17 ms·
> demonstrating that the act of creation isn't special. And that undermines categories of justifications for IP. The purpose of patents is simply to encourage
by JohnFen 3y ago
> demonstrating that the act of creation isn't special. And that undermines categories of justifications for IP.
The purpose of patents is simply to encourage invention and discourage keeping inventions a secret. It's not premised on the "act of creation being special".
The way this is most likely to play out is that humans will use AI as tools to help them invent things, not that AI will invent things all by itself. So the premise and need for patents will remain intact.
If, however, AI somehow accomplishes the same goal as the patent system, then the patent system becomes unnecessary and will go away. As long as the goal is still being achieved, that's OK.
- romeros 3y agoI thought the purpose was to make sure other don't benefit from your own hardwork.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat's the purpose of a patent. It's not the purpose of patents (as a system.)
- JohnFen 3y agoThat's not the purpose, that's the carrot the patent system gives in exchange for the invention being disclosed and ultimately (within a couple of decades) made available for general use. The purpose of the patent system, really, is to benefit society, not inventors.
- bediger4000 3y agoThat's the putative reason for both parents and copyright. And I addressed that: the machine isn't motivated economically to increase the public domain. The real reason is to own ideas, because people feel that creation is special. Takes hard work, or creativity or inspiration from the gods. Machine generated ideas undermines all of that.