5 ms·
Why the EU needs more integrated electricity markets
- pyrale 3y agoSummary : some EU energy experts believe the lesson from the 2022 crisis is we need more of the same policy.
- doingtheiroming 3y agoDamn. Came to post the same. You said it better. It's the real disease of the EU. There's no problem of failed policy that shouldn't be addressed by deepening the policy and making it harder to back track. The only possible response to problems of complexity is to make the complexity more intractable.
- pyrale 3y agoThe real shocker for me is that the authors completely ignore the difference between grid integration and market integration. They seem to hold a maximalist line where the market can and should drive planification of the power grid, and where "managerial-governance" can emerge from that abstraction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- doingtheiroming 3y agoYep. Grid integration is great. Engineered markets much less so. Sadly, the incentives for regulators and market participants are well aligned here...
- jnsaff2 3y agoI want to understand your reasoning a bit better. Care to expand please? The way I see 2022 was a crisis of energy PRICES, had the markets not been there it might have been a crisis of energy AVAILABILITY. Strictly worse.
- pyrale 3y agoInterconnexions existed before the market, and their development is not purely related to the market. A significant part of grid cooperation through ENTSO-E is about stability, not increased market benefits. If you will, this is like saying you need an exchange for trade. Well, no, OTC markets exist.
- jnsaff2 3y agoInterconnections sure, but the crisis of 2022 was mostly about cost of gas and other fossil fuels. The markets made sure that the plants got their costs covered and stayed online. One can argue whether the last-price-wins is the best market structure but how would you have forced plants to generate at a loss without nationalizing them?
- pyrale 3y ago> The markets made sure that the plants got their costs covered and stayed online. I don't really understand your point here. In an otc trade, costs are also covered, no one works for free. That being said, my original point was not even about that. It was more about lines in the article that strongly hint that, in the author's opinion, the current issue is politicians not doing enough to force their citizen to swallow the pill. Relevant paragraph: > Further market integration requires substantial political investment. Governments will need to deal with significant distributional effects within and between countries. Experience has shown that domestic political constraints in this respect are often numerous and difficult to overcome.
- mrweasel 3y agoThe problem, in this case, is that the EU lives in it's own little bubble where it assumes that the member countries and commercial interests act rationally and in the best interest of Europeans. As such I don't see an issue with an integrated electricity marked, if you at the same time ensure that countries and companies doesn't simply stop investing in energy infrastructure because: We can just buy what we need from someone else. It's fine to buy cheap wind power and shutdown a power plant if the wind is blowing, but if you only building wind farm and assuming that you can piggy back on the nuclear reactor or dams next door when the wind stops blowing, then it quickly falls appart. Each country, or region, needs to have a plan for self-sufficiency, in all circumstances, but that's not a financially sound idea. Better to have a electricity shortage once in a while, if you only care about money. This is the bit that the EU does not understand. For some reason the EU has always had a blind spot when it comes to the actions companies, and countries, will take in the name of financial gains.
- pyrale 3y ago> Better to have a electricity shortage once in a while, if you only care about money. This is the way 100% of power grids work, even the more autonomous ones. The cost to remove some once-in-a-century risks is simply too high. So every single grid operator focuses on two parameters: how often does an equipment fail, and how impactful it is to lose it.
- roenxi 3y agoSeems like an interesting article. Germany in particular. Their politicians have adopted a frivolous attitude to energy security for a long time now. Between kneecapping their own nuclear industry and the over-dependence on Russia for energy it'll be interesting to see if they get away with it. This crisis and their response to it is a real test and it is probably going to be the decisive "did it work?" moment for me of the Energiewende to date. I will also note that although they have succeeded in removing the UK from their maps, they cannot suppress the Swiss spirit. Well done Switzerland for being irrepressible.
- realusername 3y ago> This crisis and their response to it is a real test and it is probably going to be the decisive "did it work?" moment for me of the Energiewende to date. Right now they are pushing to build more gas pipelines to replace Russia so I'd say no to that. The lessons from the russian war have not been understood and this was such a big event that I don't know what else would help.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoWhat's wrong with building more gas pipelines? Maybe they's build them towards the South and connect with Turkstream - and get a mix of caspian and russian gas from there. Also Germany is building LNG terminals, but they take time and LNG is more expensive than normal natural gas, so the only "benefit" is political because they can say "we're not buying from Russia", but nothing else.
