9 ms·
Firefly III: A free and open source personal finance manager
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agois there a home-assistant addon for doing personal finance?
- cromka 3y agoWhy on earth would you want to use HA as a host for that?
- internet101010 3y agoNot the person you responded to but I can see asking "how much money do I have left in my entertainment budget?" without having to open the software would be helpful.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThis looks like exactly the kind of thing I've been searching for! Curious about testimonials if anyone's used it
- 2cynykyl 3y agoDoes 13,000 stars on github count?! Seems like a lot to me, can't believe I've never heard of it.
- tdotdev 3y agoI self host it since Mint shutdown. It obviously doesnt have automatic integrations with financial institutions so you need to export/import manually or frankenstein your own automation. There are a lot of things it does that I dont use. I am mostly there for spending visualization. It does that well, but it takes a lot of clicks to setup categorization rules, but once its done things happen automatically. Its just a few minutes work to get it setup on docker. And i think it has a demo site that you can look around on to see what tools it has. Its not perfect. But its good enough for me, for now.
- geor9e 3y ago>It obviously doesnt have automatic integrations with financial institutions so you need to export/import manually Ok, that's what I was scouring the documentation to find out. Thank you. Guess I'll stick with my current mint-alternative (Empower)
- criddell 3y ago> It obviously doesnt have automatic integrations with financial institutions Why would that be obvious? Until I read your comment I was assuming it was there. That feels like it should be a core feature for basic personal finance applications.
- rounakdatta 3y agoI've been using Firefly-III for over three years now. What I'm contemplating to write is a quick util which would auto-import transactions from my emails.
- gabrielgio 3y agoI have been using for years now. I don't have big requirements for a personal finances software. I mainly use it for cataloging my expenses so I can have a overview to where my money goes. I created a script that pushes my bank account export and have a series of rules to tag it automatically[1] and that is it. And for what I use it just works. I don't have any complains, docs are good, plenty of tutorial available and it is easy enough to setup and update (I don't use docker for it). I can't ask more of a software tbh. [1]: https://docs.firefly-iii.org/how-to/firefly-iii/features/rules/ https://docs.firefly-iii.org/how-to/firefly-iii/features/rul...
- nextaccountic 3y agoHow does it compare to YNAB?
- number6 3y agoI used it about a year but switched back to YNAB. I really like the budget in YNAB. Firefly concentrates more on the bookkeeping. Which for me is just secondary...
- nextaccountic 3y agoIt's kind of mind blowing that there isn't a lot of cheaper alternatives to YNAB that focus on budgeting.. YNAB is so popular (and so expensive)
- kayg04 3y agoI'm a YNAB guy too, and I look for a cheaper solution every year when I have to renew it. Last time the only real competitor is Monarch Money and they don't support anything other than usd.
- esseti 3y agolooking forward to moving away from YNAB. it became too expensive for what it offers (note: i can't use auto-sync) . On the other side, i've 3+ years of data and various script to overcome problems such us import from csv, auto-split categories etc. Thus, if someone find an easy-to-use alternative that has budget and bookkeeping that would be great.
- nosecreek 3y agoMy favorite YNAB alternative is Buckets - https://www.budgetwithbuckets.com/ https://www.budgetwithbuckets.com/ although especially if you don’t need auto-sync
- nextaccountic 3y agoIs there an open source alternative to YNAB that operates under the same budgeting principles?
- sanjeetsuhag 3y agoMy biggest gripe with my Firefly workflow is how difficult it is to automatically handle Amazon orders. I’ve setup rules to automatically organize/label the various types of transactions that I export from banks to CSVs, but having to break down Amazon orders is a tedious nightmare. If anyone has any ideas for how to automate this, please share. One idea is to have Puppeteer just open the order page and get the invoice, but that doesn’t seem to secure to me, even if it’s on machine.
