3 ms·
If I memorize a book, am I guilty of copyright infringement?
by pfdietz 3y ago
If I memorize a book, am I guilty of copyright infringement?
- AlexandrB 3y agoYes if you write it back out again.
- pfdietz 3y agoWhat if I merely demonstrate knowledge that means I've memorized the book? For example, being able to answer yes/no questions about what's on a particular page? The point I'm trying to make here is that in this situation I have a representation of the entire book in my brain. Haven't I copied it into my neurons?
- nhinck2 3y agoDo you profit from people testing your ability to memorise the book and give them the ability to substantially recreate the original work and act in competition to the original author?
- sebzim4500 3y agoDo LLM providers?
- pfdietz 3y agoProfiting from the act is not a requirement for it to be copyright infringement.
- romwell 3y agoWhen ChatGPT gets agency regarding what goes into training data and what doesn't, gets paid minimum wage for the work it does, and can be held liable for violations of the law, your question will be very relevant. Until then...
- PeterisP 3y agoIf we're technical, there is a substantial legal difference between your brain and an AI system, because the criteria for what counts as a copy is defined (in US) as "“Copies” are material objects, other than phonorecords, in which a work is fixed by any method now known or later developed, and from which the work can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device. The term “copies” includes the material object, other than a phonorecord, in which the work is first fixed." and all the law precedent doesn't consider any representation of something in your brain as "the work being fixed" , so that isn't a copy and anything that applies to copies doesn't apply to your memory, but do apply to any computer memory or any future technical method to make that representation. So analogies to the brain aren't appropriate, because human memories are special and separate in the eyes of law, and if we'd make a machine that does literally exactly the same thing as your brain does, it will still NOT have the same legal treatment as your brain; there is no legal principle that it should get equal or similar treatment.
- pfdietz 3y agoI don't see why brains don't satisfy the legal definition, if I have truly memorized the book, unless you are trying to claim that brains aren't material objects. Encoding a book by tattooing it on my back would count, wouldn't it? Or by encoding it in DNA and injecting it into some of my cells. Why would using the brain be different?
- PeterisP 3y agoThe definition of a "copy" requires it to be fixed in a tangible, durable medium. This law has explicitly chosen to make a strong, major black&white distinction between intangible things and things that are fixed e.g. on paper. According to legal precedent, memories in human brains are considered these intangible things and not considered fixed in a tangible medium, ergo, those do not count as "copies" as far as copyright law is concerned. Tatooing on your back or a fixed encoding would IMHO indeed probably count as fixed in a tangible medium, but that's not really relevant. And there is some argumentation about why using the brain is different (e.g. that it does't permit the unchanged reproduction of the information stored, memories tend to be fleeting and incomplete), but again, that's not relevant and any flaws in that argument don't really matter. The key point is that the argument is settled. It doesn't matter what argument you or I could make about whether using the brain is different or the same, no one cares about that argument, we have no right to re-try that question, because this discussion has been heard by the relevant courts, and it is over - it's now part of settled law, and it doesn't matter if you now figure out a better argument or the original argumentation was shoddy, the discussion is finished, and your opponent effectively has the right to demand that the judge ignores your argument and instead apply the existing case law. As it has been legally "accepted" in precedent that memories do not count as fixed on a tangible medium, then that sticks, that effectively becomes part the legal definition of what "fixed on a tangible medium" axiomatically means. Any appeal to biology/physics/whatever is pretty much irrelevant - if future science comes up with incontrovertible evidence that indeed memories store a fixed, durable, unchanged copy and are literal equivalent of tatooing a copy on your back, that doesn't matter, all it means that the colloquial understanding of "fixed on a durable medium" (which then would include memories) has diverged from the legal definition of "fixed on a durable medium", which does not. If you want to apply logic, in this context "memories don't count as fixed on a durable medium" is an axiom - changing it is possible by passing new law, but not purely by some arguments that it should be treated differently; a key common law principle is that we assume that the earlier cases have been correctly decided and don't re-litigate that with new arguments.
- wvenable 3y agoIf you just write it for yourself, then no.
- yenwodyah 3y agoHuman brains are not large language models.
- wvenable 3y agoLarge language models are also not databases of text.
- jpc0 3y agoThought question, not entirely related but if you want to go that that route it actually is. If I generate some media in say Photoshop. I then send you a JPEG representation of said media. You then distribute a PNG copy of the image without license. Have you violated copyright law? At what point is there enough parameters to an LLM that it is effectively just a compressed version. How about deduplicated storage? Is an image stored on that and the reproduced using an index of some sort to distribute a violation. If I put data into a thing,lets call it training and lets call the thing a model, and then I request the data out of it and get what is perceived as an exact replication of said thing did I create a copy. Does it matter if we call the thing a hard drive instead?
- hn_acker 3y ago> I then send you a JPEG representation of said media. You then distribute a PNG copy of the image without license. The purpose and function of an image format is to represent a single piece. The representation can vary in accuracy and can be changed to another representation (JPEG to PNG, or one JPEG implementation to another JPEG implementation), but the underlying piece is supposed to be the same in intent and a majority of the time is the same in practice. Open the JPEG image using any program that implements the JPEG specification and you will get the same image as with a different such program. The same would apply to the use of encryption on the image, but not to a cryptographic hash (designed to be one-way). Decrypt the encrypted image and you'll get something that's the same in intent and in technicality as the original image. If you don't use a tool which has the purpose of decrypting things then you almost certainly won't get the same image back. The same only partially but at least partially applies to an AI: if you don't try to use the AI to reproduce an existing work then you still might get a reproduction of an existing work; the probability of such a result varies greatly depending on the prompt. The purpose of an LLM isn't to reproduce one or more works - or rather, sections of expression - in the dataset. The purpose of an LLM is to produce speech similar to a human's response. The purpose of an image generator model is to produce images that have the characteristics specified in the prompt. In order to produce a copy of something in the training set, the prompt usually needs to reference a specific work, a related person (e.g. an author), a related work, or an attribute that is strongly associated with a particular work/author. Regarding the latter, there was a Hacker News post (that I can't find because I forgot the post title) from a month or two back about an AI image generator that produced images of the robot C-3PO from Star Wars even though the prompt was about "space" and "robot" with no reference to Star Wars. My interpretation is that the AI model had a strong association between space robot and Star Wars because C-3PO is (I speculate) one of the most common space-related robots that people talk about online. Or perhaps, the Star Wars works in the training set made up a majority of the works associated with both "space" and "robot". But I digress. The likelihood that an AI produces a copy of existing expression depends on the prompt. A user who encounters such a case can avoid liability by not using and not sharing the output, and otherwise the output might not substitute for the original expression for the user's purposes. So in most cases I think liability for the infringinging outputs of an AI model should fall solely on the prompter. The liability that should fall on the developer of the AI model doesn't have to be binary. There can be heavier penalties on the developer for an AI that is more likely to reproduce C-3PO when given a vague prompt such as "space robot", lesser penalties on the developer for a model that only produces C-3PO when the prompt is at least as specific as "space war robot", and even lesser or no penalties for a model that only produces C-3PO from a prompt as specific as "golden space robot". The threshold for vague prompt would vary; for a prompt such as "painting of melting clock" I would excuse a partial reproduction of Salvador Dalí's The Persistence of Memory.