4 ms·
> I think this is wrong, it should not be possible to patent life forms. Consider that if they couldn’t protect their work, they never would have invested the
by Aurornis 3y ago
> I think this is wrong, it should not be possible to patent life forms.
Consider that if they couldn’t protect their work, they never would have invested the money into making these and offering them for sale to begin with.
I understand why some might find it unpleasant, but the fact that these exist at all is a testament to why such protections are available.
- KerrAvon 3y agoIt’s not, though. There is a perfectly viable market of seeds and such for non-biolumenescent plants. You can, in fact, plant watermelon seeds and use the seeds in the resulting watermelon to plant more watermelon plants. Crazy.
- Aurornis 3y ago> There is a perfectly viable market of seeds and such for non-biolumenescent plants. I don’t understand what you’re trying to argue, but the patent laws aren’t designed to patent generic, pre-existing plants like generic watermelon.
- pests 3y agoHow is that crazy? That's how plants work. This is not a natural plant though.
- shellfishgene 3y agoThat's not really true for most popular high-performance varieties, most are hybrids and growing them from the harvested seed will lose the characteristics. That's why most commercial farmers buy from a supplier every year instead of saving seeds, and that's the reason for a viable market.
- ryathal 3y agoCommercial farmers also sign agreements to not plant harvested seeds. Monsanto has successfully sued several farmers for not complying with that contract.
- autoexec 3y ago> Consider that if they couldn’t protect their work, they never would have invested the money into making these and offering them for sale to begin with. That's a massive assumption. Plenty of other plants are sold every single day that aren't patented. There's zero reason to assume that they couldn't make a very nice profit on these plants without a patent. Just like every single florist in the country does.
- lukas099 3y agoThose plants probably had nowhere near the R&D costs of the glowing petunias
- shellfishgene 3y agoI think they would lose nonethless, because they are specialized on genetic modification, and if there was no patent protection any experienced mass grower of petunias could undercut them by buying a single plant, cloning it, and growing it in large numbers.
- autoexec 3y agoAnyone selling petunias last year could have also undercut the next guy selling petunias because they were already selling basically identical products, no cloning step needed, but somehow multiple florists manage to exist and be profitable.
- samus 3y agoFor this plant maybe, as they are pretty much a frivolity. Actual cash crops are another story. Edit: it also seems that nontrivial engineering work was required to improve bioluminescence. It was not as simple as straightforwardly splicing in a few genes from a mushroom.