4 ms·
"However, the bulk of the content appears aimed at creating a sense of dismay over the state of America without any clear partisan bent." This is a key point. T
by Animats 3y ago
"However, the bulk of the content appears aimed at creating a sense of dismay over the state of America without any clear partisan bent." This is a key point. The objective of modern Russian propaganda is to sow confusion and reap inaction. See McMaster's "Battlegrounds" book.[1] The winning strategy for Russia in eastern Europe is a non-united United States, and if possible a non-united European Union.
Classical propaganda is heavy drum-beating for how great your side is. That goes back to at least Cicero, increased when newspapers came along, and really got going during WWII. That stuff rapidly gets boring, and is usually aimed, at least in part, at stroking the backs of your own political leaders.
Increasing the noise level so that no one can believe anything isn't a new idea. British "black" propaganda during WWII used it quite a bit. "Rumor-mongering" was once a thing.[2] But it didn't scale.
It's picked up in recent years partly because it's much more effective when combined with ad targeting. This is a problem.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._R._McMaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._R._McMaster
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vaupcu2qqI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vaupcu2qqI
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 3y agoSee also, the part from 2:22:53 onwards: Vladislav Surkov and propaganda methods of making people distrust everything and sow strife and confusion. https://youtu.be/Gr7T07WfIhM?t=8567 https://youtu.be/Gr7T07WfIhM?t=8567 https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=vladislav+surkov https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=vladislav...
- Razengan 3y ago> The winning strategy for Russia in eastern Europe is a non-united United States, and if possible a non-united European Union. > Classical propaganda is heavy drum-beating for how great your side is. Isn't that a form of "classical propaganda" in itself? "We are perfect. There is nothing wrong with us. Only our enemies say we have problems." or "All our problems are caused by THEM" or "If you don't like America you MUST be a commie!" (one of the worst slurs in post-WW2 USA)
- llamaimperative 3y agoThe “quotes” you gave are totally and utterly unrelated to anything GP said.
- Razengan 3y agoIt's been the general gist of America ever since Trump stood for election, and before that, it was the ""Terrorists"". Now I guess there's also China.
- ethanbond 3y agoYour observation is just that conflict exists in the world and it seems to have existed at many times in the past. Of course you can state that fact with an aura of mystery and intrigue, but it’s plainly obvious and not that interesting.
- Razengan 3y agoIt's not just conflict, those are "boogeymen"
- atoav 3y agoNo you don't get it. Splitting your enemies this way is not the same as saying "us good, them bad". First you would not say anything about your intentions and how you are at all. Example: The way Putin has dealt with opposition within his own country was not to say how great his party was and how bad the others were. It was to financially support some of the opposition group, arrest others, invite other publically, have others beaten up by thugs and have it change by the day. This way they can't trust what's real anymore, they lose hope not because there is none, but because it isn't clear what even to hope for and whom to hope with. In the same time his party just is and wins by being in comparison more or less a clear, safe and before all known position to bet on — the devil that you know and all that. So the confusion, the contradiction is the goal. That's why Tucker gets invited and Navalny murdered shortly after.
- naet 3y agoThere's plenty of successful "classical" propaganda in the modern era, like Tucker Carlson interviewing Putin, and his subsequently tweeting about how much better the cities/subways/groceries/MacDonalds are in Russia than they are in America. I like to browse both far left and far right social media to see what different circles are talking about, and a lot of the far right are coming around to be pro Russia (way more than I would have ever expected given US history). There's also the conservative house representatives majority who are likely to continue blocking any additional military aid to the Ukraine. So on a whole it seems to me that Russian government has been highly effective at advancing their political agenda within the USA recently.
- dralley 3y ago>There's plenty of successful "classical" propaganda in the modern era, like Tucker Carlson interviewing Putin, and his subsequently tweeting about how much better the cities/subways/groceries/MacDonalds are in Russia than they are in America. I'm not sure that's actually successful. Even a lot of conservatives seem put off by Tucker's recent activities, especially with the Navalny news today.
- richbell 3y agoHis part about groceries has resonated with a lot of people. "Biden has destroyed the US, and groceries that cost easily $400+ only cost $100 in Russia." Of course, he made no mention of how much $100 is to the average Russian's income proportional to the average American's income.
- internet2000 3y agoIt's astonishing how easy it is to get people to forget about purchasing power. Even here in HN you often see people use that in "they don't make 'em like they used to" type threads.
- ape_key 3y agoInflation just turns people’s brains off. Some of us just panic and react without thinking about why food is getting more expensive or what policies will improve the world for us now and our children in the future. When people are hangry, they vote for the loudest monkey.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]