3 ms·
It makes sense to give thinking sentient creatures rights, be they carbon or silicon lifeforms. But I think giving current AI rights is jumping the gun quite a
by godelski 3y ago
It makes sense to give thinking sentient creatures rights, be they carbon or silicon lifeforms. But I think giving current AI rights is jumping the gun quite a bit and will have fairly bad consequences. Namely if AI can invent pattents then what's to stop OpenAI, Google, Meta, Anthropic, etc from claiming ownership of any work invented with the help of their AI tools? Our goals are to protect the little guy. Someday in the future I hope that this will include artificial life, but for now protecting the little guy means protecting ownership over their ideas and work irrespective of their tooling used to generate that work.
- sublinear 3y agoIn the absence of more rigorous definitions of "life" or "sentience" we must have such laws. This has been an issue for a long time and doesn't just affect AI (people on life support, abortion, etc). Surely we should solve those legal problems before deciding whether an AI gets to be a person.
- godelski 3y agoIt may be possible that we never have such a definition and we're stuck with Justice Potter's reasoning. You're certainly right that there are complexities, but this is an argument about focusing on the spirit of the law and recognizing that there are many nuances that cause there to be no globally optimal solution for the vast majority of problems (if not all).
- ForIveSyntax 3y agoMaybe machines will deserve rights eventually. However, the nature of those rights would be different. Going without electricity for any amount of time just amounts to a temporary loss of consciousness, whereas animals starve. Data can be duplicated with ease. Lots of differences between carbon-based and hypothetical silicon-based life.
- godelski 3y agoYeah I think when we have artificial sentience we will have to have different specifics. It makes sense. Should be the same with different biologicals too. I think this is how we should generally think about artificial sentient creatures, think about aliens. But I think at an abstract level we should all be equal. Specific will be different, but general abstract rights should be the same. Like what you point out has to deal with death. But it can get more nuanced and real fast. Removing a biological's arm is significant destruction. Removing a robot's arm is still damage, but not life altering as it can be either reattached (if it was simply disassembled), likely easily repairable, and most certainly replaceable. So the punishment should be different. The reverse situation might be forcing one into a MRI machine. Annoying for human, death for the robot. Backups also are tricky as we have to get into the whole philosophical debate about what self means and without a doubt there is "death" between the time/experiences that were lost (maybe bad analogy is force teleporting someone into the future, but where they just take over the consciousness of the future self and have no memories of the time between despite it actually having happened). Yeah, I agree that it's going to make things more complicated and it is very much worth thinking about. It's important if you believe in aliens too (why wouldn't you?), because if it is ever possible to make contact with them (I'm certain we have not already. You're not going to convince me with tic-tacs), we will need to adapt to them too. It's a general statement for "non-human life." IMO I think this is why it is so important to focus on the spirit of the law rather than the letter. The letter is a compression of the spirit and it is without a doubt a lossy compression. Not to mention that time exists...
- ForIveSyntax 3y agoI wonder if you could be prosecuted based on how long you turned a sentient machine off. Not murder, per se, but the time value of consciousness. And this bleeds into whether murder should be a bigger crime if the (bio)victim is younger. What might you try to say is the general spirit? The crime of denying agency over time?
- godelski 3y agoI would conditionally be in favor of that actually. But it may be difficult to properly contextualize, especially not being a creature that does this. Sleep is analogous but incomplete. Maybe closer to anesthesia? Like if you forcefully placed someone into a coma we'd consider that a crime, but we don't consider it to be the case for a doctor, even if a doctor does it (acting as a doctor, not just being a doctor) without the person's consent. Context matters. This aspect to me comes down to reasonable (like medical) and/or necessity (like sleep) I'm sure we'd also have to consider lifetime lengths. I don't think someone drugging me for a day should receive the same punishment as someone that did it for a month who didn't do the same as someone that took years from me. And which years matter. The question is how we deal with this for entities with different lifespans. (sorry if I'm verbose, distillation takes time. I also communicate better through analogies and I think it is also illustrative of the spirit argument as you must understand intent over what's actually said) So I think the spirit of these laws is centered around robing someone of time, because time is a non-reversible (and definitely not invertible) process that has a has significant value. That's what the laws' underlying intent is (at least partially) aligned to. So that's what I'd call the spirit. It's quite possible other entities see time differently and length of time has different value impacts as well as the means for removing said time. Overall I think these things are deceptively simple. But in reality nuance dominates. I think this is a far more general phenomena than many care to admit, probably because our brains are intended to simplify as it's far more energy efficient. I mention this though because it is critical to understanding the argument and how (at least I personally) we can make future predictions and thus what we must consider.