7 ms·
So I did a little research on this, and it seems to be two main things. Partly yes it seems to be a question of stability -- you're not going to bore and leave
by crazygringo 3y ago
So I did a little research on this, and it seems to be two main things.
Partly yes it seems to be a question of stability -- you're not going to bore and leave just a couple of feet of soil above, because of the way you want the arch of the tunnel to support itself, and that's not going to be strong enough. And close to the surface you've got looser soil etc. Going deeper does provide greater stability, in a way that isn't needed for cut-and-cover because that is supported by steel beams, not arches. But this doesn't generally require you to go crazy deep.
The bigger factor behind these crazy-deep tunnels seems to be pre-existing infrastructure. If you're doing cut-and-cover, you're digging out all of the infrastructure first and then replacing it -- it's highly disruptive. While if you're boring a tunnel, you need to go below everything that already exists -- sewers, water lines, deep building foundations, pre-existing subway lines that it crosses underneath, etc.
- JoshTriplett 3y ago> The bigger factor behind these crazy-deep tunnels seems to be pre-existing infrastructure. If you're doing cut-and-cover, you're digging out all of the infrastructure first and then replacing it -- it's highly disruptive. While if you're boring a tunnel, you need to go below everything that already exists -- sewers, water lines, deep building foundations, pre-existing subway lines that it crosses underneath, etc. Makes perfect sense! And yeah, it's yet another case of path dependence: we'd build far different cities if we had the option of designing "from scratch" rather than layering retrofit over retrofit under retrofit. In an ideal world, we'd have tunnels connecting B1/B2 of every major building in a city, and many people's trips would be elevator-transit-elevator.