3 ms·
It could be the stability of Earth's systems is just an illusion created by observer selection. If it had not been within limits, we wouldn't be here. This pl
by pfdietz 3y ago
It could be the stability of Earth's systems is just an illusion created by observer selection. If it had not been within limits, we wouldn't be here. This places no constraint on how stable it will be in the future.
Another part of the system that could be like that is the oxygen content of the atmosphere. The time constant for variation in O2 level is just a few million years (due to consumption of O2 by release of reducing gases and weathering of rocks to expose reduced materials like ferrous iron.) If it had ever dropped too much during the Phanerozoic higher life would have been wiped out. I don't believe any plausible feedback control mechanism has been discovered. In particular, fire involving plants (which couldn't have occurred before the evolution of large land plants) can be a positive feedback, as charcoal is very resistant to further oxidation and, when buried, represents a net increase in atmospheric oxygen.
Maybe, if mankind explores the galaxy, we'll find all these formerly life bearing planets where stability failed.
- BirAdam 3y agoStability is an illusion. It’s becoming increasingly evident that even small shifts in climate have triggered devastating events for humans, like the Bronze Age Collapse, plagues, and so on. Plus, there’s the whole end of the last glaciation that likely created the various flood myths and wiped out most of the megafauna.
- pfdietz 3y agoArguably Venus and Mars were more habitable than Earth in the earlier solar system. Both fell off the stability wagon and now are dead worlds (with possible survival of deep underground life on Mars.)