive person provides the real people who've bought into it limited liability, which actual humans cannot avail themselves of. This is a superpower of your fictive person exists at the literal beneficience of the society that granted its charter; its bad behavior should be more readily addressed than the due process afforded to actual humans.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> NLRB rulings are "arbitrary" only if you somehow believe that a regulatory body, whose rulings can be appealed to an Article III court for redress, are intrinsically "arbitrary". Which is a quiet little hide-the-ball attempt at rhetoric. They're arbitrary not because of the ruling (although putting judicial functions in the executive is scarcely better than putting legislative functions there), they're arbitrary because the rule you're being fined for violating was created by the administrative agency fining you rather than Congress. > your fictive person provides the real people who've bought into it limited liability, which actual humans cannot avail themselves of. It's typically the actual humans who avail themselves of it. Limited liability means that if you own shares of Exxon (or the S&P 500, which has contained shares of Exxon) and then they get sued and go bankrupt, the plaintiffs don't get to take your house. It's about protecting the investors (commonly ordinary human individuals) rather than the corporation which can still be sued into bankruptcy. It's also not obvious what one has to do with the other. So you can't sue the corporation for more than what it has, why does that mean you should be able to take their stuff under rules never passed by elected legislators?
- 15457345234 3y ago> they're arbitrary because the rule you're being fined for violating was created by the administrative agency fining you rather than Congress. This is a weird argument that seems to be being put about recently and it's one of the weirdest legal arguments I've ever seen. Of course rulemaking can be delegated. The rules and rulemaking body remains under oversight, the rules can be overridden by the elected body, etc. Just a totally strange argument; delegation of authority by elected bodies to specialist subgroups is basically how government works without having 100,000 elected positions, and if your proposed solution is 'okay let's have 100,000 elected positions' you get the local government situation in which people run unopposed because nobody really gives a damn and the local coroner is the town drunk - or people just vote straight ticket. Just weird. Seems more about destroying the system - which isn't perfect, but works - than about actually solving a problem.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> delegation of authority by elected bodies to specialist subgroups is basically how government works without having 100,000 elected positions The way you do it is that the specialist subgroup proposes legislation and then the generalist legislature votes on it. And maybe they defer to their proposals 95% of the time, but it means that the unelected specialists can't push through a controversial change without having it approved by the elected legislators.
- tzs 3y ago> And maybe they defer to their proposals 95% of the time Have you looked at Congress lately? It would be more like less than 1% of the time. The rest of the time there will be some group that blocks action to try to get concessions on some unrelated issue of theirs.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey don't need this for that, they already do it with whatever is on the agenda and then get their concessions. Do tell if you know of a way to get them to stop, but just adding another bill to the roster doesn't seem likely to change it one way or the other.
- RandomLensman 3y agoCan people have limited liability like a certain forms of incorporation? Corporations are not just collections of people but they also enjoy certain privileges as well as having some obligations.
- flir 3y agoOwned by, but not composed of. Your dog doesn't get the protections of personhood because you own it. If it attacks someone, there's not going to be a trial. (A moral view not a legal one, obviously. No comments about the merits or otherwise of this case).
- sudosysgen 3y agoThis isn't true. We already have a legal structure for a bunch of people working together, that's called a general partnership. Corporations are shielded from the vast majority of criminal penalties and essentially make truly punitive damages non-existent. This is something no person has - I can't discharge fines in bankruptcy and I can't decide that the only punishment I'll ever have are fines.