- neilv 3y agoFor Amazon orders in GnuCash, I've been idly thinking about making a browser plugin that scrapes the Amazon order page, since that's less likely to be cut off than a standalone scraper is. How I'm currently manually doing Amazon orders in GnuCash is I go to the register for account "Liabilities > Credit Cards > Chase-CC-1234", and add a transation with description, say, "2024-02-16 Amazon order 113-1234567890-987654 (bobs red mill, soy curls, yaktrax)", with a split for each item and for each payment method used (credit card, CC rewards, gift balance). I keep the order date in the transaction description so that the GnuCash date can be the date that the CC is charged. If Amazon splits the shipment and does multiple CC charges (potentially on very different dates), so that GnuCash reflects those dates, I'm currently duplicating the transaction in GnuCash, and then editing the splits in the original and the duplicate to match the CC charges and what they're for. And each transaction description gets a "#1", "#2", etc. added after the Amazon order number. One upside of the manual process is that the work is negative feedback for spending money. :)
- h05sz487b 3y agoFor Amazon I sometimes have items grouped differently in the order overview on Amazon itself then in the credit card charge. That makes it quite tedious to actually find out what charge goes where.
- zrail 3y agoAmazon's transaction engine is bananas. I've seen it split an order for multiple items across two unequal card transactions. Try reconciling that without parsing every single invoice page.
- zargon 3y agoThe author has a weird take on zero based budgeting [0]. To me it seems like a distinction without a difference. I never did try Firefly because at first it wasn't very mature and then later I found Actual Budget, which is (or at least was) perfect. (I haven't transitioned to the open source version yet, so I'm not sure if they broke it.) [0] https://docs.firefly-iii.org/explanation/firefly-iii/background/zero-based-budgeting/ https://docs.firefly-iii.org/explanation/firefly-iii/backgro...
- mdhowle 3y agoI have been using the self-hosted ActualBudget for ~6 months and found it mostly perfect. The mobile version of the site is not complete but it's at least usable for managing transactions. The only drawback is no user accounts, but you can have multiple budgets. I was originally on YNAB4, and then financier.io for ~2 years.
- igortg 3y agoI've being using YNAB4 for about 10yrs now. But I miss a mobile version to report daily expenses. Do you see any major drawback comparing to YNAB4?
- mdhowle 3y agoI haven't encountered any major drawbacks. The reporting is a bit lacking. ActualBudget has simple Net Worth and Cash Flow charts. Other than that, it has all the features of YNAB4 I can recall.
- funOtter 3y agoI also switched from YNAB4 to ActualBudget about 6 months ago. I'm hosting it on a Raspberry pi in my network. Overall it's working great!
- hiatus 3y agoHow do you get transactions into ActualBudget? Do you run a manual import job at a set cadence?
- Roadeo 3y agoI've been using Firefly iii for about 3 years now. I use it with Waterfly iii [1] so anytime I get an SMS or notification from my bank about any kind of transaction, Waterfly automatically parses text from the notification and auto-fills transaction details like the amount, transaction title and date. Makes it super easy to maintain proper history since you can instantly create transactions from your phone. [1] https://github.com/dreautall/waterfly-iii https://github.com/dreautall/waterfly-iii
- hysan 3y agoAny recommendations for a self-hosted finance tracker that supports multiple users who share bank accounts? I don’t think I need a budgeting tool? Ideally, what I want is a simple to use tool that will let me add my expenses, categorize them, and view breakdowns of where I’ve spent money each week/month/year. Does firefly work well for that?
- plondon514 3y agoI built https://porkybank.io https://porkybank.io for my wife and I for this very purpose
- the_mungler 3y agoI've been looking through the repository on GitHub and I for the life of me can't figure out where the SQL code is. How is the database created? What do the tables look like? I've never looked at a php codebase before, I'm quite lost. I'm guessing this is using some ORM provided by Laravel?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- leonjza 3y agoCreation is done by running migrations [1] (invoked via Laravel's artisan command line). Using the database is done via Models[2]. [1] https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/tree/main/database/migrations https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/tree/main/databas... [2] https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/tree/main/app/Models https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/tree/main/app/Mod...
