4 ms·
Sadly, you're not wrong as expecting a police officer to do anything with the footage is just a farcical notion. Which really makes me wonder what police were d
by dylan604 3y ago
Sadly, you're not wrong as expecting a police officer to do anything with the footage is just a farcical notion. Which really makes me wonder what police were doing when they were requesting footage from Ring directly. We've been told directly by detectives that they are too busy to look at emails with evidence. There must be some other purpose for them wanting the footage other than solving crimes. I just don't know what it is
- quatrefoil 3y agoSolving different crimes. The ones you might get a promotion or some other gratification out of. If you're in a city with 1,000+ home burglaries a year, nobody cares that you clear one and arrest some meth head. But, solve some gruesome or politically-tinged crime and you're holding a press conference and getting praise left and right. We do the same thing as software engineers. Every large company has some lore about what types of work get you promoted, and many engineers prefer to work on that.
- bluGill 3y agoWhat size is the city with 1000+ burglaries in a year? What is the value of the houses they target? If there are several million houses in the city than 1000 might be close enough to nothing to ignore. However if there are only 2000 houses in the city 1000 is half and enough to get attention - you bet the police care about solving at least some of them. Often the police know who the criminals in town are. However they lack evidence to prove anything. Thus a camera feed showing an already known criminal is enough to get their attention as while they might not care about you directly they criminal who hit you may have also hit a high importance target but they cannot prove it in court - thus convicting them of hitting you helps them for cases they cannot prove.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIf football players get robbed while on tv playing in a game, you or I have zero hope to prevent a burglary short of an armed guard or a few dogs.
- neuralRiot 3y ago> Solving different crimes. The ones you might get a promotion or some other gratification out of. Actually crime against persons (murder, assault, armed robbery) have higher priority than simple burglaries. Having your property taken away is infuriating but no one can argue that stoping a violent criminal is more important.
- quatrefoil 3y agoMaybe? First, a lot of simple assault arrests are for objectionable but ultimately trivial stuff - people getting into drunken brawls, spitting on each other, and so on. A series of burglaries targeting a local small business can be far more devastating to the owner than that. But your argument also doesn't hold because it's clear that there are property crimes that are investigated with zeal. For example, in the SF Bay Area, a person was recently charged with "hate crimes" for taking down some pro-Palestine signs. I'm not making some political point here, but we can agree that the investigation wasn't motivated by the severity of the crime, right?
- creer 3y agoThis is probably the answer. And so how can we exploit that to get OUR case worked on? Involve the journalists sounds like one. Message your city hall people might be another. Take to twitter? What else? Offer a reward (thus getting more response from all the rest - not to claim the reward but to blab about it) What else?
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoI'm always astonished when a cop shoots someone, the body camera video is released within a week. I was nearly killed by a bad driver and it took 5+ months to get the video and the driver was already processed by the kangaroo court.
- jibe 3y agoYour detective in your city on that day may have been too busy, but that’s just an anecdote, not a survey of the thousands of cities and police departments and their response to home burglary footage.
- skhunted 3y agoThe majority of murders go unsolved. The vast majority of rapes go unsolved. Police regularly don’t even spend the money to process DNA samples. I’m not an expert on this topic but it seems to me that the police in big cities largely don’t do their job.
- concordDance 3y agoThe problems you mention are extremely hard. Rape is s notoriously hard crime to prove and murders are either done in gang neighbourhoods where there sre few cameras and people don't talk to police. I don't know of any actually actionable improvement ideas to improve solve rate.
- skhunted 3y agoI believe your knowledge of how police actually work is at odds with the reality of the situation. Your reference to "either done in gang neighboourhoods.." indicates that at least as it pertains to the U.S. you are ill informed. Police juke stats and in a number of urban centers are effectively a legalized gang.
- dylan604 3y ago> Your detective in your city on that day you must of have read over the "detectives"--pural--part of that sentence. I have had a burglary in one home, and then a few years later had a home invasion where the person was very obviously identified to the police. The responding officers were able to look him up, have a positive witness ID made, and then see that this was a "bad guy". No arrest made.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aurornis 3y ago> Sadly, you're not wrong as expecting a police officer to do anything with the footage is just a farcical notion. Not true at all. Police love footage that provides anything useful when they have time to work on a case and, importantly, the footage is actually useful. A lot of DIY security camera installs provide useless footage: Cameras are mounted too high to catch faces, lighting is bad, license plates are blurry, and the list goes on. If you can actually catch faces, license plates, or anything else identifiable then it goes into the case. > We've been told directly by detectives that they are too busy to look at emails with evidence. That's a polite way of saying your case isn't a priority for them. Caseload is high and most departments have to filter and prioritize aggressively. Unfortunately, anything involving e-mail evidence gets messy very quickly because e-mails require legwork from specialists to verify and admit with a proper chain of evidence. Forwarding an e-mail to a police officer or sending them a screenshot of something might be useful as a hint in an active case, but it's not going to meet the bar for admissable evidence unless they can get more resources on it.
- whatshisface 3y agoThe first points make a lot of sense, but the email problem you raise is not a real issue - if they wanted a digital forensic chain of evidence, they could easily ask for the disks from the camera system.
- Aurornis 3y ago> but the email problem you raise is not a real issue - if they wanted a digital forensic chain of evidence, they could easily ask for the disks from the camera system. I was responding to the parent commenter's complaints that police wouldn't look at e-mails in some case (not related to video).
- whatshisface 3y agoThe police don't have any procedural rules against looking at emails, those rules are for juries.
- 3y ago