4 ms·
> Financing it. These programs are monumentally expensive. You need to get the money from somewhere. The easiest place to take it is via the money printer and t
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Financing it. These programs are monumentally expensive. You need to get the money from somewhere. The easiest place to take it is via the money printer and the second is from the rich.
This is not actually that hard because they're only expensive on paper.
Right now you have a slew of means tested programs with phase outs that amount to high marginal tax rates on the poor. Meanwhile we try to do the opposite with the tax system and have higher marginal rates on the rich. These largely cancel out, if not impose higher marginal rates on the poor than the rich.
With a UBI you can use a flat tax system because the UBI rather than the tax system is what makes it progressive, which has the added benefit of simplifying the tax system. Then everyone is paying the same tax rate, which puts a higher "tax rate" on low and middle income people but only on paper, because you've eliminated the benefits phase outs and they get to keep the UBI, which more than offsets it.
The result is that you have a small tax increase on the rich and a small increase in transfer payments to the poor/middle class, but the main benefit is the dramatic increase in simplicity and the reduction in bureaucracy and administrative overhead for administering all of the separate programs it would replace.
> Diminishing effects. A bit more money is great when everybody else in your local economy didn't get it. But when everybody gets it, things just become more expensive.
Except that the average person doesn't actually have any more money, since it's all transfer payments. Someone making $30,000 got some additional money but someone making $70,000, even though they do receive the UBI, has still received less money than they paid in tax to fund it.
And this is what already happens, but much less efficiently, through various existing means-tested programs that would no longer be needed.
- CityOfThrowaway 3y agoWhat you're saying might be true. My sense is that the political project of doing a full-on tax-and-entitlement reform that results in a more sane system is impossible in the US. At the ideological/theoretical level, I absolutely believe that there exists a radically more optimal way distribute the existing tax burden and funds. But at the practical level, I think we have to do the equivalent of a long-term refactor. Any changes we make must be within the existing system and make sense on their own. Our only real option is to steer our way, digestible diff-by-digestible diff, to a better future.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoSo do it that way. Don't start off with a $12,000/year UBI, eliminate SNAP and instead give everyone a tax credit in the same amount. Adjust the tax brackets to make the math work out. Then do the same thing with housing subsidies, and Medicaid, until all the largest programs are gone. At which point you can see the results and start asking why we shouldn't just do everything that's still left at once.
- CityOfThrowaway 3y agoI would support this!
- beej71 3y ago> you can use a flat tax system Maybe you could help me with this because I never understood it. It seems like the tiered rates of our tax is the least of our worries. I can see an argument that mathematically it's more complicated than flat, but it's just arithmetic. And practically speaking, nobody does it anyway. The computer figures it out, or they look in the tax table. And that's the same thing they're going to be doing if we have a flat tax, right? You mentioned the additional complexities of the tax code, which I agree are titanic, but doing away with those doesn't mean we need to do away with tiered tax rates. I guess in my mind, flat tax isn't really much of a gain. And we have to be extra careful to not make it regressive (with something like, as you suggest, UBI.) Am I missing something?
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> I can see an argument that mathematically it's more complicated than flat, but it's just arithmetic. No, it's more complicated because then you need to keep track of things at all. Suppose you go to your job and make a salary and they withhold some of it for the IRS. Then you take a side gig and make a little extra money, or you owned some stock and got a dividend, or anything else that changes your taxable income. Now you have to file taxes to reconcile all of this and determine what your tax rate even is. If there was a single rate then your employer takes out that much and gives it to the IRS and your side gig takes out the same percent and gives it to the IRS and your brokerage takes out the same percent and gives it to the IRS and you don't even have a tax return because there is nothing to calculate. Or you can just use VAT and not even have to do withholding. One of the other big things to keep in mind here is that a lot of the conventional wisdom on taxes is PR from rich people/corporations, e.g. claiming that consumption taxes don't tax the rich because they don't spend most of their income. It sounds plausible until you realize that what the super rich and international corporations actually do is keep their money offshore so they don't have to pay income tax on the interest until they repatriate it, which they then never do and instead take out a loan when they want to buy something. So it's actually the income tax they don't pay and a consumption tax they would have to whenever they buy things. > doing away with those doesn't mean we need to do away with tiered tax rates. Tiered tax rates are a hideous hack to begin with to avoid people having to do calculus. What you really want is a continuous curve where effective tax rate starts off negative and increases up to some maximum rate with increasing income or spending. Which is exactly what you get with a flat tax + UBI.