20 ms·
That's not the legal measure. If in fact they were both written identically, but independently there is no infringement. If it's totally obvious, but it was cop
by ars 15y ago
That's not the legal measure. If in fact they were both written identically, but independently there is no infringement. If it's totally obvious, but it was copied then there is infringement.
The takeaway is write it yourself - don't copy it without permission, even if it's so obvious. (And if it's so obvious then there really is hardly a reason to even copy it in the first place.)
- polshaw 15y agoand how, generally, is this provable? (at least, to produce 'reasonable doubt' to a layman) (ignoring that the guy seems to have said he copy-pasted here.)
- ars 15y agoWhy ignore it? That's exactly how.
- myko 15y agoOf course in this case the person who wrote it is also the same person who copied it.
- __alexs 15y agoI thought the case was not even about copyright infringement of code but of the APIs i.e. the function names and arguments? The OpenJDK is GPL'd after all, and well, an argument could be made that Google are infringing by distributing GPLd rangeCheck with the Apache license, Oracle aren't doing that afaik.
- ars 15y agoThere is more than one issue. The big one of the API's, and a smaller issue of a very small amount of outright copying already admitted to by google.
- __alexs 15y agoIf the Java APIs are copyrightable, which part of the OpenJDK GPL release doesn't provide Google with a GPL copyright license to them then?
- fulafel 15y agoSo you're saying that if I copy "for (i = 0; i < 100; i++)" then it's infringment, and there's no requirement of originality for copyright protection?
- cullen 15y agoOh dear, my freshmen are in a heap of trouble.