3 ms·
KiCad is a fantastic option for simple PCBs. For even moderately complex work, Altium and KiCad aren’t even comparable. I don’t think the size of this gap is o
by Aurornis 3y ago
KiCad is a fantastic option for simple PCBs.
For even moderately complex work, Altium and KiCad aren’t even comparable. I don’t think the size of this gap is obvious to the average hobbyist, but professional packages like Altium have a depth and breadth of features that will take years or decades to replicate in the open source space. There’s a reason professionals and organizations are paying huge amounts of money for Altium licenses still.
- bsder 3y agoAnybody who needs real PCB features isn't using Alitum. They're using Mentor Xpedition or Cadence Allegro.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoA company down the road from me building automotive electronics including for Formula 1, would beg to differ.
- OJFord 3y agoBy 'real electronics' they probably mean high frequency or very high speed designs, a GPU card manufacturer say. No doubt there's a lot of complexity in F1 electronics, but they certainly have more space, cooling, reasonable environment, etc. to work with than some industries. (Not to disagree that it was dismissive and a lot of serious work gets done with Altium Designer, and for that matter Kicad, of course.)
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>By 'real electronics' they probably mean high frequency or very high speed designs, a GPU card manufacturer say. I duuno man, at a startup I worked at, the graybeard EE was doing 2.4GHz RF design on software cheaper and more rudimentary than Altium, let alone Cadence. So I'm always rolling my eyes when someone uses the world "real" as some sort of macho flex with vague meaning like "real men", "real work", "real engineering", "real software development", as if only their particular example makes the world go round and scoff at everything else like it's unimportant child's play.
- vanchor3 3y agoSure, you can do 2.4GHz on a 2 layer board with even the simplest programs, or even Inkscape really. The hard part is arguably knowing the write math involved to design with signal integrity in mind. When you start working with very high speed things like DDR4/DDR5 on 14 layer boards you could do it with simpler software, but I don't see why you would. The time saved with the design tools and signal integrity simulations would likely be worth much more than the licensing cost, especially if you're bigger than a small hobby shop. Not to mention the money saved on having software that can identify mistakes early on when the PCBs alone can cost thousands. And then there's all the other bits like conforming to standards, providing deliverables in a format that the next place down the line deems "acceptable" (or they're just picky), as interoperability with other teams, because sometimes you're just one small part of the design process.
- Aurornis 3y ago> By 'real electronics' they probably mean high frequency or very high speed designs, a GPU card manufacturer say. Altium has good support for high speed design features. (Source: Have done many high-speed designs in Altium and Allegro) Altium is quite common at tech companies. I think maybe the parent commenter was being sarcastic?
- OJFord 3y agoOh I know. I was just trying to offer an interpretation. > I think maybe the parent commenter was being sarcastic? Yeah, see my direct reply to them (before my comment above), I honestly don't know.
- bsder 3y agoNot being sarcastic. Altium doesn't even remotely compare to something like Xpedition or Allegro. Mostly I was refuting: > There’s a reason professionals and organizations are paying huge amounts of money for Altium licenses still. Uh, no. They're not actually paying huge amounts--that's part of the reason Altium got bought. Professionals use professional tools--Altium doesn't qualify. I really do not understand what Renesas thinks they are going to get from this. The autorouter is terrible. The constraint mechanisms suck. Co-design with mechanical CAD is poor. Large designs slow it to a crawl. Design sharing is incredibly weak. Source control and database integrations are laughably bad. I can go on and on and on. There are solid reasons why professionals pay an order of magnitude more money for Xpedition and Allegro over Altium. Sure, I have designed high-speed digital as well as high-GHz RF designs in weak PCB products (including both Altium and KiCad)--that's not a badge of honor, though. When time and efficiency actually matters, you put on your big boy boots, suck it up and cough up real money for real tools. > Altium is quite common at tech companies. This is fine. As is using KiCad. 99% of companies are not doing anything complex enough for it to matter.
- javawizard 3y agoIt's awfully rich saying: > Anybody who needs real PCB features isn't using Alitum and: > 99% of companies are not doing anything complex enough for it to matter in the same breath - it really doesn't do your argument any favors. I can't see a world in which only 1% and "anybody who needs real PCB features" are congruent statements.
- OJFord 3y agoI honestly couldn't tell if you're being serious or doing Real Programmers, but after a quick search Mentor Xpedition seems to be a Siemens product, and I know (just from YouTube videos of people using Fusion360 or Solidworks) their 3D CAD package is the 'big boy' one for mech engineers, so I'm leaning to the former? I'm just surprised I haven't even heard of them before (I've heard of Cadence but not confident about Allegro) - though I did manage my quasi-EE degree I think without ever touching PCB design! (I've done so before and since, but just Eagle, Kicad, and.. I think it was called CircuitWizard at school.) As a massive tangent, I've repeatedly since thought that CircuitWizard or something like it (or whatever it's called) would actually be great for the sort of Arduino hobbyist/newcomer - it had a really good built-in component library, but quite small, and (crucially for that audience IMO) no or little choice, so really simplified. Like I need a mux of this size, or I need 4 NAND gates or whatever, and you just place that part and it lists the BOM - you're not bogged down with an overwhelming choice where to a newcomer it probably doesn't matter, or at least there's an obvious non-specialised choice.
