3 ms·
I think is important to look at the macro question: If you are looking at the market as a whole (all the apps that get bought) will most of the discovery/purcha
by netcan 18y ago
I think is important to look at the macro question: If you are looking at the market as a whole (all the apps that get bought) will most of the discovery/purchase decision have taken place within the confines of the app store (where Apple rules) or outside of it (from word of mouth to TV ads).
I think you might agree that most (or at least a significant portion) of apps will get most of their 'promotion' within the confines of the app store. This is both because of the distribution monopoly & because of the market mindset. Consumers are often buying 'apps' not 'app X' or even 'app that does X.' There will continue to be a big number of App store browsers making decisions based only on the things they encounter in this environment. Therefore, the app store is the no. 1 promotional channel as well as the only distribution channel.
Since Apple is the main influence on this, the letter makes sense. If you think that this environment is problematic on the whole, Dear Steve is your answer.
I guess I agree with you from an individual perspective. I do not know enough about this market to have a real opinion. But it seems rational to say to developers: "Do not go after the main part of the market (let's keep calling it the ringtone app market). The way Apple has set up the market, there is a tendency towards the ringtone apps. If you do not want to sell them, you still have other options. Base your strategy on those option."
But I guess my point is that the advice you are giving is 'be unconventional' which is not something you can expect everyone to do. It's like telling online merchants not to base their e-commerce strategy on Adwords/SEO or telling a supermarket not to go after middle income families. That might be good advice, but it's niche advice.
- jfarmer 18y agoMore I think that the App Store is a tiny segment of a larger market, one in which price is what drives demand. There are larger segments where other marketing techniques are more applicable, where nobody is playing. So, go play there!
- netcan 18y agoI'm not sure I understand. The app store is a tiny segment of the app market.