6 ms·
> How much solar/wind/battery capacity can 34B USD buy!? According to How Big Things Get Done, at least 30B worth. Nuclear plants have some of the worst cost a
by hinkley 3y ago
> How much solar/wind/battery capacity can 34B USD buy!?
According to How Big Things Get Done, at least 30B worth. Nuclear plants have some of the worst cost and time overruns for large projects, wind and solar some of the lowest (beaten only by roads).
And his theory as to why this happens, is that wind, solar, and roads are self-similar. Building the first 10% directly informs you on how to build the next 10%. Everything you learn along the way can be rolled back into the project in a feedback loop.
What you learn shingling a roof or building a nuclear reactor doesn't help this project all that much. It helps the next. And how many nuclear reactors does one worker build in their lifetime? 2? 4? That's not a lot of opportunity for process improvement.
- pstuart 3y agoThis is why if nuclear is to have a future it would be via Small Modular Reactors. But even that appears to be too expensive.
- einpoklum 3y agoIndeed. I mean, I'm not sure the smallness is a key factor, but the modularity for sure and maybe the size limitation comes with that. I'm not much of a fan of nuclear (pun not intended?) and would like to see solar + wind (+ other renewables) cover most of the load. But if enough resources were pooled to design an SMR, with extensive safety studies, lifetime planning, involvement of multiple parties (e.g. scientific and engineering teams from different world states) - I don't think I could really oppose, especially given the global warming situation. Of course - there's "ideal nuclear" and there's real existing nuclear, which is quite different and often very problematic.
- hinkley 3y agoMatt Ferrell posted a video about vertical bifacial solar (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqizLQDi9BM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqizLQDi9BM) last week that has me hopeful for more demand-aligned solar output. They absorb more indirect light, but the main advantage is that hot panels drop in efficiency, and standing them up improves heat dissipation substantially. One of the bits that stood out to me is that it has an output curve that partially lines up with The Duck, because you get a period of low-angle exposure near sunset. I suspect you get quite a drop at high noon, but that's fine as long as not all solar panels in the grid are vertical.
- hinkley 3y agoI've been anti-nuclear for a long time, and SMR is the least unpalatable choice. Not without caveats though. Humans are shit at statistics. Their sense of the aggregate danger of putting 100 'safe' items in close proximity often underestimates the odds by half, and in some cases by an order of magnitude. You might get lucky and lose two personal hard drives in your entire life, but the IT guy managing 100 drives is dealing with failed drives 'all the time'. Backblaze reports on something like 10,000 drives and they are claiming something on the order of 200-300 failures. And I think that's per quarter, not per year. What do you do with an array of reactors where one right in the middle did not fail cleanly?
- littlestymaar 3y ago> And how many nuclear reactors does one worker build in their lifetime? 2? 4? That's not a lot of opportunity for process improvement. France built 58 over 20 years, that's how you make it economical. India says they want to do one a year IIRC, which is probably good enough too.
- adrianN 3y agoFrench nuclear power is still not particularly economical and they didn’t build as many plants as originally planned because of it, nor do they plan to build a sufficient number of new plants to sustain current capacity over the next decades. France justifies the expense with their nuclear bomb program that benefits from a strong civilian nuclear industry.
- MagnumOpus 3y agoFrench nuclear power has a levelized cost of about $70/MWh - which is about the same cost as the levelized cost of solar or wind in France, without most the headaches of intermittency. (Remember the average French person lives further north than the average Canadian...)
- littlestymaar 3y agoExactly, and don't forget that nuclear costs in France are being driven high by wind (and solar, but less so), because it cannot run at its optimal power because it has to reduce produced power when there's wind.
- littlestymaar 3y agoDownvote all you want, when you artificially decrease capacity factor from the average 90% to 65% because you have to accommodate for wind, in an industry when fixed costs are the vast majority of costs, you mathematically raise the cost per MWh…
- Reason077 3y ago
- epistasis 3y agoAccording to this article, the staff for the regulator in Georgia (the only entity in the decision making process looking out for the customers, ratepayers) were banned from even considering the cost of renewables: > Plant Vogtle proceeded with no cost-cap, no consumer protections, and Public Service Commission (PSC) staff were prohibited from conducting analysis comparing the costs of nuclear to clean energy alternatives. https://www.powermag.com/blog/plant-vogtle-not-a-star-but-a-tragedy-for-the-people-of-georgia/ https://www.powermag.com/blog/plant-vogtle-not-a-star-but-a-... At the other pair of reactors started at the same time and with the same design in Soith Carolina, executives are in jail for lying about the project. The SC reactors were also abandoned. Nuclear in the US is so expensive that even starting a new reactor requires considerable corruption.
- asadotzler 3y ago>Nuclear in the US is so expensive that even starting a new reactor requires considerable corruption. Best line I've come across in a while. I'm gonna use it. Is it yours?
- epistasis 3y agoJust seeing your comment 10 days after it was posted, but I have many fond memories of your work, and it would be an honor for Asa Dotzler to use one of my lines.
- lamontcg 3y ago> And how many nuclear reactors does one worker build in their lifetime? 2? 4? That's not a lot of opportunity for process improvement. And reactors are inherently too big and complicated. A wind farm, solar farm, or a road is intrinsically much simpler. And reactors will suffer from decision makers sitting around a table and changing designs for the next one because engineers have thought up new failure modes of the last design and nobody wants to be the person who says "no" and then has a failure. Along with the natural tendency of US management to increase the spending of their departments in order to increase the size of their own personal kingdom. You'll never manage to stamp out reactor after reactor all of the same design.