4 ms·
Preventing other browsers from implementing PWAs does not improve security in iOS. This is a self-serving restriction intended to discourage users from switchin
by commoner 3y ago
Preventing other browsers from implementing PWAs does not improve security in iOS. This is a self-serving restriction intended to discourage users from switching away from Safari.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kj99 3y agoHow exactly does it discourage users from switching away from safari?
- commoner 3y agoWith these changes, Safari is the only browser allowed by Apple to implement PWAs on iOS, which gives Safari an advantage over the other browsers that are not allowed to implement PWAs on iOS. Anyone who uses PWAs on iOS must do so via Safari. PWA users who prefer a non-Safari browser on iOS must switch between their preferred browser and Safari for their web browsing needs. The additional burden of maintaining two web browsers discourages these users from switching away from Safari, and the entire setup prevents these users from leaving Safari completely.
- kj99 3y agoThat’s not what’s happening here. PWA’s are disabled altogether in the EU to avoid exactly this favoritism.
- commoner 3y agoAccording to the article, the latest iOS beta prevents non-Safari browsers from adding PWA icons to the home screen. These changes retain iOS's favoritism of Safari.
- kj99 3y agoNot just non-safari browsers.
- commoner 3y agoFrom TFA: > PWAs can’t be linked to alternative browsers. Apple simply doesn’t allow it anymore at the operating system or launcher level. Users in the EU are forced to open them in Safari, if they want to open them at all.
- kj99 3y agoRead it more carefully. PWAs are no longer supported, even in safari. Any old PWAs that were already in the launcher just become web links. They happen to open in safari, but they are not PWAs, and no new such links can be created. This is just a way to not delete the old links from the user's launcher until they have had time to create new bookmarks in the browser of their choice. If you are going to argue the this somehow advantages Safari, you aren't being serious.
- commoner 3y ago> no new such links can be created The article doesn't say that. It says that Apple is changing iOS in the EU so that PWAs can't be linked to alternative (non-Safari) browsers. The article doesn't mention any changes to other PWA features like notifications for PWAs/links added to the home screen via Safari. It only says that, in the EU, Apple removed full-screen mode for PWAs from Safari while restricting non-Safari browsers from adding PWA icons to the home screen.
- kj99 3y agohttps://www.perplexity.ai/search/6a34e8f6-362a-45de-9c8b-3fc09fb2ea42 https://www.perplexity.ai/search/6a34e8f6-362a-45de-9c8b-3fc... Stop focusing on just the article and do some background reading.
- burnerthrow008 3y ago> Safari is the only browser allowed by Apple to implement PWAs on iOS, which gives Safari an advantage over the other browsers that are not allowed to implement PWAs on iOS Thank you for explaining so succinctly why Apple is compelled by regulation to remove the PWA feature from Safari. To do otherwise would be anticompetitive and risk the wrath of the EC.
- commoner 3y agoApple is not compelled to remove PWAs from Safari in the EU, because Apple has the option of allowing non-Safari browsers to implement PWAs. Apple chose to remove a PWA feature from Safari and prevent non-Safari browsers from adding PWA icons to home screens, which degrades functionality for all iOS users in the EU while still granting Safari an anticompetitive advantage.
- kj99 3y agoYou aren’t making sense. How does it grant safari an advantage if no browser has PWAs?
- commoner 3y agoAs the article says, Apple is changing iOS in the EU to prevent non-Safari browsers from adding PWA icon links to the home screen, making this feature exclusive to Safari (and granting Safari an anticompetitive advantage). Apple did not remove PWAs in Safari, but they removed the ability for PWAs to be displayed full-screen in Safari in the EU.