3 ms·
Will the people that did the peer reviews be sanctioned in any way? Seems so blatant that it doesn't look like it was actually reviewed at all.
by theogravity 3y ago
Will the people that did the peer reviews be sanctioned in any way? Seems so blatant that it doesn't look like it was actually reviewed at all.
- jperoutek 3y agoTo me, this is the real question. One of the purposes of the peer-review is to validate and verify results, which was clearly not done to a great extent here. Perhaps the reviewers were also using some type of AI?
- hermitcrab 3y agoPerhaps the reviewer was an AI. Which gives a new spin to 'peer review'.
- dexzod 3y agomakes sense, because the peer of AI can only be AI
- favorited 3y agoThe reviewers are cited as part of the publication: Binsila B. Krishnan, National Institute of Animal Nutrition and Physiology (ICAR), India Jingbo Dai, Northwestern Medicine, United States
- hermitcrab 3y agoFrom a quick Google, they appear to be real people.
- gs17 3y agoFrontiers has an explicit rule against that, although I doubt any reviewer would admit to it.