- c0pium 3y agoNot SQL, but check out the contents of the database folder. For example: https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/blob/main/database/migrations/2016_06_16_000000_create_support_tables.php https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii/blob/main/databas...
- lencastre 3y agoThis vs hledger? /asking for a friend who used msmoney back in the day
- TT-392 3y agoAfter a day of trying to get it to work at all (tried through both the docker thing and the non-docker thing) and finally getting it to work. Then, the nexy time I try to start it, shit being broken again, I rage quitted and switched to hledger. I'm sure it is easy if you are in the webdev/devops world though.
- optimal-choices 3y agoLooks good! However, if you need multi-currency support, I'd recommend checking out HomeBank. Multi-currency is one of those weird things, where if you actually need it your options are much more limited, but it also feels weird to keep asking financial software developers to keep implement a niche-ish feature. Anyway, it's good to have options. https://www.gethomebank.org/en/index.php https://www.gethomebank.org/en/index.php
- JC5 3y agoFirefly III is 100% multi-currency. Even budgets, bills, anything.
- leononame 3y agoMulti currency is the one thing every app I try keeps getting wrong. It's not about calling an API for conversion rates, it's about tracking each thing at its currency and being able to convert at price/at cost. I'm hacking together my own scripts on top of beancount at the moment but I'd love an actual double entry accounting app that can handle multiple currencies (and auto import from my European bank account ideally)
- VMelnalksnis 3y agoThe UI is definitely not as polished as the other alternatives listed, but I made my own because at the time Firefly was not exactly right for me - https://github.com/VMelnalksnis/Gnomeshade https://github.com/VMelnalksnis/Gnomeshade. It can automatically import transactions using Nordigen, or you can upload a file exported from your bank if you don't want to use a third party service. It also supports multi currency transactions, and sharing accounts between multiple users.
- Rnonymous 3y agoSharing accounts between multiple users is something i've been missing in many of the existing solutions. Thanks, ill check it out!
- 3y ago
- bberenberg 3y agoThe founder of Maybe[0] oss’d it recently and they’re working towards making it easy to self host. Seems like it could end up being a fairly modern SaaS level open core alternative. 0 - https://github.com/maybe-finance/maybe https://github.com/maybe-finance/maybe
- FrostKiwi 3y agoData importer GitHub link is dead: docs.firefly-iii.org/data-importer
- snvzz 3y agoI am already using GNUCash. How does this compare?
- moorlagt 3y agoI tried GNUCash and opted for this. I think the UI is more understandable and polished. Still a lot of depth to Firefly and has its own learning curve. Its also written in PHP using Laravel which can be appealing.
- snvzz 3y agoUI might be more understandable and polished to someone new to both programs, but I have used GNUCash for over a decade. Change is effort. As for PHP, it has never been confidence inspiring. I will say this despite having used Laravel professionally.
- gidorah 3y agoI, too, use Gnucash. Gnucash is an actual double entry bookkeeping system. Firefly is not. I want to like Firefly, but you cannot properly record all liabilities. Also, you can't mix income and expenses in the same account. For example, if I get a refund, it has to go to an income account. Not net off against an expense, which is the usual way bookkeeping.
- snvzz 3y agoOK, this is enough in itself to disqualify Firefly.
- mr-karan 3y agoWhile exploring some other self hosted/OSS personal finance tools, found https://github.com/actualbudget/actual https://github.com/actualbudget/actual to be a promising project too.
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 3y agoI've been using this as a replacement for YNAB and I don't miss anything. After evaluating Firefly for six months, I would say its setup isn't easy.
- shric 3y agoHow easy is it to move data from YNAB to this? i.e. transactions, categories and accounts?
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 3y agoI just start fresh from start.
- mdhowle 3y agoIt seems straightforward: https://actualbudget.com/docs/overview/migrating-from-other-apps/ https://actualbudget.com/docs/overview/migrating-from-other-...