- realusername 3y agoIt's wrong because gas is a fossil fuel incompatible with the climate goals and the countries providing it (Algeria, Qatar, Azerbaidjan...) are basically the same thing as Russia. And LNG is even dirtier. So it's a bad thing diplomatically, environmentally and economically.
- p_l 3y agoThere's also a huge "earthquake" in how Germany is currently replacing how the internal electricity market is operated... Spent few weeks trying to help someone find out what kind of setup they need with the switchover, because even the grid compliance officer didn't know...
- sschueller 3y agoAbsolutely not! The reason the system is so f*d up is because we are gambling with a system critical resource. Not every system benefits from competitive markets especially infrastructure. Having a good working electricity network benefits the greater good and enables business to operate. This does not translate to short term market profits where you need to squeeze every possible dime out of the system. From cutting unneeded maintenance to paying the lowest possible salaries will catch up with you in 10-20 years when the system collapses. The tax payer will be the one paying for the damages and the "criminals" that caused the damage will be retired with their fortune.
- roenxi 3y ago> ...from cutting unneeded maintenance to paying the lowest possible salaries will catch up with you in 10-20 years when the system collapses... I don't think you're taking a clear view of the incentive structure around expensive capital assets. These are massive investments in infrastructure that often need to be paid back over 10-20 year periods before they make a profit. At some point the investment becomes so huge that the owners are incentivised to run even at a loss for a year or so to avoid the pain of writing down the capital they spent so much on. Skimping on maintenance and salaries isn't what the incentives push towards in a free market. In fact, having worked in similar environments, there is a slight tendency to overpay on salaries and over-invest in maintenance since they make relatively little difference to the profitability of the project and the derisking is extremely valuable. If an investor isn't planning on paying for maintenance and playing a long game, infrastructure investment is unlikely to appeal (at least not in a standard free market).
- hulitu 3y agoWell, they claimed that sometimes, electricity price is negative. What stops someone charging a battery _only_ when the price is negative ?
- jnsaff2 3y agoWell nothing stops you from doing that of course. It's just that the LCOE will be very high as you use your battery very rarely and the capital cost of the battery spread over the charge cycles will be very high.
- conradfr 3y agoNo wonder it's written by someone from Germany. I think in France right now we could reinstate the guillotine just for him.
- p4bl0 3y agoThis couldn't be farther from the truth. The electricity market is a disaster that drives the prices artificially high. There is no more correlation between production price and consumption price. A centralized planning would greatly benefit everyone here (well except for shareholders of so-called "alternative suppliers" companies). If you speak French, this series of video on the Heu?reka YouTube channel explains all this very well, both from the technical side and from the financial side. The videos are rather long because they go in depth on the subject: - Comprendre le marché de l'électricité (Understanding the eletricity market) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ienoSbONyhw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ienoSbONyhw - Les super-profits des fournisseurs alternatifs (The super-profits of alternative suppliers) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3to46JLDu8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3to46JLDu8 - Comprendre la bourse de l'électricité : le maché SPOT (Understanding the electricity exchange: the SPOT market) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZCKv0C6Dqs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZCKv0C6Dqs - Pourquoi prix de l'élecricité = coût de la centrale la plus chère ? Comprendre le modèle (Why the price of electricity = the cost of the most expensive central? Understanding the underlying model) : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ep3biZAtitE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ep3biZAtitE
- NotGMan 3y ago>> There is no more correlation between production price and consumption price. This, it's basicaly the "financialization of electricity". When I looked at the cost of electricity production vs the buying price for it in my country there was a total disconnect. The power plants don't feed my country anymore: they feed the market, which then scams the buyers.
- piva00 3y agoExactly, when the Russian invasion of Ukraine started in 2022 I was hit with absurd prices for electricity, even though I live in Sweden where we don't depend at all on gas for electricity generation (it's all nuclear/hydro/wind). I still had to pay absurd prices because of the scam of financial markets taking over electricity in the EU, why the fuck do I have to pay the highest spot price of a whole continent when none of that energy is reaching me? Natural monopolies should be in the hands of the people through the State, allowing grifters to append themselves to extract rent from those natural monopolies is just ridiculous...
