3 ms·
>1) ECC is almost free if done at scale (e.g. every computer). The only reason it costs extra is that it is only done for high-paying customers and in limited v
by gruez 3y ago
>1) ECC is almost free if done at scale (e.g. every computer). The only reason it costs extra is that it is only done for high-paying customers and in limited volume.
A ECC DRAM module contains 9 chips rather than 8. I'm not sure how you can claim that's "almost free" unless you have a very loose definition of "almost free".
>2) Computer crashes cost lives. If e.g. your doctor's device has an issue mid-surgery, you potentially pay.
Sounds like a good reason to regulate medical devices and force them to undergo certification as well. Surely you wouldn't want the the computer to have ECC memory, but it decides to reboot for a 2 hour update?
>3) It's good for the economy. In either case, the cost savings of not having a call center rep say "Wait a minute. My computer just crashed." far outweighs the costs.
If this is true, why do we need the government to step in? Why aren't businesses doing this themselves out of self interest?
>4) It's critical for resilience. Disasters (solar flares, EMP, etc.) are rare, but if every computer destroys data, we have a systemic problem.
ECC protects against solar flares and EMP? That's new.
>6) That's not to mention dual-market uses. E.g. if we need to ramp up military production, medical production, etc. next crisis, our infrastructure should be ready for it.
1. DRAM modules aren't made in the US, they're made in asian countries with cheap labor. If there's a military crisis, we'd be screwed regardless
2. As mentioned above, ECC DRAM modules are basically the same as non-ECC modules but with an extra chip. The only work to retool a line from non-ECC to ECC is to change the PCBs. Thus the supposed benefits is negligible, unless for whatever reason the military needs a massive amount of desktops.
- adrian_b 3y agoAlmost free means that the 12.5% extra cost for memory chips may mean 10% extra manufacturing cost for the memory modules and that may mean less than 5% of the total cost of a computer with 64 GB DRAM (not counting monitor, SSDs and other peripherals, which would drive the percentage to be much lower) and even less for computers having less memory.
- frognumber 3y ago> A ECC DRAM module contains 9 chips rather than 8. I'm not sure how you can claim that's "almost free" unless you have a very loose definition of "almost free". I do. Let's do the math here. A typical computer has 8GB RAM. That's under $20 at my local retail store. We're talking a $2 price difference. That's with the methods used today. The overhead can go arbitrarily low if we adopt techniques used in nonvolatile storage and work in larger blocks of bits. $2 is less than the cost of a tiny fraction of a crash. > Surely you wouldn't want the the computer to have ECC memory, but it decides to reboot for a 2 hour update? A broader regulatory regime would certainly be good. > If this is true, why do we need the government to step in? Why aren't businesses doing this themselves out of self interest? Mostly, because businesses can focus on a finite number of things. A $20 benefit which costs $2 to implement stops making sense if it means your local clinic needs to have someone on-staff who can do an ROI computation on adopting ECC. It's cheaper to buy something sub-optimal. Again, that's where centralization and regulation helps. > ECC protects against solar flares and EMP? That's new. That's literally what they're there for. ECC primarily protects against bit flips, which are the result of random radiation. Mild flares will flip a few bits which ECC will correct. Severe ones will flip a lot of bits, which ECC will detect, and the computer can shut down before destroying more data. > 1. DRAM modules aren't made in the US, they're made in asian countries with cheap labor. If there's a military crisis, we'd be screwed regardless I'm not sure what you mean by "modules," but DRAM PCBs are easy to assemble. They can be made in the US overnight. DRAM chips are primarily made in the US (Micron), Korea (Samsung), and Taiwan (TSMC). https://www.micron.com/manufacturing-expansion https://www.micron.com/manufacturing-expansion And not all crises are military. > The only work to retool a line from non-ECC to ECC is to change the PCBs. Thus the supposed benefits is negligible, unless for whatever reason the military needs a massive amount of desktops. If all you need is memory, that's true. If you also want motherboards and processors which will take those chips, that's harder. If you don't want bit flips in your computation, that's impossible without redesigning all CPUs. Academic CPUs can do error-correcting computation at nominal cost, but there isn't a market incentive to bring that to market.
- thfuran 3y ago>>2) Computer crashes cost lives. If e.g. your doctor's device has an issue mid-surgery, you potentially pay. >Sounds like a good reason to regulate medical devices and force them to undergo certification as well. Surely you wouldn't want the the computer to have ECC memory, but it decides to reboot for a 2 hour update? Did you know that medical reports are frequently viewed on consumer or consumer-grade hardware? Or that there is software that is classified as a class II medical device that runs on iOS devices and commodity desktops? Or that class III devices like pacemakers now often use phone apps for things like managing telemetry? It's all well and good to make sure the hardware in the OR is reliable, but that's woefully insufficient.