3 ms·
So who lost $120M? This is a zero-sum system.
by Animats 3y ago
So who lost $120M? This is a zero-sum system.
- maximilianroos 3y agoIf an asset goes up in price, who loses? One model is "total assets go up, no one loses". Another is "those who want to use the assets in the future will have to pay more for them".
- mminer237 3y agoNobody gains or loses anything tangible until they liquidate. Assuming they manage to do so without crashing the market, it would be those people who bought in at the high because "Ethereum is going up".
- drexlspivey 3y agoIt's definately not a zero-sum system
- dvt 3y agoYou can make an argument that the economy as a whole is not a zero-sum system, but money markets certainly are.
- skybrian 3y agoIt’s zero-sum when the game ends because there are no more buyers. That hasn’t happened yet. We don’t know how much more money will be spent on Ethereum or who the buyers will be. We don’t know how much they will win or lose. If it’s zero-sum but we don’t know how many terms are being summed or their values, then we can’t do the math and the equation isn’t very useful for making predictions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- drexlspivey 3y agoAssume a financial asset that keeps going up at a steady rate, people buy and sell it all the time but everyone who sold did it at a higher price. Who is losing money in that case?
- skybrian 3y agoAsset prices are based on what people believe the future will bring. If the price drops because of some event, and you haven’t traded, you have the same asset as before and only its price has changed. You’re poorer than you thought, but nobody gained anything from you. (You haven’t traded!) People just changed their minds about the price. It’s the same going up. When you trade, that’s different. If you sell at a higher price then the gain comes from the new buyer. If the price goes down then you lost some of what you paid to the previous seller. Also, in this case, there are loans. Someone had Ethereum and lended it out. They got paid interest, but lost out on gains that they could have had if they didn’t make the loan. (They could have gotten more money from a buyer later.)
- friend_and_foe 3y agoIt's not a zero sum system. There are capital inflows. Who loses are people who voluntarily sell. They think they're making a good decision, so does the counterparty, and only time will tell. Every deal you make with someone is both of you doing something you perceive as in your best interest. Speculative investment particularly is a high risk game. Often, it is a good decision on both parts, because peoples needs differ.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> It's not a zero sum system. There are capital inflows It's still zero sum from a dollars in / dollars out perspective. Delayed consequences doesn't make a zero-sum game positive sum. (And to be clear, all money systems are zero sum if we ignore transaction costs without accounting for their economies.)
- friend_and_foe 3y agoBy that logic everything is zero sum. The number of living organisms started at 0 and will end at 0. In the meantime we have entropy to generate...