4 ms·
I don't think this happened. Too much of it doesn't add up. I'm especially hung up on going to a major US bank and asking to withdraw $50,000 on no notice, with
by tptacek 3y ago
I don't think this happened. Too much of it doesn't add up. I'm especially hung up on going to a major US bank and asking to withdraw $50,000 on no notice, with minimal ceremony. At the least, they'd be filling out a SAR, right? I am speaking from some experience with large (and carefully papered, unlike this one!) transactions with Bank of America.
The suggestibility details in the story don't add up. She attempts to verify the CIA agent, is told to check an incoming number, knows that incoming numbers can be forged, but buys that government numbers can't be? There are too many places in this story where we're asked to let the author have it both ways: she knows something is wrong, specifically, but is going along anyways.
It's not at all clear why she couldn't call the police; it's just stated, at one point early in the article, that she concluded that she couldn't. What's the rationale for that one? The scammer might be in the local police department? Like Agent Koutris in Season 2 of the Wire?
I'm also hung up in the scammers showing up, in person, in a Mercedes. They have not in fact hacked this person's whole life (that isn't really a thing), so they don't know that the police haven't been contacted. But they're showing up, at her house, in a car probably worth more than the $50k that they're hoping to collect. Here I have just a basic Bayesian problem: the Venn diagram of people who can cough up $50k who won't contact the police, such that the handoff is a setup, is slim. It's not that it's impossible; it could happen. But the base rate is very low. As a strategy, that is a very effective way to lose a white Mercedes SUV.
I'm registering a prediction that another shoe is going to drop on this story.
Two pieces of corroborating information that are gettable:
* The police report that she says was filed on October 31 is a public record subject to FOIA.
* The handout her bank gave her about "not getting scammed" when she withdrew the 500 $100 bills should be available to anyone who asks.
- idlewords 3y agoI agree with you that this part is fishy as hell. I can swallow the Mercedes (pay a random dude money to collect the box without reading him into the scam), but not the part where she strolls into a BoA branch and gets $50K on demand while on speakerphone with her scammer.
- tptacek 3y agoI'm on a Slack trading stories about trying to take 5 figures in cash out of major banks, and (1) all of them are more complicated than getting stacks --- you get neat little envelopes, btw! --- at the teller, and everyone has stories about things escalating to managers and getting quizzed about what was going on, and (2) nobody has ever seen this supposed high-dollar withdrawal room or floor in a major bank (in fact: if you're doing HNW banking, you're less likely to see bulletproof glass, not more). I think the Internet is hypnotized by the debate about how dumb you have to be to get taken by a scam like this. Smart people get taken by these kinds of scams all the time. The story is directionally and importantly true. But I think it's almost certainly false. I've got a FOIA out for the police report. Someone should roll into a Citi or Chase and try to pull 50k out on no notice next week. I bet they freak out. One person I talked to was told they had to give advanced notice to take $15k out. And pay attention to the timeline given on this story! Everything had to have taken place between the hours of 2:00PM EST (when she got the call) and 5:00PM EST (when all the banks in Brooklyn close). At 6:00PM EST she's home giving the money to the guy in the SUV, who she's not allowed to look at, because he's UC. On Halloween. And the scammers picked the day to do this on. Come on.