3 ms·
"The Gemini solar facility in Nevada plans to begin operating in 2024. With a planned photovoltaic capacity of 690 megawatts (MW) and battery storage of 380 MW,
by Animats 3y ago
"The Gemini solar facility in Nevada plans to begin operating in 2024. With a planned photovoltaic capacity of 690 megawatts (MW) and battery storage of 380 MW, it is expected to be the largest solar project in the United States when fully operational."
That's about 60% of the capacity of one unit at Vogtle nuclear power station, and Vogtle has four units.
Also, adding the solar capacity to the battery capacity to get a gigawatt makes no sense. Either you're charging the battery, which takes power from the solar array, or you're discharging the battery because it's dark and the solar array is idle.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoGemini took 2 years and cost $1.3B. Vogtle cost $34B for 2 units and took 12 years for those 2 units. Edit: Gemini took 4 years from project submission and 2 years from construction start. Vogtle took 19 years from project submission and 12 years from construction start.
- exoverito 3y agoIn large part because of constantly shifting requirements, obstructionism, and various forms of lawfare. The US has become terribly inefficient at large infrastructural projects, see the CA HSR project which is massively delayed and over budget. China does not have this problem, and has been rapidly expanding their nuclear capacity. A standardized reactor design and regulatory certainty would enable the economies of scale and accrual of institutional knowledge to efficiently build new power plants. In response to the 1973 oil crisis, France massively expanded their fleet of nuclear reactors which were producing more than 70% of their electricity in about 15 years. If the political will is there, it can be done.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoGemini also qualifies as a large infrastructural project; it was delayed by concerns about the tortoises living in the area and challenges from local environmental groups. China does similar projects in about 6 months. IOW, China does solar projects about 8X as fast as the US. OTOH it does nuclear projects in about 5 years, about 4X as fast as the US.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoEven China is building vastly more wind and solar now than they are nuclear. And their nuclear build rate is declining.
- epistasis 3y agoThere was no obstructionism or changing requirements to blame with Vogtle. It was all self-inflicted delays and costs by the designers and the builders. France is experiencing exactly the same long delays and cost overruns today at Flamanville, despite having a welcoming regulatory environment, etc. China also has lots of delays, and presumably cost overruns, but costs are a hard thing to pin down in China. China is barely expanding their nuclear program, only something like 50 new reactors are planned, a few orders of magnitude smaller than their plans for solar and wind. CA HSR has experienced the obstructionism that Vogtle did not, but is still making good progress. The media narrative doesn't cover it well, but there are new sections completed all the time. We have problems with big construction projects in the US, but nuclear takes those problems to the next level. And we have great non-construction alternatives for nuclear.
- breather 3y ago> see the CA HSR project which is massively delayed and over budget This is not a good parallel as the HSR's cost comes in large part from traversing many counties, municipalities, and private land.
- i_am_proteus 3y agoI agree that summing the two values to a GW seems disingenuous, but there are more scenarios than the two you described. For instance, it's possible to discharge the battery during the day, as well. If peak load is in the afternoon, the plant could be charging the battery during the morning and mid-day when specific demand on that plant is less than 690 MW, then discharge the battery to have (temporary) output of 1 GW.
- rudolph9 3y agoIt seems like this thread has sparked a lot nuclear vs solar debate, but both have the potential to be net zero energy sources and most fault tolerant grids are powered by a multitude of sources. We should be aggressively building solar, wind, battery, and nuclear along with anything else that can reasonably be part of a net zero supply chain that produces electricity in the not too distant. They all have different tradeoffs and we shouldn’t be debating which is better than the other. Rather we should focus on what percent of each fit best balancing safety/resiliency/cost of adoption/long term operating costs. And this varies widely from region and changing over time. What’s need are formulas and frameworks for helping make these wildly complex decisions more straightforward.
- hef19898 3y agoWe are building solar and wind aggressively. The problem with nuclear power is, nobody manages to build it aggressively or even at enough scale to make a meaningfull impact. What we should do, is keeping existing nuclear plants running as long as economically and safely possible. Emphasis on economically and safely, because those two points meant that the German reactors did run as long as possible, they even got an extension granted from a Green minister.
- MagnumOpus 3y ago> nobody manages to build it aggressively or even at enough scale to make a meaningfull impact China does. They will be completing 60-70 GW worth of reactors in the next decade, planning to take nuclear power from 2% of their electricity production to over 10% eventually. (While also building crazy amounts of solar, wind etc.)
- hef19898 3y agoYou do know that 6-7 GW per year are close to nothing compared to new wind and solar, not to mention other plants, China is installing? Nor is it in the general picture.
- einpoklum 3y ago
- hef19898 3y agoAnd now look at number of solar and wind installed vs. nuclear. Take net numbers, as most nuclear capacity replaces decommissioned reactors in countries without a nuclear exit strategy. I am too lazy too look up, and link, those publicly available numbers again....
- audunw 3y agoLooking at a single plant isn't very interesting. Solar and wind are fundamentally more distributed so you're comparing apples to oranges. That distributed nature is both a good thing and a bad thing. Having just a few nuclear reactor go down at the same time in a single region can be problematic, as France recently experienced. Of course there are costs/upgrades associated with making large share of renewables viable at all, but those come with a more distributed and resilient solution. If you want to compare impact on actual energy generation, look at the growth in total net numbers: The largest rate that nuclear ever grew was around ~200TWh for some years in the 80s. Solar grew by ~300TWh from 2021 to 2022. Wind grew by ~200TWh. And the growth rate is still increasing exponentially. For reference the world population grew from ~5 to ~8billion from the 80s until now, if you want to take that into account when comparing the growth rates.
- tigershark 3y agoAll the nuclear energy production plants in the world ever built have the same capacity as the amount of solar generation built just last year. So your comparison doesn’t make much sense, nuclear is dead in current energy market, it makes sense only for producing fissile material for nuclear bombs.
- beAbU 3y agoPresumably you can discharge the batteries while pv is also producing at full tilt. But that'll rarely happen. I absolutely hate the current state of energy reporting in general. The writers of these articles are not even trying to make sure they report accurately. E.g. the battery stats: Is it MW or MWH? Both are very different and the distinction is important. A battery that can deliver 380MW but only for 10 mins is pretty useless.
- epistasis 3y agoThis is the EIA. They are in charge of pretty much all energy tracking in the US. They are reporting the right units, and if they seem wrong, it's because the numbers are being used for something useful, but perhaps different than what you have in mind. (That said, I do dislike units like BTU or "billions of kWh," but they are at least correct units for the quantity measured)