- tverbeure 3y agoAll the PCB designs that I’ve been exposed to professionally, both in-house and at customers in Taiwan (think ODMs for Acer, Asus, …), were designed with Cadence Allegro. These are all complex designs with high-speed interfaces (PCIe, DDR5, …), 12+ layers etc. Ironically, It’s only when I started doing hobby electronics that I learned about the existence of Altium. (That’s not a value judgement of Altium, I honestly don’t know how they compare.)
- delfinom 3y agoMentor used to be independent but got bought by Siemens. In general, Mentor and Cadence packages are where the serious electrical engineering happens where you are talking about routing gigahertz signals and simulating it. Even thermal simulations are a big deal in those suites.
- vrinsd 3y ago1 point by vrinsd 14 minutes ago | root | parent | next | edit | delete [–] I won't be as snide as bsder, but I will say Expedition and Allegro let you handle some crazy complex designs, which are much more of a challenge with Altium. Things like DDR3/4/5, 10+ layer PCBs, complex design rules, etc. Personally I think Expedition is much much easier to use than Allegro ; for the curious it was actually created by a company called 'Veribest' that Mentor later acquired. Having using Altium (all the way back to when it was Protel 98/99SE) it's gained a lot of impressive capability but it never shed a number of weird UI oddities. I'm really happy to see the direction KiCad is going, having used it circa v3 era, it's MUCH more usable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Always42 3y ago"real PCB" meaning massive boards with ton of layers. Personally I think this is a bad take, as there are many 4-8 layer boards that can be made fine with allium and those pcb's probably feel pretty "real".
- 1letterunixname 3y agoYep. If you were a gaming PC motherboard PCB manufacturer needing 8 layers, blind micro vias, and G-code output for drilling, good luck with that using anything but those enterprise EDA suites mentioned. EDA users exist along multiple dimensions including level of detail, subassembly/mechanical/BOM management, customizability, system/signal simulation/verification, automation, learning curve, and cost.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoOnce upon a time c. 2002, I used OrCAD (since folded into Allegro?) for industrial analog and mixed signal boards. It was relatively easy and usable compared to the alternatives. I'm wondering if Allegro is usable today or has a steep learning curve for prosumer individual EEs.
- vrinsd 3y agoCadence bought OrCAD and kept the schematic editor but the layout is Allegro, not the layout tool that historically was part of OrCAD. Allegro IMO does have a pretty steep learning curve, I think it's UI is quite archaic, it really hasn't see any serious improvements in over 20-years. I'd suggest Kicad if you wanted to do anything personal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoWe switched from Altium to kicad and it has been great so far. Haven’t found a feature that existed in Altium that we are missing now. For support we subscribe to kipro[1], which is a lot cheaper than an Altium license and their support blows Altium support easily out of the water. If you report a bug to them which is easy enough to fix, the next minor release will have it implemented. Altium has (or at least had) bugs that persisted for years and reporting them did nothing. We build power electronics, so this isn’t RF stuff or Gigabit communication. So I cannot speak for that. [1] https://www.kipro-pcb.com/ https://www.kipro-pcb.com/
- Aurornis 3y ago> We switched from Altium to kicad and it has been great so far. Haven’t found a feature that existed in Altium that we are missing now. If the feature set of KiCad fits your needs, then it's a great choice. It does quite well at simple boards and it can be made to work for certain minimal high-speed or RF boards if you have enough space and know how to make it work for you. However, I'm surprised you haven't found any features that you're missing. Even common settings like design rules are missing frequently-used features in KiCad. I immediately miss some of the more fine-grained design rule settings of the more powerful packages every time I use KiCad.
- delfinom 3y agoKiCad has basic design rules and a design rules scripting system, you can create a lot of design rules through that mechanism. Generally we take feedback on rules that can't currently be scripted and there are real applications for.
- m00x 3y agoKiCAD is amazing for simple PCBs, but if you're going into 10+ layers and dealing with high-frequency designs, you're going to have a lot of issues.
- quatrefoil 3y agoSimilarly to many other open-source design apps, KiCad has a fairly horrid UX and lacks some enterprise features (especially around collaboration on larger projects), but it's definitely being used for complex projects at a good number of companies. And the reasons why professionals and organizations are paying huge amounts for specific software are often less enlightened than we tend to assume. Inertia is a huge factor. Many universities train students to use Altium, for example, so it's often the path of least resistance. Plus, when you have processes and teams built around a tool that was cutting-edge a decade or two ago, it can be hard to switch. Especially for niche software like this, interoperability tents to be poor, every vendor invents their own UI and terminology from first principles, etc. But KiCad and Altium are not the only choices. There are affordable "serious hobbyist" products with much better UX (e.g., Diptrace) and there are higher-end commercial tools that leave Altium in the dust.
- tverbeure 3y agoHow does Altium compare against Cadence Allegro?
- rcxdude 3y agoThe gap is closing, and that should be deeply embarrasing to Altium, given the difference in resources. But Altium has completely squandered their efforts on stuff that isn't actually particularly useful for most of their users, while failing to fix bugs or otherwise improve the usability of their products for ~90% of their users. Altium today is about as useful to me as Altium 10 years ago. KiCAD has improved by leaps and bounds in the same timeframe.
- numpad0 3y agoI was once at an event, and a guy had some beautiful mixed signal something at a booth. Somehow I asked "so this is actually done in like KiCad..." and he kind of cut me with "well I have Altium subscription actually" and that, sufficed. Quality and feature set difference between these products is that obvious at mid-high ranges.