3 ms·
The issue is India doesn't have a judicial agreement with Switzerland over data sharing (which includes User IP Addresses) for criminal investigations [0] while
by alephnerd 3y ago
The issue is India doesn't have a judicial agreement with Switzerland over data sharing (which includes User IP Addresses) for criminal investigations [0] while the US does [1], and Protonmail only honors Swiss litigation [2]
This should change with the new India-Switzerland FTA though.
[0] - https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess.pdf https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess....
[1] - https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%80%93NOTICE https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%...
[2] - https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement
- jwalton 3y agoI think the actual issue is that a government holds the insane belief that by blocking one out of many ways that someone could make an anonymous threat, it somehow contributes to the safety of their citizens.
- alephnerd 3y ago> blocking one out of many ways that someone could make an anonymous threat, it somehow contributes to the safety of their citizens If you make an anonymous bomb threat using Gmail in India, Google will hand off all information to the Indian government as they have operations in India and will be held liable, just like they would in the US. This is the reason why Proton AG honors American law enforcement requests - the US and Switzerland have an agreement that data platforms in both countries need to honor each other's law enforcement requests. If Proton AG won't give User metadata without litigation in Switzerland, it will get blocked in those jurisdictions it doesn't play ball with. This is why most piracy platforms and data platforms will honor metadata requests from US Law Enforcement - you will become a toxic financial liability if you choose to flout US litigation.
- shaan7 3y agoYour statements are correct but they aren't relevant to parent's point. Blocking an email provider has absolutely no positive effect on the safety of the citizens. While it has the potential of a lot of negative effects, like the inability of other innocent citizens to use their email account. It is the same thing when the GoI went ahead and blocked pastebin.com because of a bunch of pastes.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Blocking an email provider has absolutely no positive effect on the safety of the citizens I agree that it's a half assed patched, but if a platform isn't responding to litigation or law enforcement requests, there is always the chance of bad actors weaponizing that loophole. And it's not like Proton AG hasn't been linked to terror attacks. The perpetrator of the Bataclan Massacre used Protonmail to communicate with handlers, leading to the French government to require email platforms like Proton AG to honor French law enforcement requests [1]. [0] - https://www.wired.com/2015/11/isis-opsec-encryption-manuals-reveal-terrorist-group-security-protocols/ https://www.wired.com/2015/11/isis-opsec-encryption-manuals-... [1] - https://www.ejn-crimjust.europa.eu/ejnupload/DynamicPages/France_Fiches%20Belges-on-electronic-evidence.pdf https://www.ejn-crimjust.europa.eu/ejnupload/DynamicPages/Fr...
- protonmail 3y agoThat is false information, there was no connection between Proton and the Bataclan attack.
- alephnerd 3y agoUpvote this. Can't edit my previous comment which misread the wired article linked or can @Dang just delete the offending comment for incorrect/misleading info?
- heikrana 3y ago> blocked pastebin.com because of a bunch of pastes Say what now?!
- alephnerd 3y agoIt was a temporary block due to an overly broad denylist the Indian government put out in 2013. Pastebin ended up getting unblocked in India in the same time period as well.
- kumarvvr 3y ago
- mdp2021 3y ago> using Gmail in India, Google will hand off all information Why should you use am E-Mail provider to send an electronic postcard. Since when would you need a third party to send E-Mails?
- mdp2021 3y agoExplain yourself, usual annoying sniper... To the best of my memory, sending emails did not require external infrastructure.
- testhn2ac 3y ago[flagged]
- capybara_2020 3y agoIt feels like the Indian gov is reactionary and has tunnel vision. They fix one problem but never consider if that fix will cause problems elsewhere or if even if that fix is worth it.
- jszymborski 3y agoRight, but the US didn't block Yandex Mail when it was HQ'd in Russia. It's not for Switzerland's data sharing with the US that folks in the US have access to ProtonMail.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoThe issue is that India has a body of hand picked bureaucrats, who have the authority to both target and ban platforms they cannot control or spy on. The article clearly states that all was a hoax and there weren't any bombs. The Indian government is setting up a nice slippery slope here for total political control of the Internet. Perhaps ProtonMail would be better off if they just pulled out of the country.
- alephnerd 3y ago> issue is that India has a body of hand picked bureaucrats, who have the authority to both target and ban platforms they cannot control or spy on Agreed. Indian jurisprudence has not kept up and is still stuck in an authoritarian mindset found in the Colonial British legal system (same problem in Pakistan, Malaysia, Kenya, and Singapore as well btw) > setting up a nice slippery slope here for total political control of the Internet The Indian government has always had the authority to control electronic communication due to the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 [0] and it's equally authoritarian successor the Telecommunications Act, 2023 [1]. India always has been, and sadly, always will be an Illiberal Democracy, and for the exact same reasons that Malaysia, Kenya, and Pakistan will be as well. It's the original sin of the British Colonial legal system. [0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Telegraph_Act,_1885 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Telegraph_Act,_1885 [1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act,_2023 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act,_2023