- ExoticPearTree 3y ago> "The energy crisis of 2022, triggered by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, posed a massive challenge to Europe’s integrated energy markets. Exceptionally high gas prices drove up the cost of gas-fired power plants, on top of which, France’s nuclear fleet, a crucial component of the western European electricity system, suffered unprecedented outages" The crisis was self-inflicted by the EU on itself: Brussels dropped imports from Russia and the prices went high-sky. They could have minded their own business and Europe could have enjoyed low gas and energy prices, but no... why waste an opportunity of a war to screw something up?
- machinekob 3y agoDamn that one of most brain dead comments i saw in a while. Appeasement never ends well, if EU wasn't so soft on 2014 invasion, r*ssian would not dare to attack in 2022.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoIt's not about appeasement. It is about minding your own business and doing what is best for your citizens. And cheap gas is better than expensive gas, and by extension cheap energy is what is best. You can downvote me as much as you want, but every government's job is to ensure the best for its people and then and only then help others. And because gas prices have tripled/quadrupled for political reasons only, I consider this a failure of all EU governments towards their citizens.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoEvery governments' first job before all else is to continue to exist. -- A government that ceases to exist (eg. by being conquered) fails to do anything at all, let alone what is best for its citizens. This is almost a tautology, because eg. try to make a "list of governments that do not exist". (see also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night-watchman_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night-watchman_state for a view on the absolute minimal requirements for a workable state.)
- mamonster 3y agoThe underlying logic of this is the same dumb thinking that caused all the stupid infrastructure privatizations of the last 20 years: That the government should "make money" on infrastructure, and if it can't it should privatize it. The entire point of infrastructure is that the government runs it at a loss, the loss gets captured by the private sector/household, and the multiplier effect makes it a positive thing on the whole. The government should ensure the money is well spent, but if it is then 1 dollar of electricity deficit(on government side) is like 1.2-1.3 dollars of surplus somewhere else on the balance sheet.
- adev_ 3y agoThe EU electricity market is very interesting if you are a trader. For everyone else, It is a giant shit show responsible of a price increase of around x2 in the last 3 years. And there is not a single valid physical or technical reason to that. It is fundamentally broken: - It has been designed around the marginal cost of production. Which implies that the price of Electricity is directly correlated on the price of Coal and Gas. A top level ludicrous move in middle of a green energy transition. - It is designed around the concept of energy (Twh) without any consideration on the notion of the power at peak. Consequently their is almost no financial incentive from investors to pay for storage capacity or production medium that will be needed during peak hours. It is a system that makes the grid more and more unstable with time and the states have to compensate that with massive subsidies for storage and fossil fuel power plants... - The general idea to propagate the variability of the energy price on the final customer by making small business pay themselves at market rate has shown to be a gigantic mistake. A Lot of small business were not able to afford "temporarily" 3-4-10x the average electricity price due to sudden envy of Vladimir Putin to visit his neighbour. The variability killed them, that was entirely avoidable. This article has been written by the financial people. The same gurus that put this idiotic system in pplace. Wierdly, every middle size company owner I know has a very different point of view about this when they receive their energy bill.
- jnsaff2 3y ago> almost no financial incentive from investors to pay for storage capacity or production medium that will be needed during peak hours. I don't follow your logic. If there is a large difference between prices during the day then there is a large incentive to build daily storage. You earn more the bigger the price differences there are and the more storage comes online the more prices even out over the day.
- adev_ 3y ago> If there is a large difference between prices during the day then there is a large incentive to build daily storage. Real peak does not happen during the day. The real peak happens around 10-15 days per year, during winter and when temperature drop. These are the days where protecting the Grid against blackout is challenging. No investor are keen to billions on the table for an hypothetical investment that will be profitable 10 days per year, at best.
- kkfx 3y agoThe real answer is simple: states who have much nuclear or public utilities have far lower prices than states who have choose the private way, the coal way and so on. As a results such states do dislike having citizens that compare prices in other EU states judging their politics...