4 ms·
Except that, from all reports online (including someone in these comments), Amazon will cancel your annual Prime subscription and refund all remaining time with
by crazygringo 3y ago
Except that, from all reports online (including someone in these comments), Amazon will cancel your annual Prime subscription and refund all remaining time without any problem. They don't seem to be holding anyone to the contract. (And of course plenty of people subscribe monthly rather than annually as well.)
So I'm not sure there's any case here at all? Since even with annual subscriptions, it seems you can cancel at any time and get a prorated refund.
The fact is, online subscription services change their benefits/features all the time. And companies seem to handle it two ways: grandfather existing customers for the rest of their subscription period, or offer prorated refunds for people who want to cancel. And while the former is definitely going to make customers happier, I think they're both acceptable from a legal standpoint? So I'm not sure this lawsuit has any chance of succeeding at all.
- Retric 3y agoSimply canceling mid contract isn’t a perfect remedy. Consider, should they get to keep the interest on the money they are handing back to you? Obviously not. Contracts are enforceable because society is much worse off if they aren’t. Imagine if your bank could arbitrarily cancel a car loan and ask for the outstanding balance back at any time simple because they felt like it.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoEnjoy the pennies on your interest.
- Retric 3y ago6 months on 139$ /2 @ 6% is $2.09 not just a few cents. Multiply that by everyone with an annual prime membership and your talking 1/2 billion dollars or so.
- crazygringo 3y agoIt's only being multiplied by the number of people who are canceling because of this. If that's 0.1% of 200 million subscribers who cancel, that's about $400K in supposed interest. Not half a billion. A rounding error for Amazon. But interest just doesn't generally factor into small consumer "returns". If you buy shoes online and then return them 25 days later because they don't match the photos exactly, you don't get interest on that either. At these amounts, it's not worth worrying about.
- Retric 3y agoAmazon canceled the existing deal for 100% of their customers and thus accepted money without delivering the advertised service. What happens in the future is a different question, especially when they aren’t willing to give a full refund. Also when you return something you got the utility of the item and deprive the seller of the item for that time period. Larger up front payment for services not rendered is simply a net loss.
- crazygringo 3y ago> The number who accept the new deal or don’t even notice the difference is irrelevant to this calculation. Of course it's relevant. If someone doesn't cancel, there's nothing being refunded, so there's no theoretical interest to be paid back. They accept that, going forwards, the deal is still worth it for them. The refund-with-interest you brought up isn't about compensation for no longer having video without ads, it's about the remainder of your payment having been tied up during your previous usage. If you continue the subscription, that means you want to continue to keep the upfront payment in exchange for the lower annual rate. There's no interest on anything to be paid back. It wouldn't make any conceptual sense.
- Retric 3y ago> They accept that, going forwards, the deal is still worth it for them. People doing nothing isn’t consent. ~0.1% of their customers die each month, you can’t argue the dead are accepting a new deal. Further, if you’re unwilling to preform a full refund, they are asking if the service is worth $69.50 not the $71.59 or whatever they actually owe you. A slightly worse service for slightly less money isn’t a true test here. > If you continue the subscription, that means you want to continue to keep the upfront payment in exchange for the lower annual rate. Order and pay for a burger and fries from McDonalds and accepting a burger from them isn’t saying they don’t still owe you the fries. There is no continuing a contract that’s already been broken. You can accept a new contract going forward but that’s a different question.
- cma 3y agoCan you finance monthly payments on a new Fire TV from Amazon and then midway through just quit paying: but to keep it from being a tort in the same way, let them have you send it back if they want it. And they have to go through your confusing UI or wait on hold for 40 minutes to request you send it back, but you don't pay any more either way.
- crazygringo 3y agoNot with Amazon, but that was historically a business model for things like TV's, called rent-to-own. If you couldn't keep paying, you had to bring it back to the store. After enough payments, it was yours.
- blibble 3y agothe commitment for both parties was 12 months presumably they wouldn't like it if I unilaterally decided to say, pay them $7/month instead of $8.99/month halfway through the commitment how is it acceptable the other way round? if they don't want to provide the service that was committed to they should refund the entire purchase amount (not just pro-rata)
- chung8123 3y agoHow does that work? They obviously can add and remove content so that wasn't in the commitment. Was ad free streaming on all their content in the commitment?
- crazygringo 3y agoBut if you tried to pay $7 they'd just say no, and cancel your service. So in your example, there is no difference. It would work the same both ways. (Gym memberships sometimes won't cancel in the middle, nor will cell phone contracts that subsidize your initial phone -- but in my experience most monthly subscriptions and utilities will just cancel you.)