- crashabr 3y agoWhy did you stop using YNAB?
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 3y agoWould like to complement beancount.
- leononame 3y agoDoes actual support tracking assets in different currencies and split transactions? I'm hacking together a tool for myself that fits my needs, but I'd really be in the market for something that could replace gnucash or beancount for me
- smcleod 3y agoUnfortunately it doesn’t seem to support integration with the open banking standard used in Australia, New Zealand and the UK
- dabeeeenster 3y agoIt connects with Nordigen/Gocardless - I use it in the UK and it works really well.
- smcleod 3y agoReally! Is that with the open banking standard or something bespoke?
- dabeeeenster 3y agoopen banking afaik
- flandish 3y agoI’m always looking for a self hosted pocketsmith alternative with a calendar like it. Thats how I use it best. I know I buy crap so categories are meh. But being able to pop ahead a month and adjust a bill or expense schedule to better align with fortnightly pay helps me. It also helps to remind me what I have not paid. And to “predict” future balances. Sure a sheet can do that but I have always found a visual calendar works best with my adhd.
- Fiahil 3y agoI'm a 5y user of Firefly-III, and was very happy with it. Unfortunately, JC5, I discovered Actual recently. It's not that FIII is bad at was it was doing, but simply Actual was a bit faster, a bit simpler, a bit more practical to use when importing. I'm mostly using rules, categories and reporting.
- kkfx 3y agoMy problem honestly is the stability/future/import-export-ability of all accounting tools. So far I'm using BeanCount via org-mode using Fava just to have some eye-candy view since two years, it's not exactly comfortable, but it's flexible and effective enough. Switching tools was NOT, I've started with the simple HomeBank than GNUCash then Ledger (hledger, actually) than BeanCount, all switches was veeeeeery long, partially manual and painful enough that instead of having continuous accounting I've decide to close any year and restart via opening balances to been able in the future to switch tool keeping the old one for a while for previous records. That's the most annoying part for me: accounting, docs (files) management, notes are things that last many years, sometimes an entire human adult/active life, having the ability to evolve from a tool to another, from a workflow to another not loosing nor painfully transitioning from past tools is a VERY big issue. Because of that I fear any tool with a large codebase/many deps because a simple tool I can keep it myself if the upstream vanish, a complex one I can't.
- Alifatisk 3y agoI wish I could get data about my transactions through an api from my bank
- lakomen 3y agoYes, but idk where you are, in the EU we have this PSD2 rule or law, which adds 2FA to every action, not just transaction, making it impossible to automate and forcing you to use a 3rd party service, which costs about 30€ / month of you'd like to automate. Before PSD2, at least German banks had a free api one could automatically query. The EU claims it's done because of "security". Essentially corruption.
- ta1243 3y agoYour bank and your implementation can use TOTP just fine while meeting a 2FA requirement.
- Share6323 3y agoBut why does the Comdirect still offer a free API to their retail customers? https://www.comdirect.de/cms/kontakt-zugaenge-api.html https://www.comdirect.de/cms/kontakt-zugaenge-api.html
- cromka 3y agoWoob is the only viable OSS solution at this point
- Akashic101 3y agoFirefly kinda worked around this. You can download all transactions of your bank as a CSV, then use the Firefly importer to automatically map the data and save it inside Firefly. I usually do this once a week and it works pretty quickly, maybe a minute of work.
- noeontheend 3y agoThis certainly works well if you only need to track one account, but my finances aren't even _that_ complicated and I still have accounts I try to keep up to date with five different banks (hometown bank with checking/savings, two credit cards, employer-sponsored retirement account with Fidelity, and a three-fund portfolio with Vanguard). All of those accounts have 2FA, so logging into each one, navigating to the download screen, and downloading it into the right spot easily adds up to fifteen minutes of work. Ironically, I've found that since I started to rely more on downloading the CSVs and importing them (as opposed to entering everything by hand), I've been entering things less regularly because of the increased start up time. If each account just had an API to pull transactions, I could schedule a job to download everything daily and life would be so much better.
