3 ms·
Just the thought of how to prioritize things in all of the reversing is enough to make me overwhelmed. Have they talked about how they prioritize? "Asahi's mos
by dylan604 3y ago
Just the thought of how to prioritize things in all of the reversing is enough to make me overwhelmed. Have they talked about how they prioritize?
"Asahi's most recent update blog post, published in mid-January, highlighted HDMI support, support for DRM-protected websites via Google's proprietary Widevine package, Touchbar support for the handful of Apple Silicon Macs that use one, and more."
Seems odd to me that a Linux open source focused something would spend so much effort on supporting DRM over USB3 functionality. So for them to go that direction implies to me they have good reasons. Are they trying to satisfy users? My knee jerk reaction would be the users willing to use this would be accepting of not supporting DRM.
- chippiewill 3y agoThe Asahi team isn't some monolithic corporation with a prioritised backlog. The skillsets and amount of work involved in getting Widevine working (quickly porting the binary from ARM64 ChromeOS) vs USB 3 (reverse engineer Apple's unique undocumented implementation and write a Linux kernel driver for it) are completely different. It's open source, if someone volunteers a Widevine implementation for Asahi then the maintainers aren't going to say no. Generally speaking Alyssa does GPU reverse engineering, Marcan does the other hardware reverse engineering, Asahi Lina writes the GPU driver and everyone else does various miscellaneous bits (like userspace binaries).
- saagarjha 3y ago> The skillsets and amount of work involved in getting Widevine working (quickly porting the binary from ARM64 ChromeOS) vs USB 3 (reverse engineer Apple's unique undocumented implementation and write a Linux kernel driver for it) are completely different. They're not all that different to be honest
- HeWhoLurksLate 3y agofor one data point, I'd much rather have DRM supported than USB 3 support- one lets me do casual things and use my machine while I relax or do whatever, and for most USB 3 devices I can just suck it up and wait for a file transfer, or do what I normally do and work off of my NAS.
- rowanG077 3y agoIt's also a part of effort. USB is very hard taking months and months. Widevine is easy in contrast. So it's also a resource payoff tradeoff.