3 ms·
It is somewhat of an humorous thing. For decades the US has interfered with other countries' election trying to have the person the US felt was better for them
by dylan604 3y ago
It is somewhat of an humorous thing. For decades the US has interfered with other countries' election trying to have the person the US felt was better for them to be in charge. Now, other countries are saavy enough to do it back, but the effort is much more effective because of the 24/7 firehose of information that is the internet. The lock-in echo chamber effect of social platforms took that effectiveness knob and turned it to 11.
The US used to fly planes to drop leaflets over population centers, so there was the expense of creating/printing the leaflets, the expense of flying them into place, the risk of invading foreign airspace, blah blah. Now, it's some keyboard warriors sitting in an office using a exponentially more efficient delivery system.
What goes around, comes around
- whatshisface 3y agoI doubt there's any evidence it's effective, only evidence that a lot of people with "analytics platforms" found a way to get paid to browse Twitter. (Oh no! China's posting memes on the internet!)
- dylan604 3y agoThe fact that there are so many people re-posting/sharing and joining telegram groups pretty much shows how it's effective. The fact that some of the "proof" from some of these hard core believers is directly the content from these spammers also shows its effectiveness. I think there's plenty of evidence that counters your claim.
- whatshisface 3y agoIf social media engagement corresponded to real changes, Kony would be behind bars. :-) That's why "twitter metrics" are such a perfect closed system; they're already optimized for engagement so of course their content engages the people observing the metrics.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 3y agoNaïve perspective. Those as campaigns you see are probably designed by some expensive tech company that hires people with good resumes and bad skills to fleece their customers. Maybe I’m wrong and you’re caught in the dragnet of good campaigns that somehow can’t figure out targeting despite all the creepy tools at their disposal.
- RealityVoid 3y agoThe thing is, people did not have the option on voting "What to do with Kony?" Whereas with elections they have a real, actionable thing that they were going to engage this anyway. The activation energy is much lower for this. There are lots of things going on here, I'd be careful about being too dismissive about this.
- ben_w 3y agoIndeed. Based on the adverts I am shown, Facebook thinks I'm a meat loving American from Florida who moved to the town of Waterlooville in the UK, who enjoys gambling on horse races, owns a dog, and works in graphic design; when I am actually a vegetarian Brit who moved to Berlin, is bored by spectator sports, who has never owned any pet, and who works as a software developer. Whoever paid money to show me those ads, wasted it.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agohttps://www.voanews.com/a/purported-text-of-secret-cable-shows-us-ire-at-imran-khan-/7219123.html https://www.voanews.com/a/purported-text-of-secret-cable-sho... So this is funny. USA wanted Pakistani prime minister out so when he leaked the cable showing American meddling, Pakistani courts found him guilty of leaking state secrets and had him removed from office? Recently he was awarded 5 year jail sentence for among other things, for having "improper marriage" with his wife. As in her waiting period apparently from divorce - remarriage wasn't enough but that being a mere irregularity, courts had to find him guilty because they want to crucify him. Why?
- dylan604 3y agoObviously, things don't always go to plan.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agowhat do you mean. he is out of office
- Paradigma11 3y agoThat is not meddling that is informing your foreign partners about your official position. And, shockingly, friendly government are treated different than hostile ones.
- sigmoid10 3y agoYou should look up how the Cambridge Analytica scandal influenced the 2016 presidential election and all the stuff that came up during the congressional hearings. It is highly likely that Trump won because of it. They not only used the leaked facebook data from 70 million americans to build models of who was voting for who, they also used it for targeted ads. For example, they knew that people from certain groups were highly unlikely to ever vote for Trump, no matter how many propaganda ads they were fed. But they didn't let all the personal data they had go to waste. They instead showed these people "news" articles via ads about Clinton and her alleged weakness, or her husband's infidelity. This way they made people who would have otherwise opposed Trump simply not vote at all. The rest is history.
- dgfitz 3y ago> The US used to fly planes to drop leaflets over population centers, so there was the expense of creating/printing the leaflets, the expense of flying them into place, the risk of invading foreign airspace, blah blah. Is your point that this is so inexpensive that it’s hardly a line item on a budget? Printing leaflets and flying a plane. Seems a lot cheaper than defending Ukraine from a madman terrorist. A madman terrorist in cahoots with PRC.
- dylan604 3y agoNo. For the US, the DoD spends exponentially more on Post-Its than one of these "missions". But if you're China/Iran/North Korea/Russia, you don't even have to spend that money at all. But again, the money isn't really the thing. It's just a comment. The effectiveness of the leaflets greatly depended on the number of people that actually found them. Social platforms allow you to have your post placed directly in front of the eyeballs of your target. You even get analytics on the campaign. I was just using old vs new techniques to show how much more modern day shenanigans are
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ericmcer 3y agoThis attitude is so nuts to me… like our parents/grandparents did bad things so we should just let the country burn because we deserve it.
- jvanderbot 3y agoAgree - also, to believe that "only" our grandparents did this and so "only" we deserve it is crazy. This had to have happened on all scales by all major powers since the dawn of time.
- dylan604 3y agoWhere is that coming from? I just stated that I think it's humorous that the karma slap is happening. Obviously, there are "attempts" to prevent it which is the same thing that the countries the US targeted do.
- creato 3y agoCharacterizing influence as "bad" no matter what is also questionable. Yes, the US attempted influenced other countries especially during the cold war. So did Russia. Would you rather live in a country influenced by the US, or Russia?
- jvanderbot 3y agoIs this a fair characterization? It's factually correct that USA interfered before and also that others are interfering now in USA's elections. But the allusion to a "only USA then" and "lol, anti-usa now" seems wrong. Surely all major powers tried to influence all elections of interest wherever and whenever they could? Both then and now?
- dylan604 3y agoWhere did you get that from my comment? I don't recall hearing Russia overflying US cities dropping leaflets, but there's plenty of stories of the US doing the very thing. I wasn't impling the US was the only ones doing it nor that they are not doing it now. However, it IS happening to the US now, and it is effective. It's also much more difficult to deny a leaflet drop, but we have people here on a very technically oriented forum denying the effectiveness of these campaigns. I guess it's a positive that they are not being denied that they are happening.??
- jvanderbot 3y agoI'm actually not interested in the effectiveness, because as you say that's kind of a bad foundation to base a moral / retribution story off. I'm just honest here, I have to assume we've been meddling in each other's leadership and civil directions for a long long time. Like forever. And I just can't believe that the USA is somehow unique either as a perpetrator or a victim. I could believe that there was a time when the USA was more effective and that time may not be right how, but the "coming back to bite you" argument doesn't ring true.
- dylan604 3y agoTo me, the difference is the type of government. The US attacking the internet of North Korea seems strange since it is so closed off, but it is very effective for DPRK to use against the US. The fact that the internet is so open to the US citizens means that directly influencing the population via the source of their addiction is just very humorous to me. Maybe it's just part of my disdain against the socials, but you got to admit, there's just a bit of chef's kiss about it
- msla 3y agoWe can't talk about any other country here without someone bringing it back around to America, as if America were the Main Character of the whole world. Other countries exist, other countries don't need America to define themselves, other countries can be without needing to be in relation to America.