4 ms·
Not really -- real estate is pretty unique in that regard. Property taxes aren't a restriction on use, as you present it -- they're a requirement for continued
by crazygringo 3y ago
Not really -- real estate is pretty unique in that regard. Property taxes aren't a restriction on use, as you present it -- they're a requirement for continued ownership.
I'm not going to go as far as the parent commenter to say it means you don't own it, but I can't think of any other possession where the government takes it away if you don't keep paying. Not books or washing machines or food or anything.
Even with vehicles, you need to pay to keep them registered but if you don't you just can't drive them on public roads. They're not taken away from you.
So real estate really is in a kind of special "you mostly own it but kinda not entirely".
- hef19898 3y agoIn Germany, cars. We pay taxes in car ownership. Thing is so, tax debt or default doesn't lead to the state taking you property away (ultimately yes, but then you are at default for a vwry long time and probably bankcrupt anyway). It just means you have to repay you debt, tax authorities might seize e.g. bank accounts. And even banks prefer refinancing over foreclosures, selling real estate is a risk and work German banks like to avoid.
- crazygringo 3y agoFrom what I can find online, you don't have to pay that tax if you de-register the car, i.e. no longer use it on public roads. So it's not really any different from vehicle registration in the US. It's not a tax on vehicle ownership, but rather on annual usage of public roads per vehicle.
- hef19898 3y agoTrue! The vast majority of people so are not collecting cars, hence generaly people tax for the cars they own. You are absolutely right so, as long as you don't use your car on public roads, you don't pay taxes, don't need insurance or TÜV.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoStill disagree. There are lots of things you need to actively spend effort and/or money on that the government will take away if you don't. Pets are one big category of stuff. Dangerous items are another.
- crazygringo 3y agoYou're undoing your own point. Your exact words were: > Ownership isn't and never is absolute possession. Actually, it usually mostly is. There are exceptions, but generally speaking it is absolute possession. It's not conditional. It's called property rights for a reason. The fact that you're bringing up exceptions just proves the existence of the rule in the just place. That doesn't mean you can use your property to do harm to others, or that you can bring it anywhere you want, or that it can't be seized if you refuse to pay debts. But most things you actually do simply own, flat-out, unlike real estate with its property tax requirement.