5 ms·
I do not know about medicare per se, but when social security was designed to support people 65 and over, I think life expectancy was around age 62. So it was d
by Mz 15y ago
I do not know about medicare per se, but when social security was designed to support people 65 and over, I think life expectancy was around age 62. So it was designed to support a relatively small number of retirees in their extreme old age. Then people began living longer.
Somewhat similarly, welfare was aimed at a tiny fraction of "the deserving poor" but was poorly worded/thought out and thus inadvertently changed the social contract and thereby actively grew the number of poor moms. At the time it was created, having a kid out of wedlock was strongly taboo. Poor single moms were thus mostly widows. The authors apparently could not imagine it becoming more socially acceptable to have children out of wedlock.
I worked at bigco for five years. Similarly shortsighted wording for contracts and the like is pretty rampant from what I have seen.
- dkrich 15y ago> I do not know about medicare per se, but when social security was designed to support people 65 and over, I think life expectancy was around age 62. So it was designed to support a relatively small number of retirees in their extreme old age. Then people began living longer. This is true, but the real problems with Social Security began when Lyndon Johnson combined the Social Security fund, then entirely separate, with the rest of the federal budget. Instead of maintaining a very close eye on how much money was coming in and going out for Social Security, there was no longer any urgency to keep that money around. In other words, money taken out of paychecks for Social Security was spent on everything else, and Federal income taxes were paid out as Social Security.
- Mz 15y agoFrom what I have read, it is complicated, probably too complicated for me to ever debate off the cuff. And I am especially not qualified right now. But thanks for contributing.
- nknight 15y agoThe Republican-invented meme of social security insolvency because it didn't account for life expectancy increases is tired and worn out. The reality is that the architects of it were nowhere near that stupid, and they accounted for evolving life expectancies with a fairly high degree of accuracy. Had they not, the fund would have been bankrupt long ago. Even now, the system faces not a crisis, but a need for adjustments. In the 2030s, incoming taxes are expected to be at approximately 75% of payouts. If no changes are made, once the trust fund is exhausted, people will continue receiving at least 75% of their entitlement indefinitely.
- shelf 15y agoNot being able to pay your outgoings is the definition of insolvency, friend. On the other hand, the government is not quite a 'corporation,' and isn't entirely subject to those kinds of notions, is it?
- nknight 15y ago> Not being able to pay your outgoings is the definition of insolvency, friend. Didn't say it wasn't. Try not randomly reshuffling the words. You'll get a much clearer picture of what I actually said.
- shelf 15y agoOnly paying part of your outgoings is considered 'not paying,' or grounds for a default, typically? So that 'meme' is pretty much factual reality, if your statistics are correct? disclosure: non-American with no knowledge of your welfare scheme
- lolcraft 15y agoNot being able to pay something twenty years from now given current income is much different than defaulting. Specially given historically low tax rates and an economic depression, and a spenditure that has mostly not been made yet.
- shelf 15y agoI agree, but that doesn't seem particularly relevant. The system in question would generate significant revenue shortfall if that fellow's comments are accurate. Typically in public policy we make plans for these kinds of scenarios, instead of just assuming that Future Murika will have a tax base robust enough to pilfer from and a political scenario permitting us to actually legislate. On the other hand, that strategy is working fine for Twitter...
- nknight 15y ago
- lurker14 15y ago> I think life expectancy was around age 62 You are thinking of life expectancy at birth, which averages in childhood death. SS only pays people who worked for at least a few years, so life expectancy for people who reach age ~20 is much higher.