4 ms·
Do you like procedurally generated content in games? Or do you quickly find it boring and empty, devoid of soul? I thought about it, and while part of my overa
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
Do you like procedurally generated content in games? Or do you quickly find it boring and empty, devoid of soul?
I thought about it, and while part of my overall dislike of procgen in games comes from it being lazy and repetitive (too easy to spot the patterns), another part comes just from realizing there's nothing behind it. No mind, no plan, just RNG that I can keep rolling to get variations of the same theme.
(There's also a sense of loneliness - when everyone is consuming unique content, it stops being a topic of conversation, because there's no shared experience anymore.)
- vidarh 3y agoMy issue with procedurally generated content is that it is often a replacement for effort, and so the problem is not lack of a mind behind it, but as you note that it is often lazy and repetitive, and so simply not good. Humans can be lazy and make repetitive crap too, and when they do I'll consider it just as crap whether or not their underlying ideas were amazing.
- asadotzler 3y agoHumans may be lazy and produce crap, but AI is lazy and produces crap. See the difference?
- vidarh 3y agoNo, I don't agree that's a meaningful difference.
- asadotzler 3y agounable to discern a difference between "may be" and "is", perhaps you missed that day of school?
- Towaway69 3y agoAnd who described, designed and built AI algorithms? See the connection? /s
- TeMPOraL 3y agoFWIW, we're not really describing and designing AI algorithms anymore - we're taking a simple algorithm and keep throwing heaps of data at it, until it designs itself.
- falcor84 3y agoWhat about taking a solitary walk in the forest. Assuming no Intelligent Design, the trees and everything else there was created without any guiding plan. And if it's a large forest, it's reasonably likely that by the time the next person goes there, even if they end up following the same path, the vegetation will look entirely different. Does that uniqueness of "content" make the forest devoid of soul? And if you do accept Intelligent Design, then arguably the RNG of AI images is also guided by it to the same extent.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI can't answer that - I'm bored out of my skull by nature. Always have been. Solitary walks in forests or parks, I find them great for clearing out my thoughts - I'll be thinking about lots of things, but at no point I'll be thinking about nature around me. Which is perhaps preferable to taking a walk in an urban neighbourhood, because I'll always find something interesting there that will let me avoid uncomfortable thoughts. (Except in context of biotech or dynamic systems; those are lenses that make me appreciate nature, but I realize this is an engineer's point of view - I'm excited about possibility of applying what we're learning, and/or repurposing what's already there.)
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoWith nature, I believe it's interesting because unlike something like Minecraft, where a single chunk is entirely dictated by math, everything in nature is dictated by life. A fully grown tree exists because a previous animal didn't eat it as a sapling. A hole which was dug by rabbits now houses snakes. A path has been created by various animals moving between the trees, so there's less vegetation there, and it allows for an easier walk through the forest...but that path wasn't there originally and animals had to choose to go that way and make the path. Whether there is intelligent design or not, you can see the effects of life existing and changing in a forest. You can detect choices, individual and collective.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoWe could argue the universe follows mathematical laws in the same way. It's more a matter of how complex those laws are. With gen AI we finally see human-created mathematical rules that approach the scale of natural ones.