2 ms·
I hear this argument all of the time here in conservative Idaho, that social security provides more of a benefit than what's been paid in. For many people (the
by twoodfin 15y ago
I hear this argument all of the time here in conservative Idaho, that social security provides more of a benefit than what's been paid in.
For many people (the subset of the working poor who end up living a long time) this is absolutely the case. For many other people (those with a below average lifespan or substantially above average career earnings) Social Security is a terrible deal and has no chance under the current formula of paying them back what they put in. Even if you don't count what their employers had to contribute, which might otherwise have been spent on higher wages.
It seems inevitable that the SS payroll tax cap will be lifted without substantial changes to the benefit formula, which will make it an even worse deal for, say, the median earner with a post-graduate degree.
That doesn't demonstrate that it's a bad program, just that's it's redistributive and we should be honest about that fact. A smart, productive 35-year old should absolutely not rely on Social Security for her retirement, assuming she doesn't want her lifestyle to drop off a cliff at age 68 or whatever the retirement age is by then.
- legutierr 15y agoSocial Security is redistributive much in the same way that flood or fire insurance is redistributive: those who never need it have overpaid, and those who do need it have underpaid. The flaw that exists in the current discourse regarding Social Security is that the program is framed as a retirement program. It is not. It is "end of life insurance". In fact, one correct term to use in describing programs such as Social Security is "Social Insurance": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_insurance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_insurance
- twoodfin 15y agoNo, it's not redistributive merely like fire or flood insurance. My $300,000 house will cost the same amount to insure as my similarly-housed neighbor who makes twice as much. And the additional cost to insure a $400,000 house isn't typically greater than the reduction in cost to insure a $200,000 house. That's not how social security works. The benefit curve drops off dramatically in relation to the "pay-in" curve: http://www.ssa.gov/oact/COLA/piaformula.html http://www.ssa.gov/oact/COLA/piaformula.html And again, things will get worse when, seemingly inevitably, the payroll tax cap is lifted without substantially modifying the "bend points". A dollar you contribute to SS on your earnings over $56,000 is worth half the benefits of a dollar contributed under that amount.