3 ms·
From looking at a variety of sources, my best, rough understanding is that 1. Data centers & Bitcoin are using about the same amount of electricity, about 2% o
by verdverm 3y ago
From looking at a variety of sources, my best, rough understanding is that
1. Data centers & Bitcoin are using about the same amount of electricity, about 2% of the US energy production each
2. AI is a subset of data center usage, but expect this portion to drastically rise and drive up the energy usage
3. Data centers & AI are continuingly becoming more efficient while Bitcoin becomes less so by design, L2 crypto is an efficiency play for crypto more generally
- x86x87 3y agoNot sure where bitcoin got dragged into the conversation. Also not sure how BTC becomes less efficient by design. The hardware BTC is mined on has improved exponentially over time moving from general purpose cpus to gpus to custom asics.
- ta988 3y agoBut what's the relation between that efficiency and the number of hashes computed? My understanding was that difficulty is increasing with efficiency so you end up having to try harder to get a block mined successfully.
- x86x87 3y agoThe difficulty gets periodically adjusted to generate a block roughly every 10 minutes. It's not really about efficiency as it's about computing power and available miners. If it's not economically beneficial to mine (costs more than reward) miners will stop mining leading to the difficulty decreasing which in turns makes it profitable to mine again.
- serf 3y ago>Also not sure how BTC becomes less efficient by design. one of the major key principles behind bitcoin is that the hashing becomes more difficult over time. hardware can't constantly keep parity with difficulty. [0]: https://www.blockchain.com/explorer/charts/difficulty https://www.blockchain.com/explorer/charts/difficulty
- anonym29 3y agoThis is not technically correct, only practically correct. Hashing does not irreversibly become more difficult as a function of time, it becomes more or less difficult as a function of total network hashrate. Now, there has been a strong positive correlation between time and total network hashrate, so for all practical purposes, difficulty has (and likely will continue to) increase over time. That said, if half of all miners went offline overnight, block times would approximately double, and the next difficulty rebalabce would go dramatically lower in an effort to maintain 20 minute block times.
- x86x87 3y agoThat's not how it works. It actually adjusts to the available computing power. This is builtin to the protocol.
- AxelLuktarGott 3y agoThe point of mining is that you don't want new blocks too often because it would create too many forks in your chain. The "difficulty" in mining is by design, if we make better hardware that can generate hashes more quickly then we need to make the valid hashes more rare to keep the property that new blocks are reasonably spaced out.
- anonporridge 3y agoThe entire innovation of Proof of Work (that made bitcoin a success where predecessors failed) is that it is costly in real world energy to corrupt the network. e.g. you can't bullshit your way into finding this number, 000000000000000000024394a1f3cb1a0c16e601a2bd5910635bb2468d2ba316, without expending a huge amount of energy, while you can verify very quickly how many guesses it statistically took to find it. An attacker can't just use words to spin a manipulative narrative, or cut of the head of an organization with a targeted attack. They actually have to commit massive numbers of joules and bit flips. And if an attacker actually acquires that much control over mining power, suddenly they realize they're too heavily invested in the network to want to harm it. In the age of increasing generative AI, proof that you have some tie to real world cost is an increasingly valuable trait.
- latchkey 3y agoFantastic thread: https://twitter.com/LucasNuzzi/status/1758232805882970562 https://twitter.com/LucasNuzzi/status/1758232805882970562
- mistrial9 3y agoare these Botcoin numbers verified at all? that is two percent of some common electrical grid? or remote hydro-power sites or something.. seems like a really large number, and lots of reasons to exaggerate/misrepresent it
- jakeinspace 3y agoThe current bitcoin total hash rate is obviously public information (currently about 6E20 hash/second). I was also able to find a report on average network-wide hashing efficiency, which is obviously self-reported, but is at least in line with logic (just slightly trails the current highest efficiency ASIC miners). That gives around 13 GW of total instantaneous power consumption. The US produced around 4000 TWh last year, which is an average of about 460 GW of power. That would make global bitcoin power consumption equal to about 2.8% of US energy production. It looks like estimates for global energy production are over 30 TWh last year, so that would mean bitcoin is around 1/3rd of one percent of total global power usage. Note that’s just bitcoin, not all of crypto.
- mistrial9 3y agoglobal energy use for BTC mining is equal to X percent of US energy.. that sounds exactly right, and the basis of the question
- pstrateman 3y agoSo bitcoin uses about 0.3% of energy production. That means the 2% claim is an order of magnitude lie.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoThe EIA was recently ordered to start investigating/receiving reports on the actual numbers after a preliminary report indicated it was consuming between 0.6%-2.3% of total US consumption: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61364 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61364
- 3y ago