3 ms·
This is old research (2018) that has been blown completely out of proportion by news media. It's one of several small studies that gets circulated from time to
by Aurornis 3y ago
This is old research (2018) that has been blown completely out of proportion by news media. It's one of several small studies that gets circulated from time to time as if it disproves that weight loss is possible or something, but it doesn't.
Look at the actual study details:
> Thirty-five (22 females) adults with severe obesity (body mass index: 42.5 ± 5.0 kg/m2) underwent a 2-yr WL program focusing on diet and exercise.
They only looked at 22 women with severe obesity on a rapid and aggressive weight loss program. Drawing conclusions from this tiny group and their abnormally aggressive program isn’t relevant to the average person trying to regulate their weight or steadily move toward a healthier weight target over many years.
- MattGaiser 3y agoIs there any research on long term weight loss that argues a meaningful amount of weight loss is reasonably possible? https://www.vox.com/2016/5/10/11649210/biggest-loser-weight-loss https://www.vox.com/2016/5/10/11649210/biggest-loser-weight-... Vox has an article on it supposedly working, but the results are not what anyone who is overweight would call successful. > The results at year eight are heartening. Eight years later and 50.3 percent of the intensive lifestyle intervention group and 35.7 percent of the usual care group were maintaining losses of ≥5 percent, while 26.9 percent of the intensive group and 17.2 percent of the usual care group were maintaining losses of ≥10 percent. In layman’s terms, half lost nothing. Half of the losers lost so little that they wouldn’t notice. 1/4 lost 10%. Basically nobody who was obese reached a normal weight.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoYou don’t have to reach a normal weight to make a significant difference to your health and risk of death. Maintaining a 10% weight loss is absolutely noticeable in health measures. https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/moderate-weight-loss-improves-heart-health/ https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/moderate-weight-loss-improve...
- makeitdouble 3y ago> Individuals in the study were instructed to eat either low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets— about 1,200 to 1,500 calories per day for women and 1,500 to 1,800 for men. If they're splitting groups, why didn't they bother having a control group with no diet change and only the study follow-up ? I couldn't see any link to the actual study, was there more details ?
- petesergeant 3y agoCould you recommend some new research that shows alternative findings that you think is better?
- eps 3y agoEven if the GP can't do that, it doesn't negate the fact that this research is for an extreme edge case and clearly doesn't extrapolate as the title implies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- makeitdouble 3y agoTBF the research in this field is bound to be on cases that can't be extrapolated. In contrast to more lab ready fundamental experiments on cell behaviors for instance, diet or metabolism need humans each living their own life and have too many uncontrolable factors to come out with a study that can withstand scrutiny.
- prepend 3y agoI think the point is that this isn’t an extreme edge case and that this research is still useful, even if it isn’t perfect. So the ask for superior research is valid since this is useful.
- sn9 3y agoStudies are constrained by all kinds of factors. It's more useful to look at populations that reliably manipulate their body composition as a learnable, teachable skill like athletes in weight classes and bodybuilders. The fundamentals have been known and practiced for decades at this point.
- petesergeant 3y agoMost athletes haven’t been obese, and many body builders are taking supplements highly likely to confound studies. None of this comes anywhere near to countering the study’s finding that having been obese fucks your satiety for a long time.
- n8henrie 3y agoTo my knowledge this mirrors the largest meta-analysis I'm aware of (JAMA? Probably way back in 2008 or so though, man I'm getting old) which showed that virtually all diets have a return to baseline weight by 2 years. Will see if I can find the citation. Do you have a recommended counter-example?