3 ms·
What's most surprising to me is the comments. They seem to be replying to the title and not the content of the article. I think no one is surprised that Russia
by godelski 3y ago
What's most surprising to me is the comments. They seem to be replying to the title and not the content of the article. I think no one is surprised that Russia is running a disinformation campaign. But this is like how people show you clips of politicians asking stupid questions that are actually just questions so that the information is on the record. What do you want, the Washington Post to __not__ report on the disinformation campaign? Should it better be titled "Kremlin's disinformation campaign to undermine Zelensky?" Or "Document reveals how the Kremlin is undermining Zelensky through disinformation?" I suspect we'd get similar comments.
The perverse nature of disinformation and propaganda is that so many think they are immune to it and it is easily recognizable. But if you really think this, this is a mark of the success of propaganda, because you have let your guard down. Just think from a likelihood perspective, and how much your model fits reality. If propaganda was easy to identify then there's two outcomes: you can't explain why it is so effective (your model is broken) or you are particularly unique and special because propaganda is effective but just not on you (i.e. everyone else is dumb, I'm smart). This is the tool at play. We like to feel smart. So sample from people you know, do you think you're sufficiently smarter than enough of them? Are you in a bubble? Or what?
The obvious propaganda helps the more subtle propaganda in. It's like how I trained my cat to be terrible at hiding. I just pretend I don't see her when she's in an obvious place and I make it well known and trick her into thinking I wasn't looking for her when she actually is in a good hiding place. It's about the information imbalance and knowing how the other side will interpret the information.
At best, if you're just another comment patting yourself on the back, all you've done is create more noise. Which enables propaganda. At worst, you're helping train yourself and others to be like my cat.
- thriftwy 3y agoThe documents (PDFs linked inline in the article) are insightful. I haven't checked the metadata and my PDF viewer reports correctable encoding errors, but the contents look legit: language/jargon gives no reason to suggest these are fake.
- djhn 3y agoIm sorry could you explain this cat training strategy? What is the purpose? How did it come qbout?
- godelski 3y agoWhen cats are scared they hide. In an actual emergency I need to be able to grab my cat. This isn't so great if my cat hides by tucking herself behind the washing machine. If she instead thinks hiding under the table is a legitimate hiding spot I can quickly grab her when it is actually needed. Training is simple. Be good at finding cats. When cat is in good hiding place, always make it known that you know and if they go to a place that is annoying to get to, extract them. Make the process annoying or uncomfortable (not harmful) so they have a bad association with it. But we also need positive reinforcement. When an easy to extract spot is used, pretend you can't find them. Make an excuse to call them. Make a big display. Walk around the house, calling them. Walk right past where they are and even get close. Cats naturally play hide and seek as a game, so we're just doing this. Basically you are inverting the reward function on the hide and seek game.