4 ms·
That's nice, but there is a long way to go, also it would probably be better to see batteries as a part of the 'storage' bracket, after all the batteries don't
by jacquesm 3y ago
That's nice, but there is a long way to go, also it would probably be better to see batteries as a part of the 'storage' bracket, after all the batteries don't generate electricity, they store it. It's a bit like lumping fields of grain in with bags for grain. The one is useful all by itself, the other can't function without some other generator doing its job first.
Typically the use for storage in the form of batteries is to play arbitrage with power prices around solar noon to farm it back out again when power is more expensive, for instance early evening or the next morning. Longer term storage also works but tends to be more capital expensive and isn't really an option just yet, though there are some edge cases where it may already work on (slightly) longer timescales.
- danielheath 3y ago> The one [solar] is useful all by itself Not in a power-grid context; it'll over-volt the grid sometimes and under-volt it other times. In the specific context of "understanding generation supply to a grid", working in terms of "load supplied by a system of solar & batteries" makes the math drastically simpler.
- jacquesm 3y agoEvery modern inverter respects the local grid regulations with respect to overvolting and undervolting isn't an issue at all and has in principle if it happens absolutely nothing to do with solar power.
- audunw 3y agoI think it's actually brilliant to include battery together with energy generation. We know that when renewables become more than 20% of power generation, every GW of renewables you add should be matched by a similar order of magnitude of batteries. So if we start reporting this way, you can immediately see if we're building enough energy storage or not. If you wanted to make the amount of power actually produced comparable you could reduce the amount of reported GW of bother renewables and batteries by 50% so they add up to a realistic capacity number. But capacity numbers are never really comparable anyway. Perhaps best to report raw numbers and assume readers are smart enough to understand that for every source you need to know the significance of what a "GW" means. Like, a "GW" of a gas peaker plant does not mean much regarding how much energy it produces. That "GW" is actually much more comparable to battery energy storage "GW"
- jacquesm 3y agoSure, but batteries simply don't generate power: you store an X number of KWh in them based on the rate of your charger and the rate-of-charge of your battery and you can discharge them using an inverter (which again, has a nameplate rating) limited by the rate of discharge of the batteries (usually pretty close to the charging rate so this tends to be symmetrical). You could have a massive storage with a relatively small inverter for discharge but a large charging capacity, the reverse and so on all highly dependent on the intended use case. So battery capacity doesn't say anything about the eventual grid capacity of the setup, for that you need to take into account all of the components (charger, battery size + charge/discharge rate + inverter). Only then you can put it into perspective.