- AndreiCalazans 3y agoWhat's with people building open source finance managers? This is like the 1000th one I have seen.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoAlong with note taking and todo apps, it's low hanging fruit. It's a problem most people / developers can understand without having to do a lot of studying, and it fits in people's heads. But it's also often an example of people not willing to learn a new tool, or not willing to pay for one, so why not build a new one? How hard can it be?
- sumtechguy 3y ago> How hard can it be? The number of stupidly huge complex projects I got myself roped into with that dumb phrase...
- InitialLastName 3y agoIt's also (similar to note-taking and TODO) a problem that can be approached in a lot of different ways, for people with very different needs and mental models. Building an app that fits your mental model can be very instructive (including helping you flesh out your own understanding of the problem space).
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoNo idea if it's still the same now, but banking account management, both from the consumer and the bank side, used to be very common example use cases when teaching OOP. Maybe some of those example projects grew into hobbies which grew into OSS projects.
- thesuitonym 3y agoNeeding a way to track finances is a problem older than writing. It's an almost universal problem, and everyone has their own ideas on how it should be done. It's also a complicated idea, and when you look at existing solutions, they almost always have a huge number of features that any given individual won't need, which makes it harder to figure out what you're doing. If you have a background in programming, and none in finance, it might be easier for you to start from what you understand, and build up an app that does what you need first, then add features later as you understand the problem space more.
- jader201 3y agoWith Mint being deprecated, I’ve been looking for something to replace it. I know there are a number of paid alternatives, but it seems like they all are missing at least one or two things that I liked about Mint. Is there an OSS option that comes close? Seems like the biggest hurdle is finding one that is close to reliable when authenticating with other sites (and able to adapt to changes they make, 2FA, etc.). I guess the good news is that most of the ones I use are fairly popular/big (e.g. Vanguard, Ally, Schwab, etc.). But I have a couple loans (home, car) tied into smaller institutions. EDIT: related, a recent thread on Mint alternatives that I had missed: Ask HN: Alternative to Mint.com? (9 days ago, 44 votes, 71 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39275231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39275231
- NikolaNovak 3y agoAre there any good paid ones, even, for Canadian institutions specifically? We have 4 credit cards and two chequing accounts plus mortgage etc at different institutions. It would be worth some small amount of money for me, especially for a desktop not SaaS solution, to get a unified view I can categorize, filter, sort, graph, etc.
- theappsecguy 3y agoOnly one I have been able to find is YNAB and I hate it. It’s expensive and forces a weird opinionated budgeting approach onto its users.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThanks! Does YNAB actually plug into bank accounts like Mint used to? I thought you had to manually enter everything, but it may have evolved since I last looked at it.
- enobrev 3y agoIt does - mostly (only?) using plaid. I tried YNAB for a few months. It's not really for me. But it was able to sync _most_ of my accounts without issue. I've been trying out Monarch more recently (which seems to use plaid, mx, and other methods). They have a discount for people coming over from mint as well as a way to import mint history. I'm still cleaning up my mint data before running the import. I've liked it thus far; I'd say it's pretty much what I hoped Mint would become when I started using Mint a decade ago.
- soofaloofa 3y agoAfter trying many different tools and being disappointed by either bank integration or being locked into a proprietary budget format I settled on using a spreadsheet. The template from https://themeasureofaplan.com/budget-tracking-tool/ https://themeasureofaplan.com/budget-tracking-tool/ has everything I need and a perfect level of flexibility to customize it for your needs.
- octobus2021 3y agoHelp me understand, I must be dumb. If people seem to value privacy and security more so that they don't trust their data hosted at a third party, why are many of these are self-hosted Web apps as opposed to a simple desktop application? I'm not just talking about this particular one, just in general on the idea of replacing SaaS (like Mint) with self-hosted. What is self-hosting buying here? If it's installed on the local, it's a waste of resources and development time, if it's hosted on a third party hoster we're back to somebody holding user's data. Is this simply because people are so used to building Web apps that they use them everywhere? (Yes you can file it under "old man yelling a the sky" category, I'm still on Quicken 2016 personally :) )
- wccrawford 3y agoI haven't done desktop UIs in a while, but my experience is that html and css work really well for UI, and there are a ton of competing desktop UIs that all have their own issues. Last time I tried making a desktop UI, I definitely preferred html over it. I wouldn't be surprised if there were a lot more web devs than native devs, too. And finally, if you have something you want centralized, it's generally a lot easier to just have a web server than setting up some kind of system to sync the data between different computers. For finances, I could see wanting to use it on both mobile and desktop on a daily basis. That makes web a lot more desirable.
- eeghyrdcg 3y agoIndeed. I can’t imagine doing native desktop development unless it was absolutely required for my project, and then I’d ask myself if maybe I shouldn’t just work on something else. All that work and it runs on one OS.
- octobus2021 3y agoHTML and CSS are most definitely NOT better for the UI comparing to the native desktop apps. HTML was designed for cross-reference documents and people spent decades enriching it with CSS/JS/whatever to get some resemblance of acceptable UI. Not even mentioning all the resources required to run all the frameworks that the modern Web UI is running on. If you want to be able to check your finances on the phone you have to put it on a 3rd party server along with your data. Might as well go with SaaS like Mint. I don't. You do lose some cross-platform capabilities when you do desktop apps, that is true, but there are some toolsets available (eg Qt). So I guess it comes down to what people are used to work with, which is Web-first.
- jpb0104 3y agoAs with most devs, I also saw personal budgeting as a nail and I had a hammer. Here's my somewhat opinionated take on personal expense tracking and budgeting. I'm wide open to feedback: https://budgetmyway.com https://budgetmyway.com
- netbioserror 3y agoI am so baffled by the choices made in so many budgeting and personal finance applications that I'm very close to just designing my own spreadsheet, to last into the future.
- meain 3y agoI mostly note down my transactions from my phone and https://moneymanagerapp.com/ https://moneymanagerapp.com/ has been working great for me. It does let you start a webserver from your phone and use it on your desktop if you really have to, but the workflow is not ideal. It also does would not work if you need to track expenses of multiple people or want to automatically import expenses from your bank. It does allow you to export your data though. Backup and restore can be done via Google Drive. Not OSS, and also paid(one time), but was totally worth it for me.
- dorbodwolf 3y agoI like this app, it’s support multilingual and multi currency types
- roccomathijn 3y agoI tried Firefly for a year but I could not find a nice workflow with it. It was a maintainability nightmare. Needed to run 2 instances for my girlfriend and myself. A third instance I think for automatic imports from my bank. Every 2/3 months whenever the integration with the Spectre API needed to be reauthorized another docker container had to be ran just to hit a reauthorize button. And then it was a battle with duplicate transactions which I could manage to fix but I could never make my girlfriend understand. Then there was weird philosophy on incoming money in a category. Let's say you have a €200 diner with 3 friends. You pay the whole bill and get €150 back from your friends later. Firefly would tell you you spend €200 euros on restaurants instead of just €50. Happily back to Ynab now.
- gidorah 3y agoHaving to record all inbound cash as income was a deal breaker for me. I wanted to like Firefly, but couldn't because of this. There is literally no other accounting software that works like this.
- k8svet 3y agoIf this can even just barely compete with LunchMoney, I'll happily spend 5x what I spend on LM on monthly donations to Firefly III. I love LunchMoney, but hate using closed source software especially for such things as my financial data/insight. edit: demo is impressive enough, 20euro/month donation setup. Rock on folks, this is neat.
- tamiral 3y agoI've been testing out ActualBudget and was looking at setting up Firefly III but i understand that its a different type of solution to finance. I love the idea of personal finance and opensource vs having our information passed through 3rd parties.