3 ms·
> Sounds like a parallel to Tasmania: the tech level kept ratcheting down, as they lost tech like crops and had no way to regain them, When did the Tasmanian p
by defrost 3y ago
> Sounds like a parallel to Tasmania: the tech level kept ratcheting down, as they lost tech like crops and had no way to regain them,
When did the Tasmanian pre colonial people have crops?
https://www.utas.edu.au/library/companion_to_tasmanian_history/A/Aboriginal%20life%20pre-invasion.htm https://www.utas.edu.au/library/companion_to_tasmanian_histo...
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Tasmanian-Aboriginal-people https://www.britannica.com/topic/Tasmanian-Aboriginal-people
https://www.britannica.com/event/Black-War https://www.britannica.com/event/Black-War
They arrived by walking across the Bassian Plain (now the Bass Strait) to a land with highlands locked by ice.
There are many sources that discuss their gathering of plants, sea foods, hunting, etc.
Which sources talk about their agrarian crop planting? More to the point which sources discuss the loss of crop planting?
The big issue in pre colonial studies these recent years appears to be a lack of past recognition of any non "hunter gather" practices - the early settlers destroyed semi permanent infrastructures such as rock pool fish traps (some quite extensive that were blown up to allow river boats through), they didn't recognise non European land and plant tending practices, etc.
There's a lack of solid study on what practices were actually taking place in different parts of Australia, and a lot of "imagined" commentary.
- wisty 3y agoSmall scale agriculture and aquaculture has been long understood. The tipping point where the use of labour and soil to create surlus labour, which is then used to conquer more soil is why agriculture led to a "culture" or "civilisation"(according to 19th century hisorians IIRC). 19th century hisorians argued (I think) that superior societies had superior technology, which made them even more superior. If anything, I think modern academics are too concerned about refuting the premise that Western civilisation ended up with superior technology, rather than simply accepting that they did (in most ways) but that this didn't always make them morally superior.
- defrost 3y agoI freely admit to knowing very little about "19th century hisorians" and their ideas about "surlus labour" .. I also am unaware how this relates to the above theory about how pre colonial Tasmanians had and then lost "tech like crops". I do have a notion that metrics such as "superior" tend to be value judgements based on particular axioms .. some people feel that storing their nuts for winter, creating an industrial revolution, eliminating other life forms on the planet through expansion, and altering the atmosphere to be a superior approach. Others seemingly enjoyed a particular quality of life for several tens of thousands of years by spending some time gathering food and most of the time telling stories. Clearly different value systems are at play.
- simonh 3y agoCan we really put that down to value systems? You’re implying that the latter group made a choice, but for that to be true they would have to have developed the new technologies and chose not to use them.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoyou don't invent guns and grain silos because you're having a great time, you do it because resources are scarce and contested. Necessity is the mother of invention they say. Personally I don't subscribe much to notions of choice, but in that framework, I would say the pre-agrarians made the choice not to develop agriculture and all the rest.
- Natsu 3y agoIs there some place that resources were not scarce or contested? Competition for resources happens across the animal kingdom as far as I can tell.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoThe degree to which resources are scarce and contested varies geographically yes. Around me there is not a constraint on the deer population, resources are plentiful for them and outside of hunting season there is little contesting the deer. Eventually the deer population grows enough that the lifeforms they share space with decide to, mm, contest their expansion, but there are places and periods in which populations can grow unconstrained for a while. I suppose I was making the point that humans maintaining a certain way of life for tens of thousands of years may have lived in a way where resources and rival tribes were not an issue, and hence, had little motivation to develop defensive weaponry / collect starvation rations for rainy days.
- defrost 3y agoThere are many places across the globe (equatorial regions) that don't have the severe winter "nothing grows at all" problem that some would argue drove European cultures to advance food storage and intensive agriculture techniques. There's always some kind of scarcity everywhere, sure, but the key notion here is regular predictable extreme scarcity that can be planned for and hedged against with a considered amount of energy and advance preparation.
- masklinn 3y agoAboriginal Tasmanians arrived there 40000 years ago when it was still a peninsula, and got cut off of Australia 8000 years ago, around the dawn of agriculture and animal husbandry. Afaik agriculture never made it to Australia (at least not in any sort of large scale) before the western invasion, let alone to Tasmania.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- gwern 3y ago> When did the Tasmanian pre colonial people have crops? My 'they' in "they lost tech like crops" referred to the Canary Islanders, as discussed by OP where the botanical evidence shows crops disappearing gradually over time.
- defrost 3y agoIf that was the case then to what parallel technology in Tasmania were you alluding to as "ratcheting downwards" ? Also, population growth in the early stages of human history was important to establish enough labour to create an "idle" (as in "people|time not spent scrabbling for food|clothing|shelter") class able to advance technology for progress. That's been increasingly non essential since post WWII with the rise of semi and fully autonomous mining | processing | production. Smaller and smaller numbers are people are required to extract resources and meet demand for what is a population excess wrt strain put on the planets environment an atmosphere by current and growing